This reasoning seems flawed to me: He seems to not understand that the rational choice for individuals acting independently is often not rational for the group as a whole. The Prisoner's dilemma, Bank runs etc. are all examples of how this can happen.
If everyone else is in danger of selling and pushing the price down, you're better off selling now before that happens... and of course, everyone else would reason the same way, making it a self fulfilling prophecy.
If the shareholders had some way to collaborate and agree collectively to not sell now, his statement might be correct - but I doubt this is even legal even if it was feasible.
Of course, if you're in it for the long haul, then other people's opinions of the stock price shouldn't matter: you just buy/sell facebook stock based on whether you think the future expected dividends justify the investment.
The interesting problem here is what employees will decide to do. It's not obvious that Facebook stock will go up any time soon. It's probably a reasonable thing for employees to diversify their holdings (which means liquidating a large portion of their facebook stock). It will be interesting to see how individual employee decisions end up pushing the stock price.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Logic_of_Collective_Action
So that may be contributing to the selloff today
"Facebook, worth $51.2 billion, has lost about $40 billion in market value since the IPO, making it the worst performer among all large IPOs on record, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
. . . .
"'It certainly wouldn’t behoove and wouldn’t be in the shareholders’ best interest to dump the shares on the market all at once,' [Harding] said. 'I would assume that all of the investors that hold the 270 million-odd shares are probably rational, and probably realize that flooding the market with that kind of supply over such a short amount of time wouldn’t help their position.'"
By contrast with Mark Harding, the analyst at JMP Securities LLC quoted in the article, I would keep in mind the old saying "The market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent," and be very concerned about other investors looking out for Number One and thus depressing the price of Facebook stock for all other holders of Facebook stock. Over the next several weeks or months, those of us who are looking on (I don't own any Facebook stock) will see what the various investors decide. Thus far, all the trading activity seems to agree in general that Facebook shares will not recover their IPO price any time soon.