News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by doktrin on Monday August 20, 2012 @06:43PM (#4410163)
a series of 1- or 2-year stays will still hurt you. Five to 7 years at a company is a good run. Consider 2 to 3 years the minimum commitment when accepting a new job.

Is this statement accurate? At first glance it seems to be a little conservative. I ask as a potential career changer with 2.5 years in my first position, and 1.5 into my second.

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by mechanical_fish on Monday August 20, 2012 @07:28PM (#4410337)
This is from Science magazine. Presumably the audience is scientists, not programmers.

Having worked as both, I'd definitely say that scientists change jobs less frequently than programmers. It takes a lot longer to settle into a job, the jobs don't evolve as fast, and it can take longer than one or two years just to wrap up your first project. Data only arrive so quickly.

The supply/demand situation is also reversed: There's a surplus of scientists, and no matter what your field is there's probably not many open positions, so the odds that the alternative job of your dreams will open up during any given year are smaller.

Finally, science is organized as an international guild that respects seniority. If you hold a chair for twenty years you've got more political power. The opposite situation prevails in many subfields of software - you have to turn over your skills fairly rapidly or risk being left behind.

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by SomeCallMeTim on Monday August 20, 2012 @07:44PM (#4410391)
Agreed.

My first programming salary job (did some consulting earlier) was for ~2 years. The person who hired me gave me a series of about 12 promises about what the job would be like, and then systematically broke every one. My second job (huge raise!) only made it about a year, at which point I lost faith in that company and was sick of the long commute.

After that, I did consulting for a while, then took another job for about a year and a half, and moved on and did more consulting...repeat. I did finally land somewhere that I stayed for almost six years before eventually resigning to consult some more, but in general my jobs have all been 1-2 years at most.

I have never been questioned about why I stayed such a "short time" at those positions, and I've only rarely had trouble getting interviews when sending in my resume (the only time really was the period after 9/11, when the country was in shock and, as far as I could tell, no one was hiring). And I get offers from many of the positions I interview for.

So no, I can say categorically that, at least in software jobs, 1-2 years at a job isn't considered problematic, at least if you're otherwise a strong candidate.

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by maximilianburke on Monday August 20, 2012 @07:08PM (#4410265)
I think it depends on the candidate's situation. If they had a series of 1-2 year stints at companies that were interrupted by the company going out of business I wouldn't hold that against them because it could just be bad luck.

If they were laid off repeatedly (with the company still surviving) it would make me question why their name always seemed to make it onto the layoff list.

If they changed jobs repeatedly every 1-2 years because they were bored then I'd be leery because I wouldn't be able to trust that I could give them responsibility or factor them into long range plans without them getting bored and leaving.

As a manager I would consider two years to be the minimum commitment for full time employment. If you (the candidate, in general) leave before then without extenuating circumstances I would probably skip over your resume the next time it landed on my desk down the road regardless of how much of a rock star you were.

Searching for candidates is an expensive, time-consuming process, I don't want to do it when I wasn't expecting to. Especially to fill a position that I recently filled.

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by polymatter on Monday August 20, 2012 @07:55PM (#4410426)
I understand you need to be picky as an employer, and I still can't comprehend the crap you as an employer receive when advertising jobs and I certainly don't envy you having to go through it.

But I'm not sure you should assume a candidate who changed jobs every 1-2 years will continue doing so indefinately, especially if they have only had 2 or 3 jobs. Personal circumstances change and peoples appetite for risk generally decreases with age (and experience) especially once they pick up partners and children along their life journey. Intuitively it feels like a very bad metric for gauging if they are a longer term employee.

If you have high staff turnover the larger factor may be an environment which drives them out. Though admitedly, if you have a say on hiring and don't have a say on the employees working environment then I guess you have few options.

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by mindcrime on Monday August 20, 2012 @08:43PM (#4410580)
if you have a say on hiring and don't have a say on the employees working environment

Anyone in that position should probably be the one looking for a new job.

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by OzzyB on Monday August 20, 2012 @07:36PM (#4410360)
As someone who recruits for Electronic Arts who has far from a stellar record where the treatment and retention of staff is concerned; I would take this with a grain of salt.
Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by cgarvey on Monday August 20, 2012 @07:51PM (#4410411)
I agree. A small period of time with a great employee can completely change a company. I don't think past employment length is in any way an accurate indicator of the value an employee can bring. Unless your company objective is "hire someone who will sit in this chair for 4 years, guaranteed".
Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by sanxiyn on Monday August 20, 2012 @07:18PM (#4410297)
Thanks. An interesting perspective from a manager.

I have a question. It stands to reason that one would want to avoid searching for candidates because it is expensive and time-consuming. But why especially to fill a position that one recently filled? Is it just sunk cost fallacy? I mean, it doesn't seem to change anything from what I can see.

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by maximilianburke on Tuesday August 21, 2012 @12:47AM (#4411229)
There are two reasons. The first is that presumably I passed on all the other candidates to go with my selection for a reason. Now that the best candidate for the position has decided to leave I must now go back and likely revisit those who I passed over.

The time is also a big one too. It takes a long time sometimes to fill roles so the group is going to be a man down until a new person is hired.

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by sliverstorm on Monday August 20, 2012 @07:21PM (#4410315)
But why especially to fill a position that one recently filled?

The phrase, "add insult to injury" comes to mind.

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by mindcrime on Monday August 20, 2012 @08:45PM (#4410586)
As a manager I would consider two years to be the minimum commitment for full time employment.

