Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software
by darkwater on Sunday May 11, 2025 @07:16AM
(#43952992)
Isn't that basically HackerOne?
Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software
by Avamander on Sunday May 11, 2025 @07:47AM
(#43953135)
No, HackerOne gets paid by the companies, so they're heavily incentivized to work for their benefit.
I've had three really bad experiences with unskilled H1 triagers that the next vuln I find from a company that uses H1 will go instantly public. I'm never going to spend that much effort again, to get a triager that would actually bother to triage.
Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software
by xmodem on Sunday May 11, 2025 @07:44AM
(#43953130)
HackerOne, BugCrowd, et al don't appear to make any serious effort to vet reports themselves.
Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software
by hashstring on Sunday May 11, 2025 @01:15PM
(#43955232)
Is that true? I thought you could pay for a H1 service that basically had professionals triaging the vulnerabilities and only pass on the correct ones?
Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software
by ycombinatrix on Sunday May 11, 2025 @05:49PM
(#43957449)
Our company pays for one of these third party triage services for H1.
The quality is seriously lacking. They have dismissed many valid findings.
Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software
by hashstring on Sunday May 11, 2025 @07:00PM
(#43957985)
Ah thank you for the info!
From what I understood, the service is also (very) expensive. Wild.
Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software
by asmor on Sunday May 11, 2025 @07:48AM
(#43953141)
except there you spend several months walking an underpaid person in india who can barely use a shell though reproduction steps, get a confirm after all that work and the vendor still ignores you
Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software
by ajcp on Sunday May 11, 2025 @09:18AM
(#43953630)
It does indeed already exist in many sectors as trade publications and journalism.
Re:One-Click RCE in Asus's Preinstalled Driver Software
by hashstring on Sunday May 11, 2025 @01:17PM
(#43955244)
Thought of something along the lines of this too before.
I think there is serious potential for this.
- protects the privacy of folks submitting
- vets security vulns. Everything they disclose is exploitable.
- publishes disclosures publicly at a fixed cadence.
- allows companies to pay to subscribe to an "early feed" of disclosures which impact them. This money is used to reward those submitting disclosures, pay the bills, and take some profit.
A bug bounty marketplace, if you will. That is slightly hostile to corporations. Would that be legal, or extortion?