News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Startup Stagnation by chime on Friday August 24, 2012 @06:14PM (#4429969)
I think there is an underlying assumption when VCs "invest in nothing" - the founder knows how to make a startup succeed, the actual product notwithstanding. The biggest risk in startups today is not the product, but the founders ability to succeed. The idea doesn't matter, the execution doesn't matter, the connections don't matter, even the near-term profits don't matter. What matters is if you can get a million people to use the product regularly. Risk(Founders who have done that once and have no product now) < Risk(First-time founders with a product).

This brings me to the biggest problem with startups that nobody seems to address and in fact, every successful/smart/talented/skilled person contributes towards it - every single startup is reinventing the wheel and that is inefficient. Step back and think about any given startup. They have to do all of the following: Setup accounting/legal/corporation, manage employees/payroll/benefits, perform data analysis/SEO/marketing, excel at PR/word-of-mouth, engage with users, encourage developers, design their brand, manage infrastructure (even AWS/Heroku accounts need pampering), source funding, present at tradeshows/industry-conferences, and tons of other boring things that you will see mentioned in expensive 20 page e-books and "X things you should do" lists. The worst part is that they have to this on top of making their product work in every environment: multiple browsers, mobile devices, app stores, online/offline modes, hi-res/lo-res graphics, hi/lo bandwidth, multiple languages/regions, and do all of that 24/7.

Why isn't all of the repeatable stuff outsourced in bulk, while still enabling the founders to develop the product and own equity? If you work for Google, you don't have to worry about any of this and just hack away on your code and let someone else market it and manage payroll. But you're trading away your high-equity/high-risk for a fixed salary/bonus. Why isn't there a median between coding at Google with no equity/risk and do-everything in your startup? Being an early hire at a startup doesn't cut it because it's high-risk/low-equity. Imagine if you could join YC and all you have to worry about is making a good product and someone else manages everything, while you still get to collect X% of your product sales. And if you feel YC isn't doing a good enough job, you can easily switch to XYZ and after a brief catch-up, they can take over everything. Certainly this happens already during acquisitions or switching vendors.

Why can't there be a one-stop-shop-startup-vendor who handles everything about running a startup? And why can't there be more of them so they can all compete for the best founders/products? I know I've simplified a lot of complex issues here but I think big ideas start with solving difficult problems. And running a startup isn't easy. Running 800 is near impossible. But it could happen.

Off-topic but related: I kept trying to clean my LCD thinking there were small spots on it. Turns out it is the site's background.

Re:Startup Stagnation by drumdance on Friday August 24, 2012 @09:33PM (#4430709)
This was basically the idea behind the round of incubators in the late 90s. My recollection is that they didn't work very well because they ended up being cost centers that the VCs had to manage. So they felt pressured to get as many of their companies enrolled and paying for the services as they could even if it was not in the company's best interest.

Usually the services were priced on a per-seat basis for something like $1-2k per month. It made sense for very small companies that had raised a few million, but once you hit 10-20 employees the math didn't work as well and so you had to either pay through the nose or scramble to find in-house replacements (not to mention office space). And if you were bootstrapped it was hard to justify the cost.

Re:Startup Stagnation by tryitnow on Friday August 24, 2012 @06:34PM (#4430026)
As startups become more common, we will be getting closer to this ideal. There's a company that basically allows you to outsource your COO function. I forget their name, but apparently Uber has used them and many other startups do as well.

Startup entrepreneurs are not compensated because of technical genius, they're compensated because they accomplished the very difficult task of combining some domain expertise (often software engineering in Silicon Valley style startups) with business acumen, including executing all the boring stuff you outlined (and executing often can mean just coordinating vendor services).

Re:Startup Stagnation by AndrewKemendo on Saturday August 25, 2012 @12:08AM (#4431081)
I was at a startup event just yesterday and talked to an aspiring VC about a plan he had to build an incubator of sorts for people to bring ideas to and he and his team would build the team, marketing, production, sales etc... around it and the "founder" would ostensibly run the company and direct the enterprise. So the "founder" only had to bring the idea - and the rest would be done. At the back end, the VC would get their share as all do and the company and founder would be on their way.

