I'm guessing from past comments of yours that it's the former. But if there's an actual connection, it's very not-obvious to me what it is, and a quick look at the "problems" and "crisis" links you gave doesn't suggest to me any connection with Nix's European-ness.
EU funding doesn't come free. It comes with strings, reports, and endless box-ticking. Suddenly, your priorities aren't what users need but what the grant requires. Need to refactor Nix's UX? Too bad. And what happens when 2027 rolls around? All momentum dies the second funding dries up, and the project roadmap becomes a mad scramble for the next funding round, not actual technical progress.
Fhere is the magnificent farce of "supporting authors" while functionally turning them into NPCs in Nix's grant-funded side quest. The NGI Zero consortium doles out cash to projects, and oh what a coincidence, the NixOS Foundation gets to "help" them by demanding they conform to Nix's byzantine idioms. Free training! Pair programming! (Terms and conditions: your project must now live in the Nixpkgs purgatory, where it will languish unmaintained until the heat death of the universe.) It's not capture, it's ecosystem synergy. Just ignore the fact that every "supported" project is another brick in the wall of Nix's EU-funded fiefdom.
Then there's the priceless spectacle of "volunteer contributors" being hailed as the "most valuable collective resource" in one breath, while the actual money flows to a cozy cabal of insiders who know how to write grant proposals. The Summer of Nix? A masterclass in extracting labor: unpaid trainees get to grind away on the thankless scut work of packaging 1200+ NLnet projects (because quantity trumps quality when your funders count success in metric tons), while the real paid gigs, the ones with job security, go to the same faces who have been orbiting Nix's grant infrastructure for years. But hey, it's mentorship! (Unless you ask who's actually getting paid to "stick around." Then it's complicated.)
The EU wants numbers, so NixOS churns out numbers (packages! development environments! tested examples!), but the second the funding dries up, so does the maintenance. The users? They're left holding the bag, sifting through a graveyard of abandoned flake templates and rotting CI configurations. But metrics were met, damn it! The European Commission got its pound of flesh!
The alternatives, the paths not taken because they'd require actual self-sufficiency instead of groveling for grant crumbs? Corporate sponsors? Too tainted by the profit motive (unless it's NLnet's government-adjacent cash, then it's pure). Community funding? Too hard. Why bother building real user loyalty when you can just outsource your budget to Brussels? Paid support contracts? Heresy! That would mean listening to users instead of grant officers.
So here we are: NixOS, the poster child for how to hollow out an open-source project under the guise of "sustainability." The docs are still incomprehensible, the UX is still a tire fire, but by God, the EU got its "digital infrastructure." And when the funding evaporates in 2027? Well, there's always another grant to chase. Until then, enjoy the kafkaesque spectacle of a project claim its independent while dancing to the EU's tune and don't ask who's really calling the shots. It's never the volunteers.
I mean, it's not as if other projects, open source or otherwise, funded by companies or lots of random individuals' donations or governments or no one at all, don't make bad decisions all the time.
And the specific complaints you make -- "it has bad UX and bad documentation", "when money's available, most of it goes to people who have been involved in the project for ages", etc. -- are ... not exactly unusual in the world of open-source software.
Consider two hypothetical worlds. In one, the Nix project has been corrupted by taking money from the EU, just as you say it has. In the other, the Nix project's flaws are just those of a typical open-source software project, and you're imagining it's caused by the project's taking funds from the EU because you really hate the EU. How could I distinguish between those two worlds?
As if governance meltdowns and bureaucratic capture announce themselves with flashing lights and notarized confessions? The evidence lies in the patterns, the incentives, the quiet substitutions of purpose.
Take the Foundation's bylaws. They are a masterclass in ambiguity. Article 2.1's lofty mission to "develop, propagate, and promote" is conveniently elastic, stretching to accommodate whatever grant-funded side quest Brussels dreams up next. The board's unchecked authority (Article 15.1's "in all cases not provided for, the board decides") is a blank check for mission drift. And why wouldn't it drift? When your funding depends on pleasing the EU's "Next Generation Internet" bureaucrats, "supporting open-source projects" morphs into herding grantees into Nix's ecosystem whether their code belongs there or not. The NLnet grants aren't altruism; they're a colonization program dressed as philanthropy.
Then there's the governance vacuum. The Foundation's refusal to define its relationship to the very projects it claims to steward. Is Nixpkgs independent? A "workgroup" under Article 11? The silence is deafening. This isn't oversight; it's strategic opacity. When maintainers resign en masse, protesting Foundation overreach, the board's response isn't clarity. It's the sound of crickets. Meanwhile, the Summer of Nix churns out metric tons of low-quality packages (1200+ and counting!) because grantors measure success in volume, not maintainability. The result? A dependency graveyard where "supported" projects go to die, abandoned the second the funding cycle ends.
As for the money trail: follow the jobs. The "volunteers" touted in press releases aren't the ones landing paid gigs writing grant proposals or "mentoring" NLnet's captive projects. Those roles go to the usual suspects, the insiders who've turned grant-chasing into a career. The Foundation's financial disclosures (if they exist) won't show a line item for "compromised priorities," but the pattern's clear: when salaries depend on EU grants, the roadmap becomes a dance to Brussels' tune. The docs stay broken, the UX stays hostile, but look at all those shiny "tested examples" for the Commission's reports!
The Foundation's Dutch legal structure: a stichting, deliberately designed to be unaccountable. No members, no oversight, just a self-perpetuating board that answers to no one but itself. When the community revolts? Tough luck. The bylaws grant them no leverage, just as the EU grants leave no room for dissent. The real tragedy isn't that NixOS sold its soul; it's that it did so for the pettiest of reasons: the bureaucratic equivalent of pocket change. But hey, at least the metrics look good on paper. Until 2027.
https://web.archive.org/web/20250404052551/https://nixos.org...
"We are tasked with supporting authors (...) by running Summer of Nix" -- because nothing says "sustainable open-source" like unpaid interns (sorry, "trainees") doing the grunt work while leadership pats itself on the back for "mentorship." And don’t worry, if they stick around long enough, they might get a part-time gig!
"The NixOS Foundation is a partner in the NGI Zero consortium" -- the classic nonprofit-industrial complex maneuver: secure public funding under the guise of "digital infrastructure," then quietly ensure that the people who control the purse strings also control the narrative. Who audits the auditors?
"Paid contributors: (...) we want to be an exemplary business partner" -- translation: "We'll pay just enough to avoid revolt, while ensuring that the real power (and grants) stay in the hands of the usual suspects." But don't worry, volunteers! Your "expertise and attention" (read: free labor) remain the "most valuable collective resources." How touching.
"European Commission: Funds the entire operation." -- And there it is. The real stakeholder. Not the users, not the volunteers, but the faceless EU grant machine that demands metrics and deliverables, ensuring that the whole circus keeps spinning just long enough to justify the next funding round.
Nix leadership gets to play both grantee and grant-distributor, all while framing their own pet projects as "community-driven." The volunteers keep the lights on, the paid insiders keep the grants flowing, and the end result is more Nix packages that technically exist but still require a PhD to use.
- The founder is Dutch
- NixOS Foundation is funded by the EU
- Majority of contributors are from the EU
- There are severe governance problems: https://lwn.net/Articles/971531/
- Broader Nix leadership crisis: https://lwn.net/Articles/970824/