One coulld hire a software developer to write such a program. But, in general, software developers can be untrustworthy and prone to stealing ideas for their own selfish purposes.
Before Mark Zuckerberg dropped out of college, he answered a classified ad from someone in the real world^1 who wanted to create a website that could search a database of images. Nothing to do with "social media". IIRC the target market was the auto insurance industry (I could be wrong).
1. Not Winklevoss brothers. That is another story.
Zuckerberg never finished the job but he did create his own website which executed searches and served up images of students at Harvard. He was of course sued by this person after Facebook became popular.
The point is that "generative AI" is not something that computer users are asking for, but it certainly is something that relies on stealing from others. To initially "launch" Facemash/Facebook, Zuckerberg never asked for permission to use others' photos.
It stands to reason the primary value of "generative AI" is not the work of computer programmers, it is the work of the authors. phtotgraphers, etc. responsible for the copyrighted content being ingested, generally without permission, for machine learning,.
The methods of machine learning certainly have some value, but arguably the value of "generative AI" does not supercede the value of copyrighted work. Standing alone, without the use of copyrighted works, these methods have minimal value. The same as any other free software we use.
Ehhhh? Yes there are examples of that, as there are for any arbitrary group of humans you could select, but [anecdotally] I've noticed the opposite... it's not uncommon to find a passionate developer that's only interested in the challenge/problem solving aspect - it's a lot less common for say.. real estate agents.
I don't really get the point you're making beyond "people be greedy sometimes" (which I do agree with, don't get me wrong).
Similarly, other people could use that database to check newly published work, making it easier to detect and stop obvious copyright infringement.
Problem is, the copyright system - both as a body of laws and as a spirit and mindset behind them - prevents the database from ever being created. At least in any form other than "yes / maybe?" responses from comparing perceptual hashes; go beyond that, someone comes out of the woodwork, seeking royalties. Reverse image search engines exist, but are barely helpful because of that.
Anyway;
> And if I'm going to cross the line, at least I know I am the one who makes this decision and takes the legal risk. With the current generative AI I don't even know who holds accountability. Likely nobody, or worse, an unaware me.
Ultimately, you're still the one making the decision. No one forces you to publish whatever a generative model produced in response to your prompt. It's up to you what to do with the output. You also exercise creative control - both during and after generation.
The legal situation of GenAI in general is still uncertain - but at the very least, you're still in control of whether you're referencing or plagiarising in a moral sense.
You would think we'd be there already. But search as a field has died. Hopefully temporarily but pretty dead. This is interesting because good search is supposedly how Google make their profit. And for years now they have obsessed about anything but good search. It's now a given that a google search will give you anything BUT what you want. I know: there are upstarts - are the upstarts that good? For example, is there a great image search upstart?
https://lenso.ai/en/search-by-text?desc=a+woman+looking+outs...
When I say "a woman looking outside from her seat on a train" I don't want it to generate such an image for me. I want it to literally give me existing images that more or less fit the description, with full credit. If it's from a movie I'd like to know the movie's name and timestamp and the actor's name and everything.
I know the difference between referencing and plagiarism. And if I'm going to cross the line, at least I know I am the one who makes this decision and takes the legal risk. With the current generative AI I don't even know who holds accountability. Likely nobody, or worse, an unaware me.
This is why I think the copyright law is very broken. If someone made the database I described above, their pants, house and first-born would be sued off. But I'd argue it's a not just more useful, but also more ethical product than generative AIs.