News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by LightBug1 on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:39AM (#43936614)
At this stage, I'm kind of admiring the idiocracy of it all ... (as someone outside of the USA).

Apologies. I'm sympathetic to all the decent people there who didn't vote for this (and even to some who did).

But the USA as a whole voted for this ... twice. At some stage you all have to own it.

Your democracy has spoken.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by jzb on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:05AM (#43936916)
As someone inside the United States... I sort of agree with you, though not entirely. Where we are today is the culmination of decades of attacks on our institutions and public discourse. This is not majority will, but it is a failure of the majority to curb the attacks on our institutions. Collectively, we're to blame -- but at the same time, is it hard to understand why the majority of people in the U.S. haven't been able to push back given what people are up against?

The wealthiest folks have the resources to continually and almost casually undermine institutions, while it takes enormous effort for the larger public to push back. Most people are just trying to live their lives while the Murdochs, Kochs, and others can keep throwing money and bodies at corrupting the country. For every win against the anti-Democratic corruptions, there's two or five losses. They pile up.

But the fall of the U.S. has seemed inevitable for decades. As someone who is here and isn't likely to leave -- my family is here, too many people to muster out and I won't leave them behind -- this is going to suck pretty horribly for some time. If we're very lucky, this will be the wakeup call the U.S. needs and when the dust clears we may rebuild something better. If we're not... well, I don't want to dwell on that.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by tstrimple on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:37PM (#43941931)
At some level it falls back on the bullshit asymmetry problem. Lies are easy. Truth requires details and nuance. This is why the "free marketplace of ideas" is doomed to fail. Too many willfully ignorant people who desperately seek out comfortable lies. Far too many unscrupulous people willing to take advantage of the ignorant.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by duxup on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:57AM (#43936827)
>idiocracy

It doesn't even fit that, it's worse. In Idiocracy President Dwayne Elizondo Mountain Dew Camacho actually chose to find educated / smart people to make decisions.

In this setup it's all politicians and political hangers on making decisions about things they seem to have limited education on what they manage.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by LightBug1 on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:30PM (#43941533)
Fair.

I heard someone today refer to the USA as a kakistocracy.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by pyrophane on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:26AM (#43937167)
I'm an American. I struggle almost every day with what feels like a betrayal of our republic by so many voters and leaders, and none of the explanations for why it has happened, even when taken together, are wholly satisfying.

It has shaken my faith in democracy, but at the same time, there's nothing else, so I have no choice but to try to fight for it in what ways I can.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by ghugccrghbvr on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:32AM (#43937964)
Roger that!

I tell everyone the system can handle it. But Schmidt on yt isn’t wrong.

Excellent username

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by zmgsabst on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:47PM (#43939369)
This is democracy working:

More voters feel the way you do about this toward the previous state of affairs — and so their perspective guided policy. They also don’t feel democracy has responded to their concerns, from immigration to economic to social policy.

That is democracy: you just can’t handle being in the losing faction — and emotionally want to subvert democracy to enforce your will.

Being unable to understand that shows a deep lack of empathy.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by thrance on Saturday May 10, 2025 @09:32AM (#43945482)
Material forces. The wealthy have a vested interest in dismantling the state, welfare programs, regulations, etc. Just so they can get more wealth through exploiting the workers.

Hence why they spend billions on propaganda tools like Fox News or influencers (Joe Rogan, Tim Pool...) propping up increasingly right-wing presidents. So far they've been successful: Raegan, Bush & cie. have been slowly but surely making things easier for the wealthy and harder for the workers.

Republicans have always used right-wing populism to get their ways (Blaming migrants, blaming LGBT, blaming leftists). Notice how pro-businesss policies are the only consistent trait between GOP presidency.

Trump is a turning point, he is the first one to do right-wing populism for its own sake instead of simply being pro-business. This is fascism. Here is my preferred definition of fascism if you seek one [1].

Trump is no singular phenomenon, you can compare him in some ways to previous or contemporary fascists: Putin, Mussolini... They all have in common a support from the oligarchy, and a hatred of minorities and leftists.

