News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou... by DanielBMarkham on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @12:57PM (#441977)
I think this is the wrong question.

Fake praise does a lot more damage than mean-spirited criticism. Because fake praise has nothing but well-meaning behind it, while mean-spirited criticism can actually point out things that need fixing. In addition, fake praise can mask a lot of flaws that should be fixed.

I'm of the mind that the more mean criticism you get the better off you probably are -- people at least took time to rag on you. Apathy is what really sucks.

Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou... by pg on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @01:18PM (#442004)
Fake praise does a lot more damage than mean-spirited criticism.

I don't think that's true. Bogus praise is self-correcting in a way that bogus criticism isn't. If bogus praise gives you an unduly high opinion of yourself, you at least keep working, and the resistance of the medium may push your opinion of yourself back down to where it should be. Whereas harsh critism can discourage you from working, so you never get the successes that would have corrected your opinion of yourself.

Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou... by yan on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @02:03PM (#442085)
Can't it be said that undue praise will make the author work less hard, having achieved the dopamine high of accomplishment? Where as criticism can spur harder work from people set out to "prove themselves." I'm not saying either way is good or bad, I'm just saying both of our examples are anecdotal and either can have the desire effect. All depends on the criticism and the outlook and personality of the recipient.
Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou... by DanielBMarkham on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @06:28PM (#442439)
It's not the opinion of yourself, it's the honest appraisal of whether your current efforts are worthwhile.

There are some that will tell you that you are doing a great job without thinking critically through whether you should be doing what you're doing.

I think the distinction here is whether you take the praise or criticism personally or just as a reflection on your current effort. If it's meant personally then sure, it's kind of hard to have too much praise.

Re:Ask HN : What's the meanest thing that has been said abou... by dan_sim on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @01:07PM (#441989)
That was the case here : http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=441797

When I started the thread, I didn't want to say that criticism is bad or should be avoided. I just wanted to have fun at what people are saying about startups.