News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by bluedanieru on Saturday August 25, 2012 @01:35PM (#4432621)
I don't know who won but I know who lost. It's you. You who own a mobile phone. You lost.
Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by keithpeter on Saturday August 25, 2012 @01:56PM (#4432686)
It will be interesting to see what products are released outside the US and how those compare with products designed for the US market.

The losers might be those living in a saturated market governed by absurd patents and an uncertain legal process where billions can depend on the uninformed opinion of a small group of people who can choose to ignore the advice of a judge.

Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by bluedanieru on Saturday August 25, 2012 @01:59PM (#4432701)
I don't think the jury was really at fault, were they? They ruled that Samsung infringed on a few patents and they probably did. They infringed on patents that should never have been issued.
Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by drcube on Saturday August 25, 2012 @02:34PM (#4432789)
According to NPR yesterday, they also ruled on whether the infringed patents were valid. So yeah, that's the jury's fault.
Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by keithpeter on Saturday August 25, 2012 @02:14PM (#4432741)
"They infringed on patents that should never have been issued."

My point exactly.

Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by skue on Saturday August 25, 2012 @03:09PM (#4432885)
Do you really believe companies should have the freedom to clone successful products and flood the market with knock-offs?

Imagine if some up-and-coming auto maker started making cars that look exactly like (insert your favorite luxury brand here) - except it doesn't go as fast, the steering sucks, the upholstery has gaps, etc. And then imagine a bunch of consumers not only buying these cars, but naively insisting their car is actually better than that luxury brand they've never owned and ridiculing the owners of the luxury brand for being gullible fanbois for overpaying for "premium" quality that they don't (and probably can't) appreciate.

It's not that I'm a snob (I drive a rusty Subaru if you care), but I am glad we live in a place where good design and good engineering is valued and where companies unwilling to invest in design and R&D cannot simply steal the hard work of others.

Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by bornhuetter on Saturday August 25, 2012 @03:18PM (#4432925)
Samsung phones are not exact copies of iPhones. Not even close. Your argument is "not even wrong"
Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by drblast on Saturday August 25, 2012 @04:43PM (#4433222)
Why would anyone care that someone else has purchased a cheap knock off of something he owned?

Unless, of course, the only reason to own it is status.

But I'd hesitate to equate a Samsung smart phone with a knock off Louis Vitton handbag, for example.

I don't really understand the undying adoration of Apple. The tech industry has always been a fast moving, ultra-competitive industry where blatant ripping off of features is expected. If my competitor has a new feature that people like, you can bet the farm that everyone else will implement that same thing and try to leap frog the others in the process.

Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by jonhendry on Saturday August 25, 2012 @08:30PM (#4433881)
"Why would anyone care that someone else has purchased a cheap knock off of something he owned?"

It could lead the manufacturer of the original product to end support for it, or to even go out of business.

Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by Evbn on Saturday August 25, 2012 @11:57PM (#4434274)
That's a victory of the free market. Giving people what they want at a price they can afford, not overpriced luxury.
Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by grimboy on Saturday August 25, 2012 @01:41PM (#4432637)
Because of the chilling effect on design or because there are less and less handset manufacturers? Or another reason? Please don't vaguebook me.
Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by pfedor on Saturday August 25, 2012 @03:00PM (#4432866)
It could be bad news even for Apple users, since now Apple will increase the fraction of resources allocated to legal bullying (since it works) at the expense of making better phones.
Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by tedunangst on Saturday August 25, 2012 @05:17PM (#4433332)
I'm pretty sure Apple has enough cash to fund both the R&D and legal departments at 100%.
Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by bluedanieru on Saturday August 25, 2012 @01:44PM (#4432648)
The first one. Patent law has run amok to the point there really isn't any distinguishable difference between the trolls and the legitimate businesses any more. If you can patent pinch-and-zoom you can patent anything.
Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by jfb on Saturday August 25, 2012 @02:23PM (#4432758)
Say what you will about patent abuses, a firm that is utilizing their patents is qualitatively different than some shitballs in a two person office in Houston suing for damages of a patent vultured at some tech company's bankruptcy proceedings.
Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by Evbn on Saturday August 25, 2012 @11:59PM (#4434282)
Hey, they paid someone for those patents. Someone who would not have been paid anyway. Do the inventors not deserve compensation?

A windfall profits tax on transferred IP would be interesting, so IV and the like couldn't suck all the value out of the tech industry.

Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by jfb on Sunday August 26, 2012 @12:17AM (#4434313)
I think an "exercise or surrender" sort of clause would do wonders. Of course, the patent system is brutally complicated and rife with unintended consequences, so tinkering with it is pretty fraught. The world isn't a theorem to be proved, there's no right answer. We all have to learn to deal with ambiguity better.
Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by SG- on Saturday August 25, 2012 @01:59PM (#4432700)
Well this entire trial and damages awarded have to do with a long series of wilful copying on Samsung's part, not just pinch to zoom.
Re:Counterintuitive: Did Samsung emerge a winner? by luriel on Saturday August 25, 2012 @02:53PM (#4432841)
Just because Samsung perhaps did something morally or legally questionable it doesn't make the patent insanity any less insane.