News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by throwup238 on Monday May 26, 2025 @04:00AM (#44095095)
> Who's filling that role in this brave new world?

Us?

(Yeah, we’re fucked)

Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by lukan on Monday May 26, 2025 @04:21AM (#44095211)
In a world of vibe coders, those who can still debug on their own, will have quite a valuable skill.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by XenophileJKO on Monday May 26, 2025 @07:34AM (#44096393)
Are least for a few more generations of model.

I just finished creating a multiplayer online party game using only Claude Code. I didn't edit a single line. However, there is no way someone who doesn't know how to code could get where I am with it.

You have to have an intuition on the sources of a problem. You need to be able to at least glance at the correct and understand when and where the AI is flailing, so you know to backtrack or reframe.

Without that you are as likely to totally mess to you app. Which also means you need to understand source control and when to save and how to test methodically.

Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by goeiedaggoeie on Monday May 26, 2025 @08:20AM (#44096734)
Surely there is a scale limit to how big the application can be using this approach.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by a1j9o94 on Monday May 26, 2025 @09:09AM (#44097119)
Why do you say that? I would argue that as long as your tests and interfaces are clearly defined no reason it couldn't scale indefinitely.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by XenophileJKO on Monday May 26, 2025 @04:41PM (#44101469)
Practically there is with Claude Code at least.

Hypothetically, if you codified the architecture as a form of durable meta tests, you might be able to significantly raise the ceiling.

Decomposing to interfaces seems to actually increase architectural entropy instead of decrease it when Claude Code is acting on a code base over a certain size/complexity.

Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by nurettin on Monday May 26, 2025 @08:34AM (#44096858)
I was thinking of that, but asking the right questions and learning the problem domain just a little bit "getting the gist of things" will help a complete newbie to generate code for a complex software.

For example in your case there is the concept of message routing where a message that gets sent to the room is copied to all the participants.

You have timers, animation sheets, events, triggers, etc. A question that extracts such architectural decisions and relevant pieces of code will help the user understand what they are actually doing and also help debug the problems that arise.

It will of course take them longer, but it is possible to get there.

Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by guappa on Monday May 26, 2025 @09:05AM (#44097091)
no code has been the hot new thing for the past 40 years.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by XenophileJKO on Monday May 26, 2025 @04:47PM (#44101529)
So I agree, but we aren't at that level of capability yet. Because at some point currently it inevitably hits a wall and you need to dig deeper to push it out of the rut.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by skeeter2020 on Monday May 26, 2025 @10:23AM (#44097701)
so if you're an experienced, trained developer you can now add AI as a tool to your skill set? This seems reasonable, but is also a fundamentally different statement that what every. single. executive. is parroting to the echochamber.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by garylkz on Monday May 26, 2025 @11:22AM (#44098334)
Curious, do you supervise the code itself or at least understand what the code is trying to do?

By "I didn't edit a single line", do you still prompt the agent to fix any issues you found? If so, is that consided an edit?

Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by XenophileJKO on Monday May 26, 2025 @04:34PM (#44101401)
So yes and no. I often just let it work by itself. Towards the very end when I had more of a deadline I would watch and interrupt it when it was putting implementations in places that broke its architecture.

I think only once did I ever give it an instruction that was related to a handful of lines (There certainly were plenty of opportunities, don't get me wrong).

When troubleshooting occasionally I did read the code. There was an issue with player to player matching where it was just kind of stuck and gave it a simpler solution (conceptually, not actual code) that worked for the design constraints.

I did find myself hinting/telling it to do things like centralize the CSS.

It was a really useful exercise in learning. I'm going to write an article about it. My biggest insight is that "good" architecture for an current generation AI is probably different than for humans because of how attention and context works in the models/tools (at least for the current Claude Code). Essentially "out of sight out of mind" creates a dynamic where decomposing code leads to an increase in entropy when a model is working on it.

I need to experiment with other agentic tools to see how their context handling impacts possible scope of work. I extensively use GitHub Copilot, but I control scope, context, and instructions much tighter there.

I hadn't really used hands off automation much in the past because I didn't think the models were at a level that they could handle a significantly sized unit of work. Now they can with large caveats. There also is a clear upper bound with the Claude Code, but that can probably be significantly improved by better context handling.

Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by zelphirkalt on Monday May 26, 2025 @05:01AM (#44095439)
I already imagine future devs wide-eyed saying things like: "He/She can _debug_!!"
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by bigfatkitten on Monday May 26, 2025 @08:15AM (#44096709)
I once showed a reasonably experienced infrastructure engineer how to use strace to diagnose some random hangs in an application, and it was like he had seen the face of God.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by mprovost on Monday May 26, 2025 @06:51AM (#44096081)
I have a strong memory from the start of my career, when I had a job setting up Solaris systems and there was a whispered rumour that one of the senior admins could read core files. To the rest of us, they were just junk that the system created when a process crashed and that we had to find and delete to save disk space. In my mind I thought she could somehow open the files in an editor and "read" them, like something out of the Matrix. We had no idea that you could load them into a debugger which could parse them into something understandable.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by RUnconcerned on Monday May 26, 2025 @06:42AM (#44096033)
This reminded me of Asimov's short story "The Feeling of Power" https://hex.ooo/library/power.html
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by Reefersleep on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @03:24PM (#44109939)
Thank you for that, what a fun read :D
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by fao_ on Monday May 26, 2025 @05:30AM (#44095596)
I mean I already heard comments about myself when I went and RTFM'd

"You read manuals?!?"

"... Yeah? (pause) Wait, you don't?!?!?"

Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by Avicebron on Monday May 26, 2025 @07:27AM (#44096329)
(Anecdote) Best job I ever had, I walked in and they were like "yeah, we don't have any training or anything like that", but we've got a fully setup lab and a rotating library of literature. <My Boss> "Yeah I'm not going to be around, but here are the office keys" don't blow up the company pretty much.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by lukan on Monday May 26, 2025 @07:34AM (#44096397)
I don't really see the connection here, but it was a nice anecdote of a trusting environment.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by lukan on Monday May 26, 2025 @06:46AM (#44096061)
To be honest, I do find most manuals (man pages) horrible to quickly get information how to do something and here LLMs do shine for me (as long as they don't mix up version numbers).
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by johnisgood on Monday May 26, 2025 @08:20AM (#44096740)
I love manual pages, at least on/from OpenBSD.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by skydhash on Monday May 26, 2025 @01:51PM (#44099780)
For man pages, you have to already know what you wants to do and just want information on how exactly to do it. They're not for learning about the domain. You don't read the find manual to learn the basics of filesystems.
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by vbezhenar on Monday May 26, 2025 @06:21AM (#44095913)
Imagine reading in 2025, when you can just watch tiktok about it!

/s

Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by johnisgood on Monday May 26, 2025 @08:21AM (#44096748)
Pretty much. The hesitancy to read documentation was there long before TikTok and LLMs.

"Teach me how to use Linux [but I hate reading documentation]".

It infuriated me.

Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by gala8y on Monday May 26, 2025 @04:27PM (#44101342)
Yesterday I tried to vibe install (TM) marker-api docker image and failed miserably. Still, I was able to try. :)
Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by krisoft on Monday May 26, 2025 @04:35AM (#44095287)
I mean the process either works, or it doesn’t. Meaning it either brings in the expected value with acceptable level of defects or it doesn’t.

From a higher up’s perspective what they do is not that different from vibe coding anyway. They pick a direction, provide a high level plan and then see as things take shape, or don’t. If they are unhappy with the progress they shake things up (reorg, firings, hirings, adjusting the terminology about the end goal, making rousing speeches, etc)

They might realise that they bet on the wrong horse when the whole site goes down and nobody inside the company can explain why. Or when the hackers eat their face and there are too many holes to even say which one they did come through. But these things regularly happen already with the current processes too. So it is more of a difference in degree, not kind.

Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by a1j9o94 on Monday May 26, 2025 @09:08AM (#44097107)
I agree with this completely. I get the impression that a lot of people here think of software development as a craft, which is great for your own learning and development but not relevant from the company's perspective. It just has to work good enough.

Your point about management being vibe coding is spot on. I have hired people to build something and just had to hope that they built it the way I wanted. I honestly feel like AI is better than most of the outsourced code work I do.

One last piece, if anyone does have trouble getting value out of AI tools, I would encourage you to talk to/guide them like you would a junior team member. Actually "discuss" what you're trying to accomplish, lay out a plan, build your tests, and only then start working on the output. Most examples I see of people trying to get AI to do things fail because of poor communication.

Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by skydhash on Monday May 26, 2025 @01:58PM (#44099870)
> I get the impression that a lot of people here think of software development as a craft, which is great for your own learning and development but not relevant from the company's perspective. It just has to work good enough.

Building the thing may be the primary objective, but you will eventually have to rework what you've built (dependency changes, requirement changes,...). All the craft is for that day, and whatever that goes against that is called technical debt.

You just need to make some tradeoffs between getting the thing out the faster possible and being able to alter it later. It's a spectrum, but instead of discussing it with the engineers, most executive suites (and their manager) wants to give out edicts from high.

Re:At Amazon, Some Coders Say Their Jobs Have Begun to Resem... by collingreen on Tuesday May 27, 2025 @11:15AM (#44107775)
> Building the thing may be the primary objective, but you will eventually have to rework what you've built (dependency changes, requirement changes,...). All the craft is for that day, and whatever that goes against that is called technical debt.

This is so good I just wanted to quote it so it showed up in this thread twice. Very well said.