News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The 37signals Effect by tptacek on Monday January 19, 2009 @06:21PM (#441053)
It's not my fault you're building a company on a protocol from 1989. =)

You know, I made the same mistake in 1998; we started (and got funded) a company that basically took IRC and:

* Added arbitrary TLV encoded data to messages

* Used link state routing to solve the netsplit problem

* Used FEC to provide reliability over the resulting mesh network

But even though you've kept current on IRC and I wrote it off a long time ago, I'm pretty sure I can still win an argument that IRC is archaic and ready to go.

Re:The 37signals Effect by axod on Monday January 19, 2009 @06:32PM (#441064)
Meh seems to be working fine for me thanks :) Plenty of people are building companies based on HTML also you know. I don't quite see your point...

Those problems you 'solved' are not problems any user cares about though. They want IRC to be easy, and usable as a webchat.

Re:The 37signals Effect by tptacek on Monday January 19, 2009 @06:35PM (#441068)
Oh I totally agree, the world did not need a BitTorrent/IRC combination in 1999, or in 2009.

But the world certainly wants to be able to upload files and images into group chats. No user cares about IRC; they want group chat to be easy as using a website.

Re:The 37signals Effect by axod on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @04:31AM (#441568)
You can't win the argument, because millions of people are still using it, and it's growing...

I assume your startup failed. Perhaps that's tainted your view a tad.

Re:The 37signals Effect by tptacek on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @09:36AM (#441738)
My 1999 startup did not fail because I made the wrong bet about the ancient IRC protocol. IRC isn't "growing" just because you stuck a web front end on it and started counting page views. Like I said, the overwhelming majority of your users could care less what the protocol is behind it.

You are the opposite of right; IRC is dying, and will be replaced with web chat systems with backend protocols nobody thinks about.

Re:The 37signals Effect by axod on Tuesday January 20, 2009 @12:50PM (#441965)
"started counting page views"

Why would I count page views? Counting profit is much more fun.

I think you'll see an explosion in online webchat this year and next, and IRC will be one of the clear winners. I don't like the protocol, it's a complete mess to be honest, but that's what'll happen.