News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by triceratops on Monday May 05, 2025 @11:54AM (#43896436)
> But also, you are allowed to make them.

Not of physical media. You're allowed to make archival copies of digital media.

> Or reading a book via a computer would be illegal

No you purchased a license (or your library did, in the case of e-borrowing) to read the book on a computer. That makes it legal.

Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by Dylan16807 on Monday May 05, 2025 @12:02PM (#43896504)
I am allowed to point a webcam at my physical book and read off the screen, even though that makes digital copies of all the text.
Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by triceratops on Monday May 05, 2025 @12:13PM (#43896608)
FWIW the essence of copyright law AIUI is: copying is not permitted, unless done in a form explicitly allowed by the license holder.

This scenario seems quite contrived but is there an actual court precedent allowing it? I'm 100% confident no one will ever prosecute you for doing it but that's not the same thing as "allowed".

In another thread I already posted about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Broadcasting_Cos.,_In....

This case was about pointing <recording equipment> at <content someone is allowed to access> and making a copy to transmit it to <that person>. The Supreme Court held it to be illegal. There was a lot of money on the line, which is why it went so far.

Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by Dylan16807 on Monday May 05, 2025 @12:19PM (#43896685)
As far as I can tell there is also a principle that you can have ephemeral copies as part of handling and processing the work.

Your example involves transmission and mine doesn't, and that's a whole different can of worms.

Also the result of that case was self-contradicting so it's not a great basis to build too much logic upon.

Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by triceratops on Monday May 05, 2025 @12:26PM (#43896772)
> there is also a principle that you can have ephemeral copies as part of handling and processing the work.

I'm not aware of this principle. Where is it spelled out?

> Also the result of that case was self-contradicting

I agree the verdict was a travesty. An innovative business went to ridiculous lengths to stay on the right side of the copyright mafia (data centers with tiny individual TV antennas for each subscriber FFS!) while providing a better product and experience. They still had the hammer brought down on them.

Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by Dylan16807 on Monday May 05, 2025 @12:28PM (#43896807)
> I'm not aware of this principle. Where is it spelled out?

Well, do CDs give you a license agreement that allows you to copy the data? I've never seen one. And it's nearly impossible to play a CD without that copying.

Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by triceratops on Monday May 05, 2025 @12:33PM (#43896872)
> And it's nearly impossible to play a CD without that copying.

Exactly. It's how you are supposed to use the CD. That's not true for your example of a book on a webcam. You're supposed to read the book, not an image of the book.

That's not the same thing as copying for "processing".

Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by Dylan16807 on Monday May 05, 2025 @12:36PM (#43896907)
Well you said explicit license earlier.

Would it be a violation to play back a record like a CD and have a digital buffer? That would be pretty silly.

Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by triceratops on Monday May 05, 2025 @01:44PM (#43897550)
> explicit license

Selling you the CD explicitly grants you the right to play it using a CD player.

> Would it be a violation to play back a record like a CD and have a digital buffer?

I genuinely have no idea lol.