There may be a pattern here. Perhaps the pattern is that these statements are emptily true: they're either truisms if taken literally, or miss the point otherwise. It may be the latter disconnect with reality gives the commenter the impression that they have discovered some new insight that needs to be mentioned. I.e. a truism that was also true when applied to the world would clearly be something that everyone else also believed, and thus wouldn't be worth mentioning.
I agree that the comment has become very boring. It is especially annoying to see it injected into conversations that don't really involve VC funding.
As with medals, how much it matters depends on who was impressed with you and for what. Later rounds converge on measuring revenue, which is what people who think companies shouldn't be celebrating fundraising usually think they should be celebrating instead.
As usual, even when the conventional wisdom of HN is on to something, it's for the wrong reasons and rapidly reaches the wrong conclusions.
A funding round, as I understand it, is financing to enable a certain goal. I don't knock companies that seek funding, and I would congratulate any that received it IF that is something that they deemed necessary. I think this notion that it is an "achievement of sort" is the type of thinking that elicits these types of repetitive comments that remind people, an investment round is awarded to make possible a goal by increasing its access to resources.
I think you're missing the distinction between the symbol and the act. A medal is not what you are seeking to win. Its a representation of what you have achieved (which seems to be pg's point). You can take away all of Michael Phelps medals and it won't in one way diminish the fact that 18 times he was the fastest guy in the pool at the Olympics.
Conversely if I fund you, does that in any way validate your product? Nope. Paying customers do that I'm afraid.
To suggest that a round of funding is an achievement in and of itself is to put it in the same camp as winning a business plan competition. Sure it might show that One person likes your idea, but that's pretty much worthless compared to paying customers.
Like I said originally; I'm happy for anyone who gets funding to pursue their project. Great for them. But it doesn't affect me at all, especially since so many of them are so early in their development they don't have anything to talk about it. It's just a waste of anyone's time who's not involved.
It seems to me that raising a large VC round does have an intrinsic and lasting value, I'm not sure whether it should. Kevin Rose is a great example of this type of success. He's started 4 or 5 companies that I'm aware of, out of those AFAIK Revision3 is the only one that I believe had an exit based on the merits of the company (Milk, was a successful exit but seemed like an acqui-hire).
We also continually get messaged that having founded a company once even if it fails is going to be a leg up when raising money for your next venture.
Anyway its hard to say "raising money" doesn't have intrinsic value, when Silicon Valley (and I don't mean "startup culture" I mean the players actually doing deals in SV) continually signals that it does.
Second; at no point did I think it was a novel complaint. I'm well aware that it's an opinion that is both widely held and has been previously stated.
But that doesn't mean it doesn't need to be restated. Because the reality is that content-free blurbs about funding rounds continually get posted, upvoted, reprinted, etc. all over the tech industry as though they mean anything to anyone who is not directly involved in the operations of the company in question.
This should be called out as the meaningless crap that it is, and it should be replaced by actual content.
Meanwhile it seems to have eluded you that the whole point of this thread is that your original comment was meaningless crap devoid of any actual content.
But hey, it's cool if you wanna be really wrong.
We invent a "startup culture" archetype (and strawman) to which to ascribe things that no one actually believes and are easy to disagree with. We then disagree with it. And then we, and everyone who upvotes us, feels like clear-thinking contrarians for pointing out the obvious flaws that lots of people (read: no one) believe.
Because that's obviously not true based on the fact that they get posted and upvoted regularly.
Yeah nobody might be out there going "Geez I'd love to see more stories about VC funding.", but people are reprinting them and upvoting them. And that's the behavior I was saying should stop.
But is it worthy of being industry wide news? Most of the time, no. Most of these press releases contain no actual information that would be of interest to anyone who's life is not directly affected by that money.
That's my point. Sure, tell all your friends. Post on Facebook and Twitter. Great!
Hell even send out a press release. But industry news sources should not be reprinting these press releases, and we should not be upvoting them, unless they have actual content beyond "Hey these guys got some money to pursue their project."
Most startups would prefer to talk about their product, but that's a much harder sell as news.
I think people would read that if there were more of it, though. People on HN do vote up even fairly cursory product-focused articles when they appear, e.g. a blog post doing a comparison of Heroku and a competitor. I see the funding-related stories as more just a least-effort excuse to talk about a startup: someone (usually TechCrunch) doesn't really have the time to spare doing a proper product review, but throws out a little blurb about funding, and opens up the floor for discussion about the startup. That then gets voted up on HN because people are curious and want to discuss it, and the TC blurb presents an opportunity to do so, even if it isn't itself that compelling as an article.
Now if TC gets the same hits from those low-effort articles, why would they put in Consumer Reports style work doing more in-depth product-focused reporting? I would guess there's little monetary justification for doing so, unfortunately.
News places will reprint anything that will get views, and people will click through on anything sensational. So is that a valid excuse for engaging in GoDaddy-ish behavior?
No. You have to take responsibility for what you choose to do.
If you choose to release press releases purely about your VC funding round instead of talking about your product; that's your choice, nobody else's.
And if you talk about your product and nobody is interested in it; you should take that as a sign.
I don't care if some people think my funding announcement less valid than other industry news, or somehow "less earned." The fact that there is a market for that kind of news means that enough people derive value from it. Not all news is valuable to all people: celebrity news and financial news have two very different audiences. If an investor is accidentally exposed to celebrity news at the grocery store checkout line, is it the fault of the celebrity?
Press releases about funding don't reveal a lack of moral fibre or dubious ethics. They just reveal that the organisation is savvy enough to do something that works (een if it is pointless).
It's great that you're funded, but that has nothing to do with me, nor is it evidence that you are ever going to accomplish anything worthwhile, IMHO. It just means you convinced someone with money that you're going to put their money to good use. Their confidence means nothing to me.