Anyway, that has not stopped large parts of the JavaScript ecosystem -- notably Angular -- from using an experimental variant of decorators, such as the one provided by TypeScript. [2]
They’re undeniably productive, but they’re very black box-ish. Just slap a decorator on a method, now it’s a cron job! Slap a decorator on, and now you’re logging the function call!
I feel like a lot of problems that decorators solve could also be solved with good ol’ higher order functions. Decorators also give zero (or limited? Idk) information to the typescript compiler, so you end up asserting a lot of types instead of inferring them.
I have all these gripes, but it really is amazing to throw decorators on stuff and have it work. Especially with third party libraries that provide decorators. I gave a nestjs app a queueing system by installing bullmq, then just slapping the bullmq decorators around!
Makes me think of the Rich Hickey “simple made easy” talk. Decorators are definitely not simple, which makes me naturally dislike them. But damn are they easy!!
The Stage 3 version of decorators are mostly just a syntax sugar for higher-order function composition. (As opposed to the rejected at Stage 1 version that did a lot more "reflection" and type meta-magic.) I personally was rooting for the Pipeline composition operator to win out first over decorators as what I feel a more generally useful higher-order function composition tool, but I understand given Java/C#/Python how much more people seem to love the decorator syntax.
By ambitiously adding useful features, could Teal push the upstream to make progress? Probably not because Lua's scope is intended to be small (and we're no longer in the same context as 2015 era Typescript and tc39), but it's interesting to think about.