Until we fix the power imbalances of our democracies and rid it of all money's influence (easier said than done), we will suffer through fascism every 80 years or so. The time it takes for new oligarchs to emerge and accumulate the wealth necessary to dictate politics again.

[1] https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1995/06/22/ur-fascism/

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by analog31 on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:54AM (#43936782)
No. We did not elect the party majority in Congress or the Supreme Court. If anything, the weakness of our constitution has spoken.

Take this as a lesson, and defend your democracy while you still can.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by tgv on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:03AM (#43936897)
Maybe somewhat indirectly, but the US population did elect those people in the usual sense of the word.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by analog31 on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:06AM (#43937610)
They "elected" candidates who were chosen for them.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by 0xTJ on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:27AM (#43937896)
They chose between two candidates chosen via the US presidential primaries. Party members vote for delegates, who vote for a presidential candidate. Republicans chose Trump, then people who voted Republican at the election chose him over the alternative=.

He did not hide his fascist and dictatorial desires and he was open about how he wanted to dismantle the government. When he lost in 2020 he threw a fit and tried to have people do a coup. People did in fact elect him, I can just hope that his actions don't leave too much lasting damage here in Canada. (Maybe de-funding US science will help start to reverse decades of brain drain.)

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by cvwright on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:14PM (#43939627)
Nitpick: Only one candidate was chosen by voters in the primary.

The other was selected by party leaders after the primary was over.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by insane_dreamer on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:06AM (#43937609)
We elected the Prez and Senate majority who appointed 3 SC justices, "flipping" the Court hard right. So yeah, we own that too :/
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by 0cf8612b2e1e on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:24PM (#43940568)
After the head of the senate refused to let the president submit a new SC justice.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by warkdarrior on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:30PM (#43941530)
The head of the senate was elected, so presumably his actions reflected the wishes of his constituents.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by insane_dreamer on Friday May 09, 2025 @06:58PM (#43941699)
Yes but the Prez was blocked from carrying out the wishes of his constituents (on a terrible argument and on that surprise surprise McConnell reversed his position on once Trump was in).
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by stock_toaster on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:01PM (#43942073)
Indeed. McConnell has done an incredible amount of damage to America over the course of his time as a Senator (blocking supreme court nominations, refusing to call witnesses during the first Trump impeachment, use of the filibuster, delaying/obstructing health reforms, and on and on). Quite incredible, in a way (depressing).
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by insane_dreamer on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:46PM (#43942322)
I detest what he did and agree his actions were very damaging to the US both short and long term, but I have to admire his political abilities.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by tstrimple on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:40PM (#43941954)
Ultimately this is the problem. Conservative voters are the problem. They always have been from fighting to maintain slavery to fighting against women's suffrage to fighting against civil rights to fighting against LGBQT rights. People like Trump wouldn't matter if it wasn't for the tens of millions of conservative voters who support him and who cheer this bullshit on.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by Findeton on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:54PM (#43942044)
Trump is a reaction to what was there before him (and in between). Perhaps Obama/Biden were not that bad in comparison, but they went too far in one direction and now the reaction is going too far in the other direction.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by LightBug1 on Saturday May 10, 2025 @05:57AM (#43944442)
That tan suit still grinding your goat?

I jest. I get what you're saying, but I didn't see any real extremism in the O/B eras (clarify for me). I do see extremism, outright incompetence (again), and exponential grift with Trump. It's so obvious.

I don't agree with your pendulum analogy.

My experience looking on has been this: the D's front a President and they make good/shit calls on each issue, and overall the USA continues, possibly marginally improving if you're lucky.

R's kiss Trumps ass and let him absolutely ruin the USA.

That's not a pendulum. That's willingly letting extremist thiefs ruin the USA at any chance they get. And the R party being silent about it when it happens.

