News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by alangibson on Monday May 05, 2025 @11:38AM (#43896241)
> AI doesn't actually directly copy the material it trains on, so it's not easy to make this ruling.

IANAL, but it doesn't look that hard. On first glance this is a fair use issue.

What an LLM spits out is pretty clearly transformative use. But the fact that it pulls not only the entirety of the work, but the entirety of MOST works means that the amount is way beyond what could be fair use. Plus it's commercial use. Put it together and all LLMs are way illegal.

Re:Judge said Meta illegally used books to build its AI by Dylan16807 on Monday May 05, 2025 @11:45AM (#43896323)
> the fact that it pulls not only the entirety of the work

What do you mean by "pulls"?

What matters in traditional fair use is how substantially your output copies the work (among other factors). Your input is generally assumed to be reading/watching/listening to the entire work, and there is no problem with that.