News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software by efdee on Sunday May 11, 2025 @09:27AM (#43953689)
Strange wording. You are the one that put tens of thousands of your users at risk. Not the one who discovers the problem.
Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software by stavros on Sunday May 11, 2025 @09:41AM (#43953769)
If you forget your shop's door open after hours, and someone starts shouting "HEY GUYS! THIS DOOR IS OPEN! LOOK!", I have a hard time putting 100% of the blame on you.
Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software by pixl97 on Sunday May 11, 2025 @11:28AM (#43954466)
If I point out the bridge is cracking and you get angry about it, I'm blaming the idiots that engineered a crap bridge and didn't maintain it.

Maybe it's time we get professional standards if this is how we are going to behave?

Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software by haswell on Sunday May 11, 2025 @12:45PM (#43955001)
This seems like a fallacious analogy to me.

Why is a cracked bridge dangerous? Because anyone traveling over it or under it is at risk of being hurt if the bridge collapses. Warning people that it is cracking does not increase the likelihood of a collapse.

Why is a software vulnerability dangerous? Because anyone who knows about it and has nefarious intent can now use it as a weapon against those who are using the vulnerable software, and the world is full of malicious actors actively seeking new avenues to carry out attacks.

And there are quite a few people who would exploit the knowledge of an unlocked door if given the chance.

There’s a very clear difference in the implications between these scenarios.

Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software by pixl97 on Sunday May 11, 2025 @01:26PM (#43955312)
A cracked bridge is always dangerous.

A vulnerable piece of software is always dangerous.

There are large numbers of state funded exploit groups and otherwise blackhat organizations that find and store these vulnerabilities waiting for the right opportunity, say economic warfare.

Much like building safe bridges from the start we need the same ideology in software. The 'we can always patch it later' is eventually going to screw us over hard.

Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software by haswell on Sunday May 11, 2025 @04:51PM (#43957057)
I agree with the conclusion that we need safer software from the start.

But we also have to deal with the reality of the situation in front of us.

I will maintain that the differences between the implications of revealing a crack in a bridge vs. prematurely revealing a vulnerability to literally the entire world are stark. I find it pretty problematic to continue comparing them and a rather poor analogy.

> There are large numbers of state funded exploit groups and otherwise blackhat organizations that find and store these vulnerabilities

This underscores my point. What you’ve been describing is a scenario in which those organizations are handed new ammunition for free (assuming they don’t already have the vuln in their catalog).

Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software by efdee on Monday May 12, 2025 @01:58PM (#43965808)
They didn't "forget" to lock the door that one time. They just never lock it. The guy yelling it out loud is pissing off all the people who already knew you didn't. He is not the one to be angry at.