News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Marines mobilized in response to LA protests by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @04:04AM (#44233962)
> Foreign nationals waving flag of their nation, attacking citizens and being in country without permission. Smells like invasion

But is not. Invasions are military offensives involving combatants of a geopolitical entity [1].

If this is an invasion, every rally in which a Confederate flag is waived is a rebellion. Also, ยง 4 concludes with "and on Application of the Legislature, or of the Executive (when the Legislature cannot be convened) against domestic Violence." The Constitution is very clear about the scope of executive military power within the United States because they weren't illiterate and knew how Rome's republics fell [2].

Hell, even when Hamilton argued for federal control of militias, he underscored that its risk "to the liberties of the people" was mitigated by the fact that the states "have the SOLE AND EXCLUSIVE APPOINTMENT OF THE OFFICERS," emphasis his [3].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invasion

[2] https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed70.asp

[3] https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed29.asp

Re:Marines mobilized in response to LA protests by spaceman_2020 on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @04:16AM (#44234031)
If waving a foreign flag is an invasion, boy America is going to have a lot of invasions when it co-hosts the football world cup next year
Re:Marines mobilized in response to LA protests by TiredOfLife on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @04:18AM (#44234044)
If they are in country illegally and are throwing rocks and attacking people then yes
Re:Marines mobilized in response to LA protests by spaceman_2020 on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @04:41AM (#44234176)
I don't know if you've ever been to a football world cup, but throwing rocks and attacking people usually ends up being the norm

and God forbid if the English team crashes out early...or worse, ends up winning.

Re:Marines mobilized in response to LA protests by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @04:30AM (#44234119)
> If they are in country illegally and are throwing rocks and attacking people then yes

For sake of argument, let's grant this.

"A first-time illegal entry is a federal misdemeanor, punishable by a fine of up to $250 and a maximum jail sentence of six months" [1]. Assaulting a federal police officer carries a maximum jail sentence of 5 [2] to ten years [3].

The first category, petty misdemeanors, includes things like DUIs, cyberbullying and vandalism [4]. It also, conveniently, doesn't require a jury trial [5]. Based on your standard, if a tourist is caught driving under the influence, or is suspected of cyberbullying or vandalism, it triggers the threshold upon which, if any violence of any kind is suspected in their vicinity, troops can be deployed against American citizens. (And then they get no jury trial.) Because I will love to see that precedent explored the next time the far right whips up an election-denial conspiracy.

[1] https://legalclarity.org/18-u-s-c-1325-illegal-entry-and-its...

[2] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/111

[3] https://medvinlaw.com/federal-assault-on-law-enforcement-pen...

[4] https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/classes-of-mi...

[5] https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution-conan/amendment-6/p...

[dead]
Re:Marines mobilized in response to LA protests by reverius42 on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @06:13AM (#44234869)
There are no invaders attacking myself.

There are no invaders attacking my family.

My people is all of humanity and I don't believe any race or nationality should be favored over or considered better than another. There are no (space) alien invaders attacking my people.

My territory is this Spaceship Earth, a speck of dust in a giant uncaring universe, and I share it with all known life in the universe. There is no other life known, and therefore no invaders.

I do have children. I do love my family. I did have a stable, happy childhood. My ethnicity is extremely irrelevant and I'm offended you'd ask.

Re:Marines mobilized in response to LA protests by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @05:34AM (#44234573)
> What makes someone like you so eager to defend the "invaders"?

I'm not particularly incensed about illegal immigration either way. I think ICE could be more humane. But they're ultimately executing the nation's laws.

What Trump is doing with California's National Guard and the Marines is orthogonal to what he's using to justify it. (The Marines aren't arresting illegal immigrants. They've been deployed against protesters. Mostly Americans.)

To the extent I believe there is a risk from illegal immigrants, it's principally in the risk from cartel violence leaking into America. These sort of theatrics undermine that law-enforcement prerogative by focussing on quantity [1] over quality.

> My instinct is to annihilate them in defence of myself, my family, my people, and our territory

I'm much more concerned about someone with those instincts than I am about nonviolent people. (As would have been our founders.)

[1] https://www.axios.com/2025/05/28/immigration-ice-deportation...

Re:Marines mobilized in response to LA protests by TiredOfLife on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @04:17AM (#44234038)
> domestic Violence.

but people who are in country illegally are not domestic.

Re:Marines mobilized in response to LA protests by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @04:22AM (#44234062)
> people who are in country illegally are not domestic

"The Clause uses the term 'domestic violence' in the now-archaic sense of '[i]nsurrection or unlawful force fomented from within a country,โ€ and not the modern usage meaning violence between romantic partners or within a household" [1][2].

[1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution-conan/article-4/sec...

[2] https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed21.asp

Re:Marines mobilized in response to LA protests by thaumasiotes on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @05:09AM (#44234370)
What is your response supposed to show? You appear to be agreeing with your parent comment.

Is the fact that someone is present in the country illegally more likely to be presented as evidence that that person doesn't count as a source of insurrection "from within the country", or as evidence that the person isn't beating his wife?

Re:Marines mobilized in response to LA protests by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @05:38AM (#44234609)
> What is your response supposed to show?

The point is domestic isn't qualifying violence, it's referring to a particular category of threat.

> the fact that someone is present in the country illegally

Illegal immigrants aren't "from within [the] country."

The people who are from within the United States are protesting. Mostly peacefully. They're the ones the Marines are being deployed against.

Re:Marines mobilized in response to LA protests by thaumasiotes on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @05:41AM (#44234632)
> The point is domestic isn't qualifying violence, it's referring to a particular category of threat.

But that is the way TiredOfLife presented it. He says that people who are illegally present don't fall into that category. You respond that he shouldn't be talking about wife beaters. Where did that come from?

(Also, of course, "domestic" is qualifying "violence". It's just doing it in Merriam-Webster's sense 2 rather than sense 3.)

Re:Marines mobilized in response to LA protests by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 10, 2025 @06:04AM (#44234803)
> He says that people who are illegally present don't fall into that category

The term domestic violence cannot be decomposed into domestic and violence. It's a term of art referring to "[i]nsurrection or unlawful force fomented from within a country."

> of course, "domestic" is qualifying "violence"

No, it's not. It would be like arguing that a law that talks about the United States of America doesn't apply if the states aren't united at the time of its application. (It's even stupider, since this is not only a term of art, but an archaic one as well. Decomposing it is akin to using the modern definition for domestic violence to interpret that text.)