Launch HN: Jazzberry (YC X25) – AI agent for finding bugs

Re:Launch HN: Jazzberry (YC X25) – AI agent for finding bugs by ToValueFunfetti on Wednesday May 14, 2025 @11:39PM (#43991615)

I think it maps perfectly onto the halting problem: just say one of the requirements of your program is halting. Humans can decide whether a program halts in a lot of cases, including more-or-less all of the programs we're likely to encounter. But for the overwhelming majority of possible programs, we can't figure it out.

A useful bug detector doesn't need to overcome this because it would be detecting bugs in the kind of code we write, but there is no bug detector which gives the correct answer for all inputs.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Launch HN: Jazzberry (YC X25) – AI agent for finding bugs by ninetyninenine on Thursday May 15, 2025 @09:42AM (#43995013)

I don’t think you realize how universal the halting problem is in the universe.

Like the law governs everything that exists in the universe so it governs humans as well.

If a human can know that a program halts it also means the program is provably haltable. If a human doesn’t know whether a program will halt it likely means that the program is not provably haltable.

The halting problem refers to a general algorithm that can prove any program will halt.

[ Parent | on HN ]