But also, no - Just self-host or it's all your fault is never ever a sufficient answer to the problem.
It's exactly the same as when Exxon says "what are you doing to lower your own carbon footprint?" It's shifting the burden unfairly; companies like OpenAI put themselves out there and thus must ALWAYS be held to task.
If you send your neighbour nudes then they have your nudes. You can put in as many contracts as you want, maybe they never digitised it but their friend is over for a drink and walks out of the door with the shoebox of film. Do not pass GO, do not collect.
Conceivably we can try to control things like e.g. is your cellphone microphone on at all times, but once someone else, particularly an arbitrary entity (e.g. not a trusted family member or something) has the data, it is silly to treat it as anything other than gone.
I wish it was different and I agree that there’s a massive accountability hole with… who could it be?
Pragmatically it is what it is, self host and hope for bigger picture change.
You lose your rights to privacy in your papers without a warrant once you hand data off to a third party. Nothing in this ruling is new.
Otherwise, you are picking your data privacy champions as the exact same companies, people and investors that sold us social media, and did something quite untoward with the data they got. Fool me twice, fool me three times… where is the line?
In other words - OAI has to save logs now? Candidly they probably were already, or it’s foolish not to assume that.