Frontier models are being provided at a loss right now to my "knowledge", and they're already as crap as you'd want to go, if not even crappier, for worker replacement in my experience.
So right now, I have a really hard time seeing LLMs as a well-spent money if they were bought at their real cost
https://www.epi.org/productivity-pay-gap/
The questions of who will benefit from AI is a political questions. As power is currently firmly in the had of the capital class, AI will only make the rich richer and the poor poorer.
Wages are not based on how much value you produce but how much it cost to reproduce your labor. How much it cost for you to stay alive and be able to work and feed your family. What kind of living standard that entails is a political matter and depends on how strong your unions are, how willing you are to fight for it and so on.
Same with welfare. It is something which was fought for and if the power balance is such that they can get away with giving you less, they will do. In fact some rich pricks would gladly turn you into soylent green if they could get away with it.
I have hope in decentral technologies. Solar power is a rare example. If things gp right then in a few decades, your typical household will just not depend on anybody anymore in terms of energy needs. That's a significant shift.
That is, if big corps don't manage to capture that somehow, though I can't currently see how. But it has happened before. The www and email used to be as decentralized as you could imagine. Nowadays rarely any email gets sent that doesn't come from or go to a gmail server, or definitely not outside one of the biggest 3 providers. Similarly with the www. Everything is so centralized now, it's a great success of big tech.
It doesn't matter how many products and services your society shits out, what matters is how you organize it. And clearly we're already way past the point where the amount of products and services is a bottleneck to quality of life. Access to healthcare, job security, home ownership, the ability to afford kids, good food, all of these things are going down, not up, despite the fact that as a whole we're much better off than in the last century.
Virtually no one can sustain a family on a single salary, it was the norm not so long ago
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Haruki-Seitani/publicat...
Housing is more and more out of reach
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/335721006/figure/fi...
Most of the productivity gain doesn't translate into income:
https://files.epi.org/charts/img/235212-28502-body.png
Sure enough we now have access to instant brain rot doomscrolling services, infinite low quality entertainment, vast amount of ultra processed food, &c. but if anythings these things are distractions.
And as exhibit A I provide progress in automation in the last decades (enormous) in relation to the median buying power of the population in developed nations.
It just doesn't work the way you describe, but I have sympathies for naïvely believing that it does.
Same goes for my movie theater, when did it x2 its price in the past 5 years while having less employees ? Oh wait, there's only one theater in town and I don't have a car, that's probably why.
Taken for granted that AI is extremely cheap. Product and services don’t become cheaper just because they are easier to produce. One way to get rich is artificial scarcity.
Now the only way I know that people in most jobs got better pay was to organize. Including striking. You can’t bully people too much if they can shut down sectors of the local community or country.
Cheap AI can make things cheap. Or not. Who owns it? Some dozens of rich people? Do they have to make it cheap? Do governments have to make living on social welfare (who says there will be social welfare?[1]) “more luxurious than working full-time is now” when you look around and... there’s no one to pressure them to do that any more?
[1] Some people with a lot of money stuffed in their ears think that social welfare is something that the poors/the lazy can just fall back on indefinitely. They know nothing about means testing or the fact that social welfare has been fought against by the very rich (ideologues who are savvy, they certainly didn’t stuff money in their ears) since social welfare was introduced.
Society as a whole will produce more products and services and have to work less for this.
In other words, products and services will become much cheaper.
In the future, living on social welfare might offer a lifestyle more luxurious than working full-time is now.
So if most peoples life goes from "I have to work hard to pay my bills" to "I don't have to work as hard and can afford more", that will not drive people to go fight on the streets.