News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by ujkhsjkdhf234 on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:12PM (#43881355)
This is true of a lot of our food. Trump, now and in 2016, has been trying to force the UK to buy US chicken and the Brits are NOT having it because US food standards are below that of the UK.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by gruez on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:22PM (#43881410)
>Trump, now and in 2016, has been trying to force the UK to buy US chicken and the Brits are NOT having it because US food standards are below that of the UK.

Why not let the consumers decide for themselves? If consumers really "are NOT having it", then the UK government wouldn't need to ban US chlorine chicken?

Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by ujkhsjkdhf234 on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:29PM (#43881460)
The UK has very strict requirements around certain foods that their farmers have to meet. Allowing US farmers to bypass those requirements will undercut those domestic farmers and while individual consumers may still opt for the more expensive domestic option, restaurants and takeout businesses will usually opt for the cheapest option which introduces it to the country even if the consumers don't want it. It's not like McDonalds has a sign that says "Made with US Chicken!" on your nuggets. Secondly, allowing cheap US chicken just penalizes the poorest in your country that will go for the cheapest option to survive. Some people don't have choice and food standards help bring the bottom up.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by gruez on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:38PM (#43881532)
>restaurants and takeout businesses will usually opt for the cheapest option which introduces it to the country even if the consumers don't want it

Restaurants are free to advertise that they use domestic chicken. You can even legislate mandatory labeling if you're so inclined. The fact that you think consumers need to be actively prevented from getting US chicken, because they don't have the capacity to decide for themselves contradicts your claim that "Brits are NOT having it".

Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by ujkhsjkdhf234 on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:40PM (#43881563)
It really doesn't but you're free to think that the only way to determine that is to allow complete free market access and just see what happens.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by blibble on Saturday May 03, 2025 @05:11PM (#43882356)
and it's not a free market, the animals are fed with federally subsidised corn

it's classic dumping, the sort that Trump gets upset about

Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by kyralis on Saturday May 03, 2025 @04:20PM (#43881923)
This is the silliness of the pure free-market libertarianism, with its stray man of "oh, you're being paternal and saying they can't decide for themselves!".

No. A society, which has chosen its government, has decided that it would like to outsource the individual work of tracking food provenance and safety in the form of ensuring that the only food available is food that meets the standards that the society has decided to set.

This is specialization at work, which is in fact one of the primary drivers of civilization and progress.

No one is saying that people can't make these decisions by themselves. People are saying they do not want to, especially in an environment that is heavily information-asymmetric.

I'm a well-educated, intelligent software engineer. Sure, I could go looking into the details of the production facility for all of the meat that I buy, maybe, at the grocery store - but I certainly don't want to. And if I go to a restaurant, I absolutely do not want to have to spend hours researching their supply chain first.

This is not incapacity. This is intelligent division of labor.

Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by 8note on Saturday May 03, 2025 @04:54PM (#43882228)
you can look at canadian stores as of late, which are taking to relabelling "made in the USA" with maple leaf stickers.

the US is free to make non-chlorine chicken, and then sell it to places that demad non-chlorine chicken

Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by cjs_ac on Saturday May 03, 2025 @05:33PM (#43882518)
> It's not like McDonalds has a sign that says "Made with US Chicken!" on your nuggets.

I'm not sure whether this is still the case, but the cardboard boxes that McDonald's packages its burgers in in Australia used to have '100% Aussie beef' printed on them, but the beef was actually imported from South America by a wholly-McDonald's-owned subsidiary called '100% Aussie'.

Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by distances on Sunday May 04, 2025 @02:48AM (#43885001)
I have hard time believing this actually happened. Any references?
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by ocharles on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:26PM (#43881446)
Because we know the implications of poor quality food, and we also know those who would buy it have no choice but to buy the cheapest. So, no thanks. I'd much rather the state intervene here and keep this crap out. This "let consumers choose" argument is tiring when consumers don't have the ability to choose. They are just trying to survive
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by gruez on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:34PM (#43881505)
>and we also know those who would buy it have no choice but to buy the cheapest. So, no thanks. I'd much rather the state intervene here and keep this crap out.

Having "the state intervene here and keep this crap out" isn't going to magically make the domestic chicken cheaper for those people who "have no choice". You're not improving the chicken quality for them, you're preventing them from buying chicken at all.

Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by throwaway173738 on Saturday May 03, 2025 @04:34PM (#43882055)
They’ve decided as a group that they would rather people eat less better quality food than more poorer quality food. I don’t understand the hang up. Is it the idea that people can collectively decide something? Presumably if it’s such a big problem people in the UK can elect a different government.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by 8note on Saturday May 03, 2025 @04:57PM (#43882249)
even poor people are able to manage and prioritize their spending.

in america, you could just sell the ultra poor people a piece of dirt you picked off the ground for a couple cents. theyre still buying "chicken" but its not at all what people want when theyre wanting to buy chicken.

Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by spauldo on Sunday May 04, 2025 @12:25AM (#43884482)
Why do you suppose that chicken quality would be tied to price? Do you know where your chicken comes from? If you buy expensive, high quality chicken, do you know it's actually high quality and not just a fancier package with a higher price tag? Do you want to research every single product you eat to make sure it's safe?

I sure don't.

Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by YawningAngel on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:32PM (#43881484)
We have decided, we elected a government and had it pass food safety laws.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by gruez on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:49PM (#43881632)
I'm not claiming such food safety laws are illegitimate, I'm only claiming that the idea that British consumers have rejected chicken is laughable, as evidenced by the government feeling the need to ban them.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by blibble on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:55PM (#43881709)
> I'm only claiming that the idea that British consumers have rejected chicken is laughable

it's not laughable, it's a huge political point mentioned constantly

the average UK consumer specifically does not want US products entering our food supply

Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by wood_spirit on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:48PM (#43881622)
Chlorinated chicken has become a big talking point in the UK and there is overwhelming public support for continued ban.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by MandieD on Saturday May 03, 2025 @05:10PM (#43882347)
Same deal in Germany - if you asked a German about American chicken, I can almost guarantee you that "Chlorhuhn" would be their first response.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by blibble on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:54PM (#43881690)
because the US always insists on changing labeling rules so consumers can't

even if this wasn't the case, the substandard US product will end up replacing UK product in everything that isn't labelled (processed foods)

Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by sorokod on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:30PM (#43881466)
They kinda did using that representative democracy gizmo
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by gruez on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:41PM (#43881568)
And the problem of concentrated benefits (for domestic chicken farmers) and diffuse costs (for everyone else) is a well known problem for democracy. If you're going to invoke this, you might as well also argue that Americans are "are not having trade imbalances", because they elected Trump.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by ujkhsjkdhf234 on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:49PM (#43881628)
Domestic farmers are not all in the same company. They compete amongst each other under the same set of rules they must all abide by. I have no idea why they would agree to sell an inferior product that doesn't have to abide by the same set of rules.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by 8note on Saturday May 03, 2025 @04:58PM (#43882262)
america is not a democracry though, its a union of states.

the states have decided to address the trade imbalance, rather than the people

Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by gopher_space on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:34PM (#43881499)
Why would a citizen want their representatives to allow bad meat into the country? What would their thought process be here?
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by Zigurd on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:30PM (#43881465)
Why enable a race to the bottom? They don't take our dubious food colorings, either.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by gruez on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:46PM (#43881616)
The whole idea of "race to the bottom" implies at least some portion consumers are going to choose the inferior product, which directly contradicts the original claim that British consumers have rejected US chicken, and the US needs to force them to buy it.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by inetknght on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:53PM (#43881680)
> The whole idea of "race to the bottom" implies at least some portion consumers are going to choose the inferior product

Yup.

> directly contradicts the original claim that British consumers have rejected US chicken

No it doesn't.

> the US needs to force them to buy it

Why let the US force foreigners to buy an inferior product?

Better solution: block inferior products from being imported. Then people choose to purchase not-inferior products.

Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by ujkhsjkdhf234 on Saturday May 03, 2025 @03:51PM (#43881645)
You're one of these people that get off on being technically correct even though it has no value to the discussion at large. No, 100% of Brits were not surveyed and all said no and as I said in another comment, the poorest of the country would likely buy it because it would be the cheapest option.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by Zigurd on Saturday May 03, 2025 @06:39PM (#43882955)
This kind of bunk is why I outgrew being a libertarian four decades ago. Transparency, anti-fraud laws, and standards make markets work. Fantasies about "network states" do not.
Re:Deadly Screwworm Parasite's Comeback Threatens Texas Catt... by merrywhether on Saturday May 03, 2025 @04:51PM (#43882208)
While we’re at it, why not let manufacturers reintroduce lead into paint and toys and let consumers choose what they want there too? The problem is that “consumer choice” is frequently a shield for amoral companies to take advantage of information asymmetry to externalize problems onto individuals. Individual consumers do not have time to deeply research every purchase they make and so it is not reasonable to expect them to handle these things themselves. Instead we have the Hobbesian contract where it is much more efficient to empower a government to centralize the handling of these common goals. It’s not smart or edgy to argue for the “free hand of the market” in these one-off topics, because none of these decisions are made in a vacuum but rather are part of a continuum of choices that the governed are mostly happy with (no such safety regime can ever be perfect).