> so why does it feel different when LLM ingests ...
Most-ish people are biased in favor of both "the little guy", and in favor of "artists" (whether authors, musicians, painters, or whatever).
Re:Bohemians at the Gate?
by jazzyjackson on Monday June 02, 2025 @12:27PM
(#44160463)
Because an LLM is not an artist, an artist is working to improve themselves and putting something new into the world that aligns with some desire or vision they have.
The LLM lacks all desire and vision, it is a machine that can produce a trillion variations of something that sounds like Miles Davis, for example, without an ounce of intention to what it wants to do, what art it wants to make.
Fundamentally the LLM is not a living thing that interacts with other living things and has an idea of how it wants to influence itself and others. it is just a printing press capable of flooding the marketplace with lookalikes and slop.
[Despite my tone, I appreciate the prompt, it's a subject I'd like to write on at more length than an HN comment]
so why does it feel different when LLM ingests some music to "fundamentally shape how it 'thinks' of the artform"?
i can create loads of speculation about what that difference is, but to be honest it all feels pretty post-hoc and hand-wavy.