So, wait... you're saying you want employees to commit to you for 2 years, no matter how bad the job turns out to be? Ok, so are you going to commit to the employee for a minimum of 2 years, no matter how bad the employee turns out to be?

Or are you just trying to have your cake and eat it to? Employees don't exist to make your life easier, they're people, with their own dreams, hopes, goals and ambitions... why should they take one on the chin for you, if it might interfere with their pursuit of what matters to them?

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by maximilianburke on Tuesday August 21, 2012 @12:10AM (#4411135)
Did you read the sentence after that? Hopes and dreams are great. If you leave because you're unhappy I'll wish you all the best. However if you find that the grass isn't greener on the other side of the fence and re-apply after being on the job for only 9 months in the first place, I'll probably pass on you as I'll still have it in my mind that you left your old team down a man with the same work to do.

It's far from black and white. Context matters. If you're coming from another part of the company I'll check to see what projects you were on. I know a lot of good people that lost their jobs, and others who left, after they were on a string of unbelievably bad projects. But I knew the context of the work and the project they were on and ended up recently making one of the best hires my group has ever done with one of these guys.

After that point? If you're unhappy with your work, or want to try something new, I'll help you find something better. I hired you because I thought you'd be a good fit for the company and ideally I'd like that relationship to continue. To that end I'll ask the all people I know to see what's open and hopefully find you something that's engaging.

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by mindcrime on Tuesday August 21, 2012 @10:10AM (#4412752)
Did you read the sentence after that? Hopes and dreams are great. If you leave because you're unhappy I'll wish you all the best. However if you find that the grass isn't greener on the other side of the fence and re-apply after being on the job for only 9 months in the first place, I'll probably pass on you as I'll still have it in my mind that you left your old team down a man with the same work to do.

Sure, and the corollary is, if a firm lays somebody off after 6 months because their numbers for the quarter took a dip, the employee should pass on them if they come calling wanting them back.

After that point? If you're unhappy with your work, or want to try something new, I'll help you find something better. I hired you because I thought you'd be a good fit for the company and ideally I'd like that relationship to continue. To that end I'll ask the all people I know to see what's open and hopefully find you something that's engaging.

That's a good outlook to have. Glad to hear it. That earlier bit just came off a little bit as "The employee owes us something, but we don't owe them anything in turn." All I'm saying is that "fair is fair."

My experience is that very few firms feel any sense of loyalty to their employees, but they want their employees to be loyal to them. That's what I have a problem with.

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by mnicole on Monday August 20, 2012 @06:53PM (#4410202)
This goes against a lot of what I've read in the past, where the 1.5/2 year mark is where you re-evaluate where you are and what you want. My longest stay somewhere was 3.5 years, and that felt like an eternity given the type of work I do and how I yearn for constant growth, particularly through change.
Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by MrEnigma on Monday August 20, 2012 @06:45PM (#4410171)
I think it depends on who you ask.

I think it's assumed that 2+ years is a normal stepping away point. Personally I've done a nearly 7 year stint, then a 2.5 year stint, and currently nearly a year into my current position. My thoughts are that I wish I would have changed jobs more often for my first job when I was learning, to open up my mind to what was out there. Although I still think it's important to move around. 5 years seems like you're stagnating (unless you're in a position where you are driving the direction).

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by Smudge on Monday August 20, 2012 @06:49PM (#4410182)
It does seem a bit conservative to me, which is why I submitted the link. I wanted to see whether I was alone in that thought.
Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by doktrin on Monday August 20, 2012 @07:09PM (#4410274)
Part of the disconnect may be down to industry norms. For instance, it's probably a little unusual to stick around a tech startup for 7+ years.

That said, I have colleagues who have worked in my current company (startup) for 5+ years. However, they are certainly the exception and not the norm.

IME, it's unusual to see a resume wherein almost the entirety of a senior engineer's experience is from 1 organization. I've even heard it described as a potential weakness.

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by vonmoltke on Monday August 20, 2012 @07:25PM (#4410329)
IME, it's unusual to see a resume wherein almost the entirety of a senior engineer's experience is from 1 organization. I've even heard it described as a potential weakness.

I left my first job about 4 months ago; two weeks from tomorrow would have been my 10-year service anniversary. I definitely think that tenure seriously hindered my efforts to leave said organization (along with a couple other, off-topic issues).

I understand the position of those who believe that should be a weakness, but I don't agree the length of tenure in itself should be a weakness. In that not-quite-10-year period I went from being an electrical engineer, to a systems engineer[1], to a real-time software engineer. Had I parked and done the same thing for 10 years[2] I would agree that it was a weakness. Of course, that has little to do with the organization and much to do with attitude, as one could move companies but not really progress technically as well.

[1] The aerospace/defense kind, not the IT kind [2] There were lots of people who did that, for far longer

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by MartinCron on Monday August 20, 2012 @07:48PM (#4410401)
I once left a job after just three months. It was obviously not a good fit for me, but I realized that sticking around for a year, the whole "I'm going to give it a year" thing, wasn't really a good idea for anyone.

For me, having an explanation about each job change is more important than the length of time at any given position.

Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by philsnow on Monday August 20, 2012 @11:33PM (#4411031)
You know, you don't necessarily have to put that 3-month job on your resume. Leaving a 3-month gap might be better, YMMV.
Re:Why Good People Leave Good Jobs by MartinCron on Tuesday August 21, 2012 @12:44AM (#4411222)
Yeah, I haven't put that job on the resume for years, nobody has asked about the gap yet.