News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by kiicia on Monday May 05, 2025 @03:48PM (#43898744)
> Mathematicians Weinan Lin, Guozhen Wang, and Zhouli Xu have proven that 126-dimensional space can contain exotic, twisted shapes known as manifolds with a Kervaire invariant of 1—solving a 65-year-old problem in topology. These manifolds, previously known to exist only in dimensions 2, 6, 14, 30, and 62, cannot be smoothed into spheres and were the last possible case under what’s called the “doomsday hypothesis.” Their existence in dimension 126 was confirmed using both theoretical insights and complex computer calculations, marking a major milestone in the study of high-dimensional geometric structures.
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by hinkley on Monday May 05, 2025 @04:39PM (#43899230)
So these are all powers of 2 minus 2, and it looks like from the article that the pattern doesn’t exist in 2^8 - 2 or higher. Is there any description a layperson might understand as to why it stops instead of going on forever!
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by robinhouston on Monday May 05, 2025 @06:58PM (#43900231)
The proof that it stops instead of going on forever is here: https://arxiv.org/abs/0908.3724

It’s more than 200 pages of pretty technical mathematics, so I’m reasonably confident that there is no description a layperson might understand.

Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by _factor on Monday May 05, 2025 @07:26PM (#43900376)
Yet.

There was no reasonable description for hypotenuse length before the theorem.

Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by thaumasiotes on Monday May 05, 2025 @07:43PM (#43900499)
What? "The longest side of a triangle" isn't a challenging concept to understand or describe.
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by john-h-k on Monday May 05, 2025 @08:10PM (#43900666)
It’s pretty clear they mean in a very strict mathematical sense. The layman can define a hypotenuse but the layman is rarely working in 126 dimensions
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by thaumasiotes on Monday May 05, 2025 @08:20PM (#43900712)
Who are you talking about? The entire claim was "there was no reasonable description for hypotenuse length before the theorem"; I assume the Pythagorean theorem is intended. But that claim is crazy. You just contradicted it yourself.

I should note that hypotenuses look no different in 126 dimensions than they do in 2 - three points determine a plane, regardless of how big the space containing the plane might be - but that's not really relevant to anything here.

Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by john-h-k on Monday May 05, 2025 @08:26PM (#43900741)
Sorry, yes, that was a major misunderstanding of the previous comment by me. I am utterly wrong!
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by janalsncm on Monday May 05, 2025 @09:34PM (#43901058)
(The longest side of a right triangle)
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by thaumasiotes on Monday May 05, 2025 @10:08PM (#43901197)
If you believe that you can only subtend a 90 degree angle, sure.

("Subtend" is a direct part-for-part translation of the verb which also gives us the name "hypotenuse".)

Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by hugh-avherald on Monday May 05, 2025 @10:45PM (#43901338)
(from the nearby toilet cubicle) "That's a right triangle, ya idiot!"
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by thejazzman on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @03:59AM (#43902716)
D'oh!
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by klysm on Monday May 05, 2025 @09:56PM (#43901146)
I assume you mean the Pythagorean theorem, and by description you mean equation?
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by _factor on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @03:53AM (#43902696)
I was trying to be vague to see how pedantic the audience here is when the meaning of a statement can be easily inferred from context. Seems very.
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by TomJansen on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @12:03PM (#43906666)
"I was only pretending to be stupid!"
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by _factor on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @01:54PM (#43907841)
Being vague/ambiguous and sounding stupid are two different things.
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by klysm on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @09:40PM (#43911426)
I think there’s probably already enough information out there to see how pedantic the typical audience is here ;)
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by tomhow on Wednesday May 07, 2025 @12:12AM (#43912206)
We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43900231 and marked it offtopic.

Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.

Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by codebje on Monday May 05, 2025 @05:17PM (#43899543)
They’re all double the last dimension plus two, without skipping any in that sequence - but that offers no insight into why it wouldn’t hold for 254.
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by aleph_minus_one on Monday May 05, 2025 @06:48PM (#43900179)
> They’re all double the last dimension plus two, without skipping any in that sequence - but that offers no insight into why it wouldn’t hold for 254.

Wikipedia at least gives a literature reference and concise explanation for the reason:

> https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Kervaire_invarian...

"Hill, Hopkins & Ravenel (2016) showed that the Kervaire invariant is zero for n-dimensional framed manifolds for n = 2^k− 2 with k ≥ 8. They constructed a cohomology theory Ω with the following properties from which their result follows immediately:

* The coefficient groups Ω^n(point) have period 2^8 = 256 in n

* The coefficient groups Ω^n(point) have a "gap": they vanish for n = -1, -2, and -3

* The coefficient groups Ω^n(point) can detect non-vanishing Kervaire invariants: more precisely if the Kervaire invariant for manifolds of dimension n is nonzero then it has a nonzero image in Ω^{−n}(point)"

Paper:

Hill, Michael A.; Hopkins, Michael J.; Ravenel, Douglas C. (2016). "On the nonexistence of elements of Kervaire invariant one"

* https://arxiv.org/abs/0908.3724

* https://annals.math.princeton.edu/2016/184-1/p01

Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by foobahhhhh on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @12:26AM (#43901805)
Here is my guess. Number of dimensions is more like a hyperparameter than a parameter. Each time you increase the dimension by 1 you get a new world. You cane expect a simple pattern to go on forever.
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by TZubiri on Monday May 05, 2025 @07:24PM (#43900361)
Can't wait to read up on volume 127 of the Dimension periodical.
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by mouse_ on Monday May 05, 2025 @07:40PM (#43900472)
ah yes, now I understand completely
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by Aardwolf on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @04:25AM (#43902823)
What does a 2D manifold with a Kervaire invariant of 1 look like?

I only found a technical article that didn't show any images at all, and 3D looking images in image search

Visually seeing a 2D one might help understand what it is though, and it shouldn't be too bad to render something in 2 dimensions :)

Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by enriquepablo on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @04:59AM (#43903023)
The article shows one, the kind of double torus - though I do not understand how neighbourhoods that intersect the line of contact between the 2 "tubes" can be mapped to R².
Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by Aardwolf on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @06:57AM (#43903696)
Ok I see, it's a 2D shape in 3D space, you actually need the 3th dimension to contain this shape... At least I find that there's s distinction between a 2D shape you can draw on a 2D screen (like a filled rectangle or a disk), and a shape that's a 2D surface itself but requires 3-dimensional space to sit in (like a torus/donut or a non-filled 2-sphere)

So I guess the 126-dimensional shape actually also is in 127-dimensional space then

But the article says "Over the years, mathematicians found that the twisted shapes exist in dimensions 2, 6, 14, 30 and 62.".

To me "Exists in dimension 2" sounds like a shape in 2D space, not in 3D space, but apparently that's not what they mean and the way I understand this language is wrong

Re:Dimension 126 Contains Twisted Shapes, Mathematicians Prove by gus_massa on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @07:59AM (#43904104)
> So I guess the 126-dimensional shape actually also is in 127-dimensional space then

Sometimes you need more dimensions to embed the manifold. For a 2-dimencional object, the most famous example is the Klein bottle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Klein_bottle You can construct one of them in 3-dimmension only if you cheat. Yhey look nice and you can buy a few cheating-versions. But you can embed the Klein bottle in 4-dimensions (without cheating).

For the manifold in the article, I'm not sure how many additional dimensions you need. Perhaps 127 (n+1) is enough or perhaps you need 252 (2n) or perhaps something in between. You can always embed an n-dimensional manifold in the 2n space, but that is the worst case. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whitney_embedding_theorem