News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI is not our future – Procreate by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:14AM (#44137040)
"I want a good image search engine + database."

One coulld hire a software developer to write such a program. But, in general, software developers can be untrustworthy and prone to stealing ideas for their own selfish purposes.

Before Mark Zuckerberg dropped out of college, he answered a classified ad from someone in the real world^1 who wanted to create a website that could search a database of images. Nothing to do with "social media". IIRC the target market was the auto insurance industry (I could be wrong).

1. Not Winklevoss brothers. That is another story.

Zuckerberg never finished the job but he did create his own website which executed searches and served up images of students at Harvard. He was of course sued by this person after Facebook became popular.

The point is that "generative AI" is not something that computer users are asking for, but it certainly is something that relies on stealing from others. To initially "launch" Facemash/Facebook, Zuckerberg never asked for permission to use others' photos.

It stands to reason the primary value of "generative AI" is not the work of computer programmers, it is the work of the authors. phtotgraphers, etc. responsible for the copyrighted content being ingested, generally without permission, for machine learning,.

The methods of machine learning certainly have some value, but arguably the value of "generative AI" does not supercede the value of copyrighted work. Standing alone, without the use of copyrighted works, these methods have minimal value. The same as any other free software we use.

Re:AI is not our future – Procreate by cwsx on Friday May 30, 2025 @11:32AM (#44137219)
> One coulld hire a software developer to write such a program. But, in general, software developers can be untrustworthy and prone to stealing ideas for their own selfish purposes.

Ehhhh? Yes there are examples of that, as there are for any arbitrary group of humans you could select, but [anecdotally] I've noticed the opposite... it's not uncommon to find a passionate developer that's only interested in the challenge/problem solving aspect - it's a lot less common for say.. real estate agents.

I don't really get the point you're making beyond "people be greedy sometimes" (which I do agree with, don't get me wrong).

Re:AI is not our future – Procreate by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Friday May 30, 2025 @03:58PM (#44139432)
Perhaps it is not a coincidence that so many software developers commenting online seem to have an extreme dislike for intellectual property. It interferes with the stealing and copying they practice to compensate for their won lack of creativity. For example so-called "Big Tech" companies that do not produce any content despite billion of dollars at their disposal; instead they copy and store other peoples' work, so-called "user-generated content" (UGC).