News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by arrrg on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:03AM (#4403988)
I do not believe that this is politically motivated. I just see no evidence for that.

Justice systems are allergic to public disrespect. That alone can completely explain the behavior of the police in Sweden and the UK.

Assange is a self-importent prick, cowardly on the run from pretty serious allegations. He exploits his involvement with Wikileaks to sow doubt. I really think it's as simple as that.

Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by Tycho on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:21AM (#4404057)
- Sweden refused to promise Ecuador that he would not be extradited to the US

- Sweden issued police alerts more befitting of an international terrorist suspect

- Assange was hit by these charges coincidentally just at the the time when he'd provoked the wrath of the US

- the charge they'd managed to conjure up is one for which there can be basically no exhonerating witnesses and no physical evidence, so they simply 'must' question him in person

- the supposed victims were tweeting about how excited they were to be with Assange seemingly after the alleged crime and also did not report it until later as if they were prompted by some other motivation

I'd put the odds of this being a legitimate criminal case at something like 0.0000034%

Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by arrrg on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:26AM (#4404071)
Sigh.

Just one thing. no country will promise not to extradite someone. They can't. It's just not possible to promise something like that. How is that supposed to work? If (hypothetically) the US were to request Assange's extradition and if they had (hypothetically) evidence and valid reasons for doing so, Sweden would have to break their treaty.

Why do you believe it's possible to promise something like that? That's crazy.

Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by Tycho on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:33AM (#4404092)
Pretty simple, they ask the US if they wish to have Assange extradited or not. If they don't, then Sweden can say to Ecuador that Assange will not face extradition to the US for anything he has hitherto committed. If they do, then Sweden should just fucking admit it.
Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by Volpe on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:37AM (#4404112)
Politics isn't as clear cut as you are making it. What treaty (specifically) are you referring to? Its extradition treaty? Well yeah, it'd need to break that.

But why is that completely out of the question?

Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by arrrg on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:44AM (#4404129)
Simple, really. They don't want to respond to Assange's every whim. You can't expect governments to respond to every stupid request. Do you really think Sweden would break an extradition treaty over one person? Most certainly not. They can't predict the future, they won't make promises like that.
Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by dasil003 on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:35AM (#4404102)
Okay. What about the other four points?
Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by MarkMc on Sunday August 19, 2012 @11:39AM (#4404280)
The four other points are valid defense arguments - something which were probably brought up at the UK extradition hearing and would be brought up in a Swedish trial.

However, the allegation of the charge being 'conjured up' would require that both the UK and Swedish judicial systems be severely compromised. That would be an extraordinary conspiracy, so the claim requires extraordinary evidence. The four points mentioned simply don't meet that standard in my opinion.

Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by Tycho on Sunday August 19, 2012 @12:39PM (#4404448)
Extraordinary claims... A meme that has never made much sense to me. Anyway:

Think about this from the start: Assange has just become an enemy of the US due to wikileaks dumping a lot of official documents onto the Internet. Knowing this, Assange would be extra careful not to do anything that could lead to his arrest by a America-comliant government. Next thing we know, he's being accused of the one crime for which there can be almost by definition no corroborating witnesses, no forensic evidence, no signs of physical harm on the victim. What are the odds? And remember, they haven't even pressed the charges (that way they can deny the judicial system was actually compromised), this is just an excuse to get him into custody so he can then be officially extradited to the US.

Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by SoftwareMaven on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:42AM (#4404123)
I think Assange is a self-important twit. I have no knowledge of what happened so I have no idea whether he is really guilty or now.

I also think he's right to be afraid. The two pieces of evidence that make me fill that way are, first, that the prosecutor that wants the questioning is not the prosecutor that spoke with the women and, second, they won't question him anywhere but Sweden, even though Sweden has done remote interviews in the past. Couple this with one of the accusers refusing to sign her statement and it gets very fishy.

Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by rjsamson on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:10AM (#4404009)
Agreed. Assange's ego and self importance have really hurt what wikileaks was supposed to be about. By all accounts the guy is a scumbag on a personal level and he is unjustly trying to use wikileaks as a shield.
Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by hammersend on Sunday August 19, 2012 @11:16AM (#4404210)
"By all accounts the guy is a scumbag"

This is so ridiculously absurd and easily rebutted by there just being one account of him not being a "scumbag" that I wonder why you would even bother typing such a transparent ad hominem in the first place.

Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by Natsu on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:09AM (#4404006)
> I do not believe that this is politically motivated. > Justice systems are allergic to public disrespect.

For some definitions of "politically motivated," you would have contradicted yourself.

Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by arrrg on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:15AM (#4404034)
Sigh. I knew someone would say something stupid like that.

We all know what was meant with politically motivated in the comment I was responding to. Don't be a pedantic ass when I was perfectly understandable.

Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by Natsu on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:21AM (#4404053)
It's going to be hard to understand what you mean if your definition of "politically motivated" does not include pissing off the authorities.
Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by arrrg on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:28AM (#4404075)
Politically motivated in this context clearly means related to Wikileaks and nothing else. All I want to say that it isn't.

That's why comments like yours are pedantic self-importance that only want to derail the discussion.

Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by Natsu on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:39AM (#4404116)
Wikileaks itself was flagrant disrespect for the political system, whose secrets it exposed. I don't see how you can say it's this kind of politically motivated but not that.

I see that you've retreated with that "and nothing else" part though, admitting that it is, in fact, a factor.

Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by arrrg on Sunday August 19, 2012 @10:53AM (#4404160)
Please stop putting words in my mouth.

The British justice system is motivated to get him because he is behaving like a prick in public and managed to escape them. That's all. Not really politically motivated at all.

Re:Julian Assange is expected to address the world's media a... by Natsu on Sunday August 19, 2012 @11:00AM (#4404173)
The "and nothing else" part was a direct quote from your post as of the time I read it. If there have been edits, I have yet to notice them.

I believe the distinction you are trying to draw lacks a difference. You may consider that pedantry, but being able to communicate precisely what you mean is important, particularly on a story like this where tensions run high.