I have mixed feelings about this approach. On the one hand I think it would be very valuable to have a place where people with legitimately good solid ideas, but no experience could go and have them turn into something real. On the other hand ideas are dime a dozen and really mean nothing without execution - and it's in getting to execution that the product is actually worth anything. Learning all of that "stuff" is the core of what being an entrepreneur is about. Short circuiting that is a recipe for disaster in the long term where you have tons of one hit wonders - that barely get out of beta, or V1 and don't know how to use what they have built to build other things.

I think there is value in re-inventing the wheel in most cases because you'll notice, when you have to do that, it's the real smart folks who recognize how the wheel is broken along the way and seek to improve that while developing their original product. That's where the gold is.

Re:Startup Stagnation by jyu on Saturday August 25, 2012 @12:54AM (#4431167)
This approach fails when hard obstacles start presenting themselves. The founder is not bought into the idea so much that he/she cares to see it through. The VC sees it as 1 of a large portfolio of ideas. And if you look through the history of startup ideas, (as you've said) the execution helps bring the team unique insights to help with pivots.

I've seen this type of thing work inside companies though, where people work in an incubator like YC, except there are shared resources and the incubator is an umbrella company.

Re:Startup Stagnation by soup10 on Friday August 24, 2012 @06:50PM (#4430102)
A company of companies? Sounds reasonable, but I think our legal/tax system isn't really designed for that so the accounting/legal issues could get hairy.

Typical startups contract out most of the stuff you mentioned. Which amounts to the same thing, although it's not as efficient as having a trusted competent department in-house.

Essentially incubators and VC's are a way to lower the risk for startups. You trade equity in return for capital/guidance/connections/and a better chance of a soft-landing if you fail.

Re:Startup Stagnation by michaelochurch on Friday August 24, 2012 @07:32PM (#4430332)
I can vouch for VCs investing in nothing. I can name at least three people not 1/100 as talented as I am who've raised funding in the double- and triple-digit millions. One I recently had the misfortune of working for.

I don't know if watching idiots have enormous success should be taken as encouraging (if they can do it, so can I) or discouraging (in the what-the-shitz-is-going-on sense) but, whatever man. I've definitely seen some fucked-out morons get funding, and not a small number.

Re:Startup Stagnation by jfarmer on Friday August 24, 2012 @08:36PM (#4430568)
It's not about how talented you are, per se. It's about how talented you appear to other people (VCs, in this case).

The best way to demonstrate that talent is to start your own company and make it wildly successful. Until then, the risk of investing in you will be greater than the risk of investing in someone else who has done that, regardless of your respective talent levels.

I've worked for people whose biggest talent was convincing other people they're talented. It sucks, but take that as a lesson in what talents you might be lacking rather than dismissing potential investors as "idiots."

Re:Startup Stagnation by michaelochurch on Friday August 24, 2012 @08:49PM (#4430605)
Of the 3 morons who come to mind as morons who raised money, one did so circa 2000 when it was easy and another one managed to tweak someone into acq-hiring his first startup as a charity (and thus secure funding for his next act). The third is from a prominent family and got funded on connections and nothing else.

It's depressing to watch people like that get funding. I have no faith that any of these king-makers really have much sense. No idea if I could do their jobs better, because it may be that sizing people up is just an unsolvable problem that we've tricked ourselves into believing we can hack (i.e. fooled by randomness) but I know I wouldn't be worse.

Re:Startup Stagnation by jfarmer on Saturday August 25, 2012 @04:27PM (#4433177)
Then prove it by starting a successful company.
Re:Startup Stagnation by adgar on Friday August 24, 2012 @06:32PM (#4430022)
> Why isn't all of the repeatable stuff outsourced in bulk, while still enabling the founders to develop the product and own equity?

Because then it would be painfully clear how little value the products bring.