I wouldn't call that a pendulum. I'd call that a tragedy and a democracy about to fail and fall into the hands of autocracy / kakistocracy, transactionally-funded and given sucour by the oligarchs.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by trealira on Saturday May 10, 2025 @10:08AM (#43945761)
Obama was like the Democratic version of Mitt Romney. To equate him with Trump is, bluntly, stupid. If the US stays a democracy, and a Democrat is ever elected as president again, one day we will get a leftist Trump who breaks the law as much as Trump does and is as cruel and stupid as Trump is, and then we really will be dithering back and forth between two extremes like a Latin American country post-dictatorship.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by bdangubic on Saturday May 10, 2025 @10:15AM (#43945813)
If Trump went too far in the other direction at the same scale as Obama and Biden did we wouldn’t be talking about him other than made up shit politicians feed you so you talk about stupid social wars/issues instead of real issues in this country
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by 0xbadcafebee on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:42AM (#43938104)
Don't be sympathetic to us. We could rise up and stop it; we choose not to. It only just occurred to me that empires fall not because of leaders, but because of people letting its leaders tear it all down. Take us as a cautionary tale; if you don't participate in reform, this is what can happen.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by wussboy on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:51AM (#43936752)
Unfortunately, the benefit of democracy isn’t that the people choose well. It’s that they can choose at all.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by i80and on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:10AM (#43937668)
Compounding the misfortune, it seems people are easily talked into choosing to not have to choose anymore
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by zkmon on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:22AM (#43937124)
America is almost like two separate countries with full animosity and opposite ideologies. But they can never have the luxury of having their own ruler.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by NoMoreNicksLeft on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:28AM (#43937182)
I think that we decided over 100 years ago that an amicable divorce was out of the question. So what now?
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by alabastervlog on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:34AM (#43937252)
Not a lot of people with any amount of power are even talking about trying to fix the problems that are shoving us toward autocracy, and there's not really a workable way to fix them anyway. What it'd take is just not in the cards (step one would be radically changing the makeup of the Supreme Court, so...)

"What now" is we keep getting closer to autocracy until we're unambiguously fully there, or a less-than-amicable divorce. That's about it. The former is by far the more likely of the two.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by ahmeneeroe-v2 on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:38AM (#43938033)
>Your democracy has spoken

And what is your democracy saying? Unless you're from China, your country is further behind the US

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by philipwhiuk on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:14PM (#43939079)
This an incredibly ill-informed take. Behind in what? Child poverty? Leisure time per person? Quality of life? Average life expectancy?
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by jjice on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:50AM (#43936731)
Maybe pedantic, but the US as a whole didn't vote for it in the 2016 election. Clinton won the popular vote in 2016, but Trump had more electoral votes.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_United_States_presidentia...

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by _djo_ on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:34AM (#43937256)
Unfortunately a majority of American voters saw what happened in the first Trump term and decided that they wanted more of it, with even fewer controls and restrictions.

The OP is correct, Americans collectively own this just as other countries' nationals have owned responsibility for the bad governments they've put into power. If the general response is one of absolving themselves of responsibility there won't be the necessary level of reflection and reform to prevent it from happening again.

As it is the damage done to US power and credibility will take decades to fix, and it's only 100 days in.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by jjice on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:20AM (#43937791)
> If the general response is one of absolving themselves of responsibility there won't be the necessary level of reflection and reform to prevent it from happening again.

Where did I absolve anything? I just corrected something that was wrong. I didn't vote for the guy either time, I don't like this either.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by _djo_ on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:26AM (#43937884)
I didn't direct that at you, but at the general response of the American public. Apologies for not making that clear.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by jjice on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:03PM (#43938335)
Apologies for my earlier response being curt - I totally get it.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by timschmidt on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:02AM (#43937561)
> Unfortunately a majority of American voters saw what happened in the first Trump term and decided that they wanted more of it, with even fewer controls and restrictions.

I'm not sure this accurately conveys the situation. American voters have been dissatisfied with the lesser of two evils choice foisted upon them every 4 years for decades. We're 75 years into endless wars. Massive numbers of union high paying jobs have been shipped overseas since the 80s hollowing out the middle and working class.

