News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by repsiace on Monday June 23, 2025 @01:52AM (#44352786)
I work daily in Cursor, producing around 200k lines of code per week, though only a small portion ends up being truly effective (still significantly more than what I could achieve on my own before). I think we need to adapt to these changes and focus on shaping better workflows to fully harness the potential of AI.
Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by mittensc on Monday June 23, 2025 @02:40AM (#44353060)
Why do you need yo write that much?

Is it all just throw away code to test out ideas?

Would libraries to help abstract stuff and you writing a few lines at a higher lever be better?

Since you throw away most of the code, could you design a bit before jumping to code and just develop something near desired solution?

Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by boothby on Monday June 23, 2025 @02:08AM (#44352873)
I've gotta ask. Who wants you to write that much code and why?
Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by repsiace on Monday June 23, 2025 @02:24AM (#44352979)
It's just one way of working. In reality, I only need a few thousand lines of effective code out of it. If I were to do it all on my own, it would likely take two to three times longer—perhaps with better or worse quality. While LLMs generate code incredibly fast, the full process of trial, error, and debugging takes more time. Additionally, since this involves multiple projects and contexts, a lot of junk code inevitably gets generated along the way.
Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by mittensc on Monday June 23, 2025 @02:52AM (#44353133)
> In reality, I only need a few thousand lines of effective code out of it. If I were to do it all on my own, it would likely take two to three times longer—perhaps with better or worse quality.

Have you tried doing it on your own as comparison?

Any lessons why that might be true?

Are you missing some design/brainstorming stage that you are doing now by iterating through junk code and which might not be necessary?

You might be right now, but you gain experience that you otherwise lose by delegating to the LLM. With experience the reverse might be true.

Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by joshstrange on Monday June 23, 2025 @06:39AM (#44354253)
That works out to 5K/hr (200k/5/8), that’s absurd verging on insane. It’s over a line of code a second.

I’d fire someone who was putting out that “code”.

Seriously, there is no way someone can review all that code so you must be solo (or at a place that doesn’t code review). If you aren’t reviewing your code then you are “vibe coding” (said with maximum derision) and what you are “building” is a house of cards.

Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by jf22 on Monday June 23, 2025 @09:50AM (#44355817)
The discussions about AI code always devolve into "derision" comments like this.

"You are a dumb vibe coder producing bad slop"

You don't know anything about the code, the project, the person, but feel justified to insult and demean.

Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by joshstrange on Monday June 23, 2025 @10:01AM (#44355908)
> 200k lines of code per week

Do you seriously think that someone can write/review/maintain that?

Either they are lying about the output or they _are_ creating slop, period.

Ridiculous comments like that should _not_ go unchallenged, I wouldn't want younger-me seeing that and thinking it was normal or a good idea.

Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by jf22 on Monday June 23, 2025 @10:05AM (#44355939)
Yes, I do.

You didn't challenge, you insulted.

You can ask how they ensure quality, what the review process is like, what QA is like, how do humans keep up with that pace of change, etc.

Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by joshstrange on Monday June 23, 2025 @10:40AM (#44356285)
>>> 200k lines of code per week

>> Do you seriously think that someone can write/review/maintain that?

> Yes, I do.

Then we have nothing more to discuss. If someone says "I can fly by flapping my arms" and I can absolutely say "That's absurd", I'm not going to respond with "What technique do you use? How can you do that?" because it's patently absurd. I'm not going to engage, I'm going to call out what is a lie or someone who has deluded themselves into thinking they are actually creating something of value.

Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by jf22 on Monday June 23, 2025 @12:14PM (#44357262)
Framing being productive with AI code gen as being similar to a physically impossible process is as bad faith as you can get.
Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by judahmeek on Tuesday June 24, 2025 @12:28PM (#44367927)
No, claims made without supporting evidence are as bad faith as it gets.

Claims regarding productivity gains would require long-term studies involving multiple metrics to be credible.

Until those exist, the benefits of AI code gen are basically as credible as MAHA pseudoscience.

Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by jf22 on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @10:28AM (#44377741)
>claims made without supporting evidence are as bad faith as it gets.

People are sharing their experiences. Every comment on the internet doesn't have to have scientific rigor behind.

I just want to point out you've insulted, made absurd comparisons, and now raised to goalposts to an impossible level. The cope about AI is real.

[dead]
Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by jf22 on Wednesday June 25, 2025 @10:29AM (#44377755)
I thought so too until I tried to learn AI tools.

I'm a mediocre dev but I'm at least 10x more productive with AI tooling.

Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by muzani on Monday June 23, 2025 @11:29PM (#44362637)
Anyone driving slower than me is an idiot and anyone driving faster than me is a maniac
Re:Ask HN: Using AI daily but not seeing productivity gains ... by repsiace on Monday June 23, 2025 @11:19AM (#44356699)
200k is just the number of lines of code generated, but effectively being merged is probably at the level of a few thousand lines, and I'm certainly responsible for its quality.