News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by Noumenon72 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:05PM (#44025285)
> Next, the researchers examined how fitness was associated with the risk of dying in random accidents such as car accidents, drownings and homicides. They chose random accidents because they assumed that there ought to be no association between the men’s fitness in late adolescence and the risk of dying in random accidents.

Blank slatism is the curse of the sciences. Of course the kind of people who die in car accidents and homicides are not identical to everyone else but for random luck. They're less educated[1], they make poor decisions, they have dangerous neighbors, frequently they're immigrants from countries with lots of car accidents and homicides. We've known that "everything is correlated" since 2014[2], when will science figure it out?

1. https://www.theverge.com/2015/10/2/9438197/traffic-accident-... 2. https://gwern.net/everything

Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by azan_ on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:17PM (#44025357)
Yes, and since there is a factor that affects both fitness and dying in car accidents or homicides, then it's harder to establish for how big reduction of mortality is fitness really responsible (causal). What you are complaining about is exactly the point of this study:

> This suggests that people with high and low fitness levels may differ in other important ways, which is something that previous studies have not fully taken into account

Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by conception on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:16PM (#44025351)
Any paper that starts with a blank slate and doesn’t control for confounding variables is unlikely to be published or accepted in.. like… high school.
Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by stepanhruda on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:16PM (#44025347)
I thought these studies often control for additional factors like wealth, education etc. not sure about this one, but genuinely curious whether I am mistaken and science “did not figure it out” yet
Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by gwern on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:39PM (#44025488)
Those studies never 'control for those'. What they do is a crude statistical approximation (sometimes extremely crude - eg most studies will 'control for education' by counting up 'years', which equates 4 years at Caltech with 4 years in community college), and hope that not too much leaks through as "residual confounding" (https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...). Unfortunately, because everything is correlated, there's residual confounding everywhere. This is why every time someone does a Scandinavian population registry study and compares eg siblings within the same family, often the correlation just disappears then and there.

It's 100% unsurprising that this is true of fitness too. This is what always happens. You look at something like a corporate health fitness plan and you find some correlate even after you 'control for' SES, prior health record etc etc; wonderful! Then you do a randomized experiment and it turns out that the residual confounding was still larger than any causal effect which might be there: https://gwern.net/doc/statistics/causality/2022-wallace.pdf Ah well. Maybe next time you'll manage to 'control for' the confounders...

Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by JumpCrisscross on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:43PM (#44025514)
I’m also struggling to see how one’s risk of drowning isn’t obviously related to fitness. (The nexus between weight and car crash mortality isn’t exactly buried science, either [1].)

[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11829292/

Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by fawley on Sunday May 18, 2025 @09:00PM (#44025621)
My university required a swim test to graduate, and also required 10 minutes of treading water in order to access sailboats. Many of my classmates talked about this being difficult, but both were trivial for me.

Fat is buoyant.

Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by galangalalgol on Sunday May 18, 2025 @09:16PM (#44025718)
Yeah you can have lots of spare energy and still be quite strong with great cardiovascular health. It is hard on the joints though.
Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by JumpCrisscross on Sunday May 18, 2025 @09:29PM (#44025782)
Some body fat is absolutely helpful in protecting from drowning [1]. You see a similar curve when mapping life expectancy and mortality risk against BMI—the optimum is a bit thicker than our guidance suggests. (Saying this as someone who has to fight to keep weight on.)

[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28915131/

Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by Vecr on Monday May 19, 2025 @01:13AM (#44026668)
> the optimum is a bit thicker than our guidance suggests

That's probably confounded. Anything over a BMI of 23 better be an increasing proportion of muscle, and even then there's a point that the stress on the heart isn't worth it.

Almost every physical and mental heath condition does bad things to nutrition and internal energy stores, even if only at a diet level.

It's hard to see since so many people are overweight or obese to start with, but the overall correlation goes that way enough to cause confounding.

Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by Teever on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:49PM (#44025551)
I could see a scenario where less fit people stay out of the water while people who are fit do more activities in the water and some of them engage in riskier activities in the water like whitewater kayaking.
Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by JumpCrisscross on Sunday May 18, 2025 @09:00PM (#44025618)
> could see a scenario where less fit people stay out of the water

Which further undermines the authors’ assumption that drownings are random accidents.

Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by M95D on Monday May 19, 2025 @04:02AM (#44027489)
That's not what the study said.
Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by koolba on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:51PM (#44025566)
There’s an age dynamic as well. The most reckless people I knew at age 20 were the most physically fit. But that flipped in later years.
Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by 6510 on Sunday May 18, 2025 @09:19PM (#44025735)
fit people swim, fat people float?
Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by ajross on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:45PM (#44025532)
You're misunderstanding. The point is absolutely not that the fitness/accident correlation must be fictitious. It's that the fact that it exists exists suggests that the fitness/cardiovascular-mortality link may not be as direct as previously understood.

It might be co-causal, for example: to take your list, maybe "making poor decisions" has a bigger impact on cardiovascular health than we thought.

Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by Swizec on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:53PM (#44025584)
> It might be co-causal

Kinda like how wine after dinner improves health outcomes. The kind of people who can afford to regularly drink wine, but not a lot, also have more access to healhtcare.

Also riding horses makes you healthier! (it’s a proxy for wealth)

One could argue that high VO2max may just be another proxy for wealth. People who can afford to work out every day can also afford lots of other things that correlate with health and longevity.

Re:The effect of physical fitness on mortality is overestimated by readthenotes1 on Monday May 19, 2025 @12:50AM (#44026585)
The study group were all military conscripts so at least some of the environment variations were taken care of.

Sweden had a low homicide rate as well (between 4x and 9x lower than the USA, depending on year)