No, we really aren’t. Let me know when any of those systems can get me from Souix falls South Dakota to Thunder Bay Ontario without multiple disengagements and we can talk.
Based on what I’ve seen we’re still about 10 years away best case scenario and more likely 20+ assuming society doesn’t collapse first.
I think people in the Bay Area commenting on how well self driving works need to visit middle America and find out just how bad and dangerous it still is…
> I feel (hah!) that we've reached a point where instead of focusing on objective things that the LLM-based systems can do, we are wasting energy and "ink" on how they make us feel.
> best to focus on objective things that the systems can do today, with maybe a look forward so we can prepare for things they'll be able to do "tomorrow".
These two together.. Reminds me of this type of sentiment that seems somewhat common here: 'I feel that AI is growing exponentially, therefore we should stop learning to code - because AI will start writing all code soon!'
I think this points to where a lot of skepticism comes from. From the perspective of: the AI barely does a fraction of what is claimed, has grown even less a fraction of what is claimed, yet these 'feelings' that AI will change everything is driving tons of false predictions. IMO, those feelings are driving VC money to damn MBAs that are plastering AI on everything because they are chasing money.
There is an irony here though too, skepticism simply is a lack of belief without evidence. Belief without evidence is irrational. The skeptics are the ones simply asking for evidence, not feelings.
As with a lot of issues in today's world, each side is talking past the other. It can simultaneously be true that LLMs make writing code less enjoyable / gratifying, and that LLMs can speed up our work.
IMO it's best to focus on objective things that the systems can do today, with maybe a look forward so we can prepare for things they'll be able to do "tomorrow". The rest is too noisy for me. I'm OK with some skepticism, but not outright denial. You can't take an unbiased look at what these things can do today and say "well, yes, but can they do x y z"? That's literally moving the goalposts, and I find it extremely counter productive.
In a way I see a parallel to the self driving cars discussions of 5 years ago. Lots of very smart people were focusing on silly things like "they have to solve the trolley problem in 0.0001 ms before we can allow them on our roads", instead of "let's see if they can drive from point A to point B first". We are now at the point where they can do that, somewhat reliably, with some degree of variability between solutions (waymos, teslas, mercedes, etc). All that talk 5 years ago was useless, IMO.