One could easily see the votes as being more anti-establishment than anything else.

edit: I love how people downvote comments they don't like in political discussions, even when they're just attempting to foster understanding by sharing a perspective, and not prescriptive or pejorative in any way.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by aaronbaugher on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:18AM (#43937777)
That's what a lot of it was. In 2016, the establishment was offering us a choice between another Bush and another Clinton, with Cruz being set up as the Buchanan, the conservative who would be allowed to win a state or two before gracefully stepping aside for the real nominee. So voters said screw this, we'll take a shot on the guy who might be crazy, rather than just another one of the same gang.

Surprisingly to many of them, he wasn't crazy, and actually tried to do a lot of the things they were hoping a non-establishment president would do. But then the bureaucracy dragged its feet, ignored his orders, and generally did its best to spoil his first term, giving a middle finger to the voters and saying, "Screw you, we're doing things our way." So in 2024 the voters said, "No, screw you," and here we are.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by timschmidt on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:35AM (#43937997)
I've spent most of my life voting green. I don't see myself as closely affiliated with either dems or republicans. I find that there are policies each of them engage in that I agree and disagree with. I really appreciate substantive discussion of policy. Which there seems to be less and less of every year, and more and more each side seems to be arguing and fighting against their own boogey-man version of the other side. Skewed, stretched, and exaggerated to extremes in a meme-laden propaganda war against each other.

I find that this does little to help either side understand the (often legitimate!) concerns of the other. It seems like there is an inexorable wedge being driven between both sides, by both sides. I'm not sure how we address that. And I'm not sure how to reconcile the factors which drive each side without addressing it.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by malcolmgreaves on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:31PM (#43938639)
> Surprisingly to many of them, he wasn't crazy, and actually tried to do a lot of the things they were hoping a non-establishment president would do.

Incorrect. Stop lying.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by _djo_ on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:09AM (#43937654)
I'm sorry, but that sounds like an excuse.

Yes, when you have to vote between the lesser of two evils, but one of them is blatantly more evil and incompetent than the other, you're responsible for choosing the more evil and incompetent option and the damage that results.

No system is perfect, and few countries provide morally and politically pure options to vote for in national elections. So an informed and engaged population often needs to vote tactically, understanding that establishments change slowly, and work to elect more effective candidates at local & state level who can work their way up to the national stage.

Voting in the anti-establishment choice just because voters are upset that progress is slow and politics is hard is the stuff of tantrums, and voting adults are supposed to be beyond that.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by timschmidt on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:24AM (#43937858)
It seems like you're trying to argue and assign blame.

I'm not here for that. Just explaining what I understand of what the blue collar folks I know are thinking.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by _djo_ on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:30AM (#43937934)
Not trying to argue, though blame is deserved for those who voted for Trump this time around.

I'm not saying that out of anger, that's just the nature of democracy and that the corollary of a voting public being able to choose their leaders means they're responsible when they make bad choices. That, in turn should trigger national debates, reflection, and reform hopefully, else the US will continue to head down an ever-increasingly authoritarian and populist path.

I certainly don't want the US to go down that path, nor do I enjoy seeing the damage being done now. I just believe that if we coddle voters who made terrible political choices they're just going to keep making those bad choices election after election.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by timschmidt on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:38AM (#43938034)
I think it's worthwhile to consider that what you said here:

> Not trying to argue, though blame is deserved for those who voted for Trump this time around.

> I'm not saying that out of anger, that's just the nature of democracy and that the corollary of a voting public being able to choose their leaders means they're responsible when they make bad choices. That, in turn should trigger national debates, reflection, and reform hopefully, else the US will continue to head down an ever-increasingly authoritarian and populist path.

Is almost to a word how the Right feels about the Left as well. We're watching that play out. Conflict escalation is even less fun on the societal scale.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by _djo_ on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:49AM (#43938172)
This isn't a right or left issue, and I'm not even an American. I have no political affiliation here except seeing a country I've long admired facing a profound challenge. This is about significant portions of American voters turning away from established institutions—the scientific community, professional civil service, and constitutional checks and balances that have been foundational to American strength.

