News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Build Conscious Machines by root_axis on Sunday June 15, 2025 @12:46PM (#44283313)
> Nobody is ‘declaring’ any such thing

Yes, they are.

> The claim is that phenomenal consciousness is fundamentally functional, making the existence of philosophical zombies (entities that behave like conscious beings but lack subjective experience) impossible.

They're explicitly defining the hard problem out of existence.

> I loathe this kind of lazy pejorative attack accusing someone of asserting

Take it easy. Nothing I wrote here is a "pejorative attack", I'm directly addressing what was written by the OP.

Re:How to Build Conscious Machines by simonh on Wednesday June 18, 2025 @10:17AM (#44310126)
>They're explicitly defining the hard problem out of existence.

A claim is just an opinion, it's not a 'definition' or 'declaration'. That's absurd hyperbole. If I say personally I don't think the hard problem is an obstacle for physicalism, I'm not defining anything.

Let's see what the author says in his introduction to the paper. "Take this with a grain of salt". Hardly the definitive declaration you're railing against.