News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Facebook comments is a bad idea for your site by dredmorbius on Thursday August 16, 2012 @11:08AM (#4391612)
Your data do also inherently self-select unless you're conducting your research very carefully. Once you throw up a "FB required for comments" requirement, you're going to start shooing away many people who'd otherwise be interested in participating. Some/many will simply never come back.

FB has a penetration of roughly 50% of the population in first world developed nations, and that seems to be its zenith (usage has actually started falling in the US and other early-adopter regions). So you're excluding roughly half your potential participants.

How the FB usage pattern distributes across your target/desirable population is of course another question. I don't have the answers on that.

Re:Why Facebook comments is a bad idea for your site by franze on Friday August 17, 2012 @03:34PM (#4398322)
as i said before: i would love that somebody comes up with a better study and proves my mini sample wrong, sadly i know none.

i did a similar research of fb enabled signeups vs. non fb signups (on desktop web apps) - outcome: if you enable signups via fb, you get more signed up users.

i think the pro/con fb comments/signups discussion should be based on data (data that is easy to get on our own webproperties) and not on opinions.