Re:Cinematography of "Andor"
by hackyhacky on Sunday June 01, 2025 @02:34PM
(#44152850)
> a kiss at the sunset
They don't kiss.
And that's not a sunset.
You know exactly what I mean. It couldn't have been more predictable, cheezy and cliched if it was and actual kiss at the sunset
Re:Cinematography of "Andor"
by hackyhacky on Sunday June 01, 2025 @03:52PM
(#44153357)
I know what you mean and I completely disagree. It's a subversion a standard trope. Moreover, the fraternal relationship between the two leads is a reference to Andor's arc in Andor. It's an ending about sacrifice that wouldn't make sense in any other context.
> It's a subversion a standard trope.
There's nothing subversive.
> It's an ending about sacrifice that wouldn't make sense in any other context.
There are a million ways to make an ending about sacrifice. Rogue One chose the worst one, after a lot of other ridiculous choices
10-20 minutes of static talking heads, 5 minutes of mediocre action. Repeat until the end. Meaningless side-quests. The final is a thousand cliches one after another culminating in a "main computer at the end of a rickety walkway" and "a kiss at the sunset".
The only reason it's hailed as the greatest movie ever is because so much of the Star Wars is just objectively shit.