I’ll try to compare with explicitly compiling to a binary later today.
But that’s the thing. It’s a JIT, running a VM. Swift emits native code. Big difference.
Maybe I’ll add AOT compilation for dotnet then.. Strange they didnt incorporate that though.
> But that’s the thing. It’s a JIT, running a VM. Swift emits native code. Big difference.
It's not only a JIT, you can preJIT with R2R if you need, or precompile with NativeAOT, or i think you can fully interpret with Mono.
Edit: it looks like the issue with the dotnet cli itself, which until now was not on a 'hot path'. `dotnet help` also take half a second to show up. When running a dll directly, I think it doesn't load the cli app and just run the code necessary to start the dll.
dotnet run $ time dotnet run hello-world.cs > /dev/null
real 0m1.161s
user 0m0.849s
sys 0m0.122s
$ time dotnet run hello-world.cs > /dev/null
real 0m0.465s
user 0m0.401s
sys 0m0.065sI had some Windows command-line apps written in C# that always took at least 0.5s to run. It was an annoying distraction. After Microsoft's improvements the same code was running in 0.2s. Still perceptible, but a great improvement. This was on a cheap laptop bought in 2009.
I'm aware that .Net is using a different runtime now, but I'm amazed that it so slow on a high-end modern laptop.
It can easily add hundreds of milliseconds in various situations you can't easily control.
It’s good that it allows scripts to run, and does packages. Simple is good
I was just curious and then surprised that it already caches compiled binaries, but that the time remained the same.
thanks Jared and team, keep up the great work.
time "/Users/bouke/Library/Application Support/dotnet/runfile/hello-world-fc604c4e7d71b490ccde5271268569273873cc7ab51f5ef7dee6fb34372e89a2/bin/debug/hello-world" > /dev/null
real 0m0.051s
user 0m0.029s
sys 0m0.017s
So yeah the overhead of dotnet run is pretty high in this preview version. > Measure-Command { dotnet run run.cs }
Days : 0
Hours : 0
Minutes : 0
Seconds : 2
Milliseconds : 451
Ticks : 24511653
TotalDays : 2,836996875E-05
TotalHours : 0,00068087925
TotalMinutes : 0,040852755
TotalSeconds : 2,4511653
TotalMilliseconds : 2451,1653
First run was around 2500ms, consecutive runs around 1300ms.Task manager doesn't show it, but process explorer shows kernel processes and the story is quite clear.
neuecc ran benchmark on CLI libs overhead, none reach half a second: https://neuecc.medium.com/consoleappframework-v5-zero-overhe...
> Swift does a much better job at this as interprets by default
The .NET JIT is a tiered JIT, it doesn't immediatly emit code immediatly.