News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by throw8393949 on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @01:20AM (#44166576)
> net negative to the total population, without developer questioning their role in it.

I am tired of people blaming bottom developers, while CEOs get millions for "the burden of responsibility".

Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by honestthrow1 on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @01:34AM (#44166676)
I'm not blindly blaming the bottom developer. I've played my role in past waves as well as many other developers. I'm not a CEO, so I don't know how to communicate this same message to a CEO. But as a developer, I know I've been an ignorant participant in the past. Willfully or not. And I can change my role in the next coming wave.

We developers are not blameless. If we accept that we are playing a role; then we can be proactive in preventing this and influencing the direction things go. CEOs need developers to achieve what they want.

I'm not saying it's easy. I won't even hold it against folks that decide to go in a separate direction than mine. But I at least hope we can be open about the impact we each have; and that we are not powerless here.

Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by throw8393949 on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @01:47AM (#44166760)
But developers are blameless! CEOs are paid millions because they get all the responsibility! Some companies even have "ethics" officers and entire departments!
Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by noam_k on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @02:14AM (#44166902)
This sounds like the "only following orders" argument.

_If_ developers _collectively_ were to quit jobs that don't line up with their morals and ethics, we _might_ see a change. I'm not saying this is an easy decision to make, and I definitely don't want to judge someone who decides to take a higher paying job, but there's potential here to shift the direction AI is taking.

Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by Imustaskforhelp on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @02:25AM (#44166978)
Have you seen the job market recently.

I mean, I do agree with the only following orders part. But I guess we humans are nuanced. We aren't logical but emotional beings.

You are saying its not easy to leave a job? That's so understating it

Imagine a family where the father has to worry that food might not be on their young daughter's table because he was 'logical', I guess, I don't want to be logical in such scenario where my loved ones suffer because of some greater good which might not even get to fruition anyway. (Stopping ai, in my pessimistic point of view, it won't)

Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by chgs on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @06:03AM (#44168243)
Perhaps the union could take a stand.
Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by gtsop on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @01:36AM (#44166687)
Yes CEOs are to blame, but blaming them isn't gonna do anything. They won't change. Who has the motivation and capacity to change things? The working people. Who isn't currently doing it? The working people. So it seems appropriate for me to raise this fact as a problem, the fact that the working people silently go along with all the evil plans ceos put in place
Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by throw8393949 on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @01:41AM (#44166724)
Working people have no capacity to do this! They already pay taxes preciselly for this purpose! We have an army of law enforcement and regulators!

DEI is a billion dollar industry. With bad scores company wont get loans and contracts. Maybe make a respect of privacy part of DEI scores!

Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by 9rx on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @02:54AM (#44167168)
> They already pay taxes preciselly for this purpose!

That gets you employees, but if you've ever hired employees in a private business before you'll know that you have to carefully babysit them or they'll go off and do their own thing. The employees you hire for government are not a different type of creature. The same applies there. Even where there is genuine care to serve your interests as their employer, it is impossible for them to be mind readers. As their employer, your active engagement is an imperative. If you don't literally sit down with them on a regular basis and discuss what needs to be done, you're going to get poor results.

Which is what the parent comment is asserting: That the working people are not acting as the employer. Maybe you're right that the working people don't have the capacity to be the boss, but then what are they arbitrarily hiring employees for?

Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by gtsop on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @01:45AM (#44166746)
Organized working people have the capacity to change everything. That's my opinion at least
Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by throw8393949 on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @01:50AM (#44166784)
Like when Hollywood writers were starving, because some union leader was doing their little revolution thing?

I lived in a country ruled by "organized working people". They were not even capable of producing female hygiene products!

Re:My AI skeptic friends are all nuts by foobarchu on Tuesday June 03, 2025 @02:12AM (#44166897)
> DEI is a billion dollar industry. With bad scores company wont get loans and contracts.

Respectfully, do you exist on 2023? This hasn't been true in the US (where the majority of HN lives) since Trump took office.