News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chinese dev steals US HTML5 Game engine, US hosts won't c... by analyst74 on Friday August 24, 2012 @11:19AM (#4427968)
This is very interesting.

Genuine question: how is pirating PC games, songs and movies acceptable while pirating apps is not?

Edit: this is not a question toward parent, but rather the general public, as I kind of get the sense that pirating is somewhat acceptable under certain circumstances while not others. Where is the line?

Re:Chinese dev steals US HTML5 Game engine, US hosts won't c... by rodly on Friday August 24, 2012 @11:24AM (#4427988)
Where did he say pirating anything was okay?
Re:Chinese dev steals US HTML5 Game engine, US hosts won't c... by chimi on Friday August 24, 2012 @01:15PM (#4428512)
It is funny how if it's copying a developers HTML5 game, it's stealing, but if it's a movie or song, well... that's just copying, because the creator still has a copy -- that's not stealing.

The level of hypocrisy around here is incredible. The only occurrence of the text string "not stealing" in this whole tread is in my post right here.

Re:Chinese dev steals US HTML5 Game engine, US hosts won't c... by lindenr on Friday August 24, 2012 @02:23PM (#4428894)
You didn't answer the question. No-one ever said pirating was okay (or "not stealing").

Also, I think you're wrong: pirating a movie/book/whatever will at most result in the price of one movie/book being lost from the creators (given that I may or may not have bought it legally otherwise). Copying an app, on the other hand, can result in a (theoretically) unlimited number of apps being purchased where the money doesn't go to the original creators. That is more like ripping a dvd and posting it to a torrent site.

I'm not saying pirating is defensible, but downloading something illegally is far less harmful than copying someone's app.

Re:Chinese dev steals US HTML5 Game engine, US hosts won't c... by simonbrown on Saturday August 25, 2012 @04:08PM (#4433114)
What about posting movies/books/whatever to trackers in the first place?
Re:Chinese dev steals US HTML5 Game engine, US hosts won't c... by betterth on Friday August 24, 2012 @03:44PM (#4429277)
Comparing theft of a product with the intent of resale to theft of a product with the intent of personal consumption is disingenuous.

Stealing something to resell it for a profit is rightly a much worse transgression than stealing it for personal use, as you're only denying a single potential sale (your own) as opposed to actually stealing multiple REAL sales and keeping all the profit.

Re:Chinese dev steals US HTML5 Game engine, US hosts won't c... by chimi on Friday August 24, 2012 @05:31PM (#4429792)
"... than stealing it for personal use ..."

As long as both instances are stealing, I have no problem. Relative badness is another debate, but I doubt we'd disagree much on that.

Re:Chinese dev steals US HTML5 Game engine, US hosts won't c... by Dylan16807 on Saturday August 25, 2012 @04:27AM (#4431466)
It's not hard to argue that only the one that involves money is theft.

Not that that argument is exactly where I would stand, but I think you're on shaky ground to call them the same crime with the difference being magnitude.

Re:Chinese dev steals US HTML5 Game engine, US hosts won't c... by lelandbatey on Friday August 24, 2012 @03:49PM (#4429305)
Plagiarism, where you take another's ideas or work and pass them off as your own is a different act than stealing (or copying) something for your own enjoyment. Neither are acceptable, either morally or legally, but there is a difference between the two.

As well, you are acting as though this thread of conversation is trying to justify one while demonizing the other. No one has made any kind of statement at all justifying copyright infringement. I don't understand your accusation in the context of this thread.

Re:Chinese dev steals US HTML5 Game engine, US hosts won't c... by ftwinnovations on Friday August 24, 2012 @03:13PM (#4429138)
I'm not sure if I gave the impression that I think pirating games, songs, or movies is acceptable to me but it is certainly not. I have paid for every song I own, every movie I've watched, and every game I've played. No exceptions.
Re:Chinese dev steals US HTML5 Game engine, US hosts won't c... by TazeTSchnitzel on Friday August 24, 2012 @11:52AM (#4428138)
Well, certainly some people are solely motivated by it being free, and don't care it's illegal. Not everyone thinks into it as much as people on HN do.