I could maybe understand why people voted for the anti-establishment candidate the first time around. Legitimate frustrations exist with a system many felt wasn't working for them. But the second time around, with clear evidence of the consequences, is not defensible and shouldn't be excused.

This is a form of reactionary populism and it's deeply dangerous for the US's power, prosperity, and political freedoms. Ask Argentinians what Peronism, as another form of anti-establishment populism, did for them. There are countless other examples to learn from too.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by timschmidt on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:53AM (#43938212)
I am American. Most of the people I know are also American. I'm trying to tell you why lots of my fellow Americans voted this way. aaronbaugher's comment in this thread is also insightful.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by _djo_ on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:11PM (#43938417)
I understand why many Americans voted that way, I’m just saying that they are responsible for the inevitable consequences.

Regardless of motivation, electoral choices have consequences that voters collectively own.

Again, it’s not like we haven’t seen this before in other countries that have voted in populists. It’s always the same cycle: Widespread dissatisfaction promotes populists who correctly identify legitimate problems but offer implausibly simple solutions to solve them. Voters choose the populists out of anger & frustration, only to find that they can’t solve the problems but create the kind of institutional damage that reduces the ability of any successors to solve those problems.

Trump is a populist and we’re already seeing that institutional damage merely 100 days in. There’s no indication that the outcome will be any better than all the other historical parallels.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by timschmidt on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:32PM (#43938643)
> only to find that they can’t solve the problems but create the kind of institutional damage that reduces the ability of any successors to solve those problems.

I watch all sorts of news. Ultra-liberal Democracy Now!, CNN, ABC, NBC, podcasts on the left and right, right-leaning Fox, etc.

I can say that the right is cheering perceived win after win. From their perspective, tariffs are bringing manufacturing jobs back, what they see as corruption is being rooted out, government is being made leaner, more efficient, and more local. Law is being enforced.

The left seems to be focused on publicizing what they see as losses, assuming that the right will inevitably see the self-evident error of their ways. I don't think this is likely to happen.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by MyOutfitIsVague on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:42PM (#43938743)
Small correction: A plurality voted for Trump, not a majority. A majority is more than half of all votes. Trump got less than 50% of votes, he just got more than any other candidate, which is a plurality.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by oldprogrammer2 on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:27PM (#43938595)
In my opinion, this was decades in the making. Most Americans are sick of the two party system that can't seem to get anything done, as well as with a political system owned by the elite. As odd and bizarre as it is, Trump was able to channel that disgruntlement into a voting bloc. And it certainly doesn't help that the Democratic party has been unable to put forth a charismatic candidate since President Obama.
Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by LightBug1 on Saturday May 10, 2025 @06:44AM (#43944651)
Is charisma really "it" though?

Are Americans really that shallow that they'll take borderline autocracy / actual-kakistocracy / full-on corruption over dull and possibly mediocre competence?

If so, as I said, the US people own this.

OWN IT. This isn't the Dems fault.

I don't say that to blame you. I say it in the sense that taking responsibility is not sitting back in your arm chair and blaming the Dems, it's recognising the issue and doing something about it.

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by tomhow on Saturday May 10, 2025 @09:47AM (#43945591)
Please don't post nationalistic flamebait to HN threads. It just leads to flamewar hell, which is the primary thing we're trying to avoid here.

This isn't the first time we've had to ask you to adhere to the guidelines. If you up this style of commenting, we'll have to ban the account.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:NSF faces shake-up as officials abolish its 37 divisions by LightBug1 on Tuesday May 13, 2025 @06:19AM (#43971399)
Seriously. With the greatest respect. Fuck off.

Your wanker president is THE issue of the day. It impacts everything.

It's not a flamewar hell to express that and want to talk about it.

If you can't handle in your orange little world, you know what to do.