News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by andr on Monday August 27, 2012 @01:57PM (#4439948)
I'm really interested in what percent of Kickstarter projects end up abandoned, like Diaspora just was? Are there any statistics?
Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by citricsquid on Monday August 27, 2012 @02:41PM (#4440162)
Lots of them do and quite a few flounder in the "I'm working on it, sorry!" phase. I backed a project in early 2010 (A documentary) and the total raised was $15k, initial estimates were a few months. It's approaching 2 and a half years, the guy still updates monthly with "I'm editing this piece!" and "I did this" and sometimes he'll even include an excuse and apology!

I said it last year and I'll say it again now, Kickstarter is going to feel a serious backlash the first time one of the high profile projects falls apart because Kickstarter act like this big wonderful place for nurturing these projects and a lot of people seem to believe Kickstarter has some sort of interest in helping these projects succeed, but they don't, they are nothing more than a funding platform.

The problem is unavoidable I guess; give creative people lots of money, no guidance or supervision with only the moral obligation to actually do what they promised and inevitably quite a few will quit, change their idea or under deliver.

A common thing I've read on reddit is people believing that either Kickstarter makes the project creators accountable for not delivering or that the project creators don't get the money until they deliver... I wonder how a lot of people would react if they realised all they're paying for is a promise.

(oh and to clarify, I really do love Kickstarter and hope they continue to do what they're doing, but I can't help but disagree with their (potentially necessary) approach to projects after they've finished getting funded -- maybe they're working to solve this)

---

I backed a project in May 2011 called "MemeFactory Writes A Book", billed as a book about internet culture. The idea was cute and I wanted a t-shirt so I backed it with $100. Now a year and a third later they've "changed direction" because their original idea "wasn't what they thought it would be" so here I am with $100 in a project that is never going to happen and instead I'm waiting on a new project... they also still didn't deliver my t-shirt. http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/rugnetta/memefactory-wri...

Another project that I didn't back but I'm aware of is by a Youtube video creator called Bashurverse, the summary is: "Donate to us to go to a convention and we'll make a documentary", they got $4k and went to the convention... and apparently got the $4k scammed from them by an evil company... so now they've not delivered anything and the people that backed them are left with nothing and thinking "...oh". http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/bashcraft/bashcraft-the-...

Will kickstarter do anything? Nope. Do people know that? Nope, they think accountability exists. When I now back a kickstarter project it's "I guess this would be nice to have, I'll send some money and maybe I get it, if not then whatever." instead of "holy crap this is amazing, I'll stick in as much as I can I can't wait!" which is how it should be.

Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by flurpitude on Monday August 27, 2012 @05:20PM (#4440991)
Crowdsourced funding does have the advantage of spreading the risk among the crowd though. When I fund a Kickstarter project I know full well that these people might run off with the money or the project might fall flat, but I take the risk with a small amount of my own money - an amount I can afford to lose. I don't expect every project I fund, or even the majority of them, to succeed, but you pay to give them a chance, and you take on the risk knowingly. That seems to be the best way to see the deal.
Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by waterlesscloud on Monday August 27, 2012 @03:32PM (#4440409)
" Kickstarter is going to feel a serious backlash the first time one of the high profile projects falls apart"

Well, this is one of their high profile projects, and it's fallen apart.

It will be very interesting to see what happens from here.

Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by mibbitier on Tuesday August 28, 2012 @03:48AM (#4442593)
There will always be a certain number of suckers ready to pay their money for vapourware unfortunately.
Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by jrochkind1 on Monday August 27, 2012 @08:14PM (#4441504)
i suspect a bunch of high profile projects already HAVE fallen apart; they just haven't fallen apart in high profile ways. "Still working on it" messages gradually decreasing in frequency until everyone forgets.
Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by dusing on Monday August 27, 2012 @02:01PM (#4439964)
Well at least they stuck with it for 2 years, about as long as the money lasted.
Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by jeremyjh on Monday August 27, 2012 @02:22PM (#4440072)
Amazing if they actually made $200k last two years. I still can't believe people think this is a lot of money for a software project.
Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by smacktoward on Monday August 27, 2012 @02:45PM (#4440176)
They didn't -- the $200K ran out a year ago: http://www.readwriteweb.com/cloud/2011/10/the-state-of-diasp...
Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by stevencorona on Monday August 27, 2012 @02:24PM (#4440080)
Agreed. Four founders, that's $25k/year each for 2 years.
Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by PakG1 on Monday August 27, 2012 @02:48PM (#4440193)
Was labour the only cost? There must have been other costs also.
Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by jeremyjh on Monday August 27, 2012 @03:15PM (#4440310)
It would have been most of the cost. I believe they got free office space in an incubator. Heroku's spotlight page said they used 9 dynos, which would have been only a few hundred a month in hosting costs.
Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by MichaelStubbs on Monday August 27, 2012 @02:21PM (#4440062)
Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by whichdan on Monday August 27, 2012 @02:00PM (#4439956)
Kickstarter link[1] for the lazy. They raised $200k as of June 1st, 2010.

[1] http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/196017994/diaspora-the-p...

Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by shardling on Monday August 27, 2012 @02:04PM (#4439978)
Ok, apparently you read a different article than I did?

Because the implication of what I read was that the founders are still working Diaspora, but that they're preparing to make the project more community oriented.

Now, that could just be their way of spinning it. Are the founders leaving to work on other jobs? I don't know much of the background here -- does it have something to do with this makr.io thing?

Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by andr on Monday August 27, 2012 @02:18PM (#4440051)
They seem to have moved to http://makr.io. I think the fact the site greets you with a Facebook login button says enough about their belief in Diaspora.
Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by wrekkuh on Monday August 27, 2012 @04:08PM (#4440590)
I agree. On the surface of things i'm completely put off, but i haven't completely lost faith in these guys. I think they should make the alternative way of signing up ("The e-mail way," as they have it on the front page) an equally sized link as the Facebook option.

On the surface of things, the Diaspora team is crossing a line by sending e-mails about Makr.io to the people who were interested in Diaspora. I look at it as the two not being related at all, regardless of the reason they gave in the e-mail announcing makr to the people who expressed an interest in Diaspora -

"Existing social networks do not encourage their users to feel like they have the power to MAKE things on the internet. Rather they are just “capturing” the ephemeral social actions that define social networks today. With Makr, we are making creativity accessible to everyone, in the hopes it enables people to realize that what you post and create online is worth owning."

For me time will tell if this is genuine, or just the Diaspora team using their already existing mailing list to "capitalize" on an already established audience.

Re:Diaspora Will Now Be A Community Project by sp332 on Monday August 27, 2012 @02:10PM (#4440004)
The goal is to make this an entirely community-driven and community-run project. This part sounds like they're leaving.