News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by gweinberg on Friday May 02, 2025 @04:19PM (#43874197)
Materials that are strong under compression aren't necessarily strong under tension, and vice-versa. I would think teeth (just) need to be really strong under compression, and spider silk really strong under tension.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by e28eta on Friday May 02, 2025 @04:41PM (#43874368)
I was curious about what they meant by strength, and the link at the bottom of the article says this is tensile strength. So the comparison to spider silk was actually appropriate.

I also noticed that it’s from 2015, although it was still new to me and interesting.

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by potato3732842 on Friday May 02, 2025 @04:21PM (#43874216)
Strength per weight vs strength per volume are an issue as well.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by hwillis on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @09:33AM (#43904945)
It's tensile strength, not specific strength. Strength over an area.

There also is no such thing as strength per volume.

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by prmph on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @07:51AM (#43904037)
To be fair tensile strength is more impressive and to me is the only true strength. Water has great compressive strength, and yet is it difficult to think of it as "strong".
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by sk5t on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @08:03AM (#43904130)
Water being mostly incompressible is not the same as having high compressive strength. Liquid water makes for a poor tooth or structural column.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by prmph on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @08:29AM (#43904333)
That's my point; think about it deeply.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by jmillikin on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @08:49AM (#43904504)
You wrote "water has great compressive strength", sk5t directly (and correctly) refuted that claim. What is there to think about?

Are you confusing "compressive strength" with compressibility?

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by stormfather on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @08:57AM (#43904583)
I think his point is that things very rarely experience purely compressive forces. Just being compressed induces tension in other directions, like water being squished out between your clapping hands. So even though water has great compressive strength, in practice this isn't very useful.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by prmph on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @09:11AM (#43904694)
Exactly.

Many materials would have compressive strength easily, just by being relatively uncompressible.

But most loads have a (troublesome) tensile component. Fundamentally, the ability of a rigid material to resist deformation (in the most general sense) is what is most important, and that requires tensile strength.

See this comment elsewhere in this sub-thread that explains it probably better than I did: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43904800

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by prmph on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @09:26AM (#43904872)
Look up the Wikipedia definition [1] of compressive strength:

> In mechanics, compressive strength (or compression strength) is the capacity of a material or structure to withstand loads tending to reduce size (compression). It is opposed to tensile strength which withstands loads tending to elongate, resisting tension (being pulled apart).

Google search AI summary states:

> Compressive strength is a material's capacity to resist forces that try to reduce its volume or cause deformation.

To be fair, compressive strength is a complex measure. Compressibility is only one aspect of it. See this Encyclopedia Britannica article [2] about how compressive strength is tested.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compressive_strength

[2] https://www.britannica.com/technology/compressive-strength-t...

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by jmillikin on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @10:19AM (#43905436)
Nothing that you wrote here indicates you understand what is being discussed.

Water has very low compressive strength, so low that it freely deforms under its own weight. You can observe this by pouring some water onto a table. This behavior is distinct from materials with high compressive strength, such as wood or steel.

(I say "very low" instead of "zero" because surface tension could be considered a type of compressive strength at small scales, such as a single drop of water on a hydrophobic surface)

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by prmph on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @10:52AM (#43905829)
Your comments betrays a lack of comprehension and understanding. Please reads my comments and linked definitions carefully.

See this comment elsewhere in this sub-thread that explains it probably better than I did: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43904800

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by brennanpeterson on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @10:08AM (#43905304)
Please tell me how to make a water prism to test compressive strength and deformation resistance. Water is an incompressible fluid, that is different.

These are well understood terms in the field. Unfortunately, this illustrates the bounds of ai in subfields like materials: it confuses people.

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by prmph on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @10:54AM (#43905856)
I'm not saying water meets the strict definition of a material with high compressive strength (it does meet some, since it resists forces that attempt to decrease its volume well). I am just using as an extreme example of the issues with the concept of compressive strength.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by thatcat on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @03:03PM (#43908544)
lower the temperature
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by cma on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @08:51AM (#43904515)
Very hard to force it to failure into permanent changes in shape.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by blitzar on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @11:42AM (#43906382)
It is useless until you are in a movie gun fight next to a pool / river. At that point jumping into the water is both life saving and cinematic with turbulent bullet trails follwing you in the water but falling just short of you.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by hwillis on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @09:21AM (#43904800)
https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsif.2014.132...

> The tensile strength of discrete volumes of limpet tooth material measured using in situ atomic force microscopy was found to range from 3.0 to 6.5 GPa

Also "compressive strength" is not really a thing, in that it's only a metric that is useful for practical applications. It's proportional to tensile strength, and unlike tensile strength it does not generalize well to things like modeling stress. Tensile strength is a much more fundamental quality than compressive strength.

Strength of a material is force per area. In ideal terms it is measured over an infinitely short length; if you measure over a long distance then the sample is stretched and becomes thinner, changing the measurement. If you test on a shorter and shorter sample you get closer and closer to the ideal value.

The same is not true for compressive strength tests. If you measure compressive strength by pressing on a very very thin disc of material it will just resist all force; it has effectively infinite strength. The actual failure mode of compression is always tensile strength in the radial direction, or buckling or something. You press the sample and it stretches sideways until it exceeds the sample's tensile strength in that direction. The shorter the sample is, the less it can expand radially and the stronger it appears to be. There is no "ideal" compressive strength, only useful test setups.

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by hydrogen7800 on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @09:50AM (#43905111)
>Also "compressive strength" is not really a thing.

This is true, but neither is "tensile strength" really a thing for the same reason. A simple uni-axial tensile test is not really uni-axial, but a combination of orthogonal normal stresses that ultimately results in shear failure. I've heard it said that "all failure is shear failure", and I think that's true. When you look closely at the ductile fracture surface of a ruptured tensile specimen, the characteristic "cupping"[0] appearance consists of various surfaces at 45 degrees from the direction of the applied load. Principle shear stresses are always oriented 45 degrees from the principle normal stresses.

[0]https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/1b/DuctileF...

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by hwillis on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @02:11PM (#43908029)
> This is true, but neither is "tensile strength" really a thing for the same reason.

Well, not the same reason. Shear strength is in many ways more important because failure usually propagates from an origin like a rip- by shearing.

But fundamentally, tensile strength and shear strength are both much more empirical than compressive strength. Tensile strength can be used with ~99% accuracy on a wire that is microns long or miles long. If you double the relative width of a testing sample it will dramatically change the measured compressive strength even without buckling.

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by throw7383753 on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @02:18PM (#43908084)
You could take that further and say that shear does not exist. It's a construct we have created to deal with tension failures in other planes. Everything basically comes down to a truss model. The failure you idealize as a shear stress is really a failure of a tension element in a miniature truss. This is true in bolt shear, scissors, etc.

This is why the code forces you to use strut and tie model deep concrete beams. As much as you may want to idealize a shear stress, really what's happening is the beam is arching over the span.

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by hydrogen7800 on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @02:40PM (#43908298)
Ha, yes! I've even heard some argue that stress isn't even real! Whatever "real" means. Nothing is real; it's models all the way down.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by bozhark on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @07:34PM (#43910752)
All models are wrong… Some are useful
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by rda2 on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @03:12PM (#43908613)
For those who are interested in learning more:

"All failure is shear failure" - this is a simple explanation of Tresca's Yield Criterion. For materials with higher compressive than tensile strength, the equivalent is the Mohr-Coulomb failure criterion.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Material_failure_theory

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by kurthr on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @05:07PM (#43909648)
For a simple example try twisting a ductile aluminum bolt (or clay), twisting a brittle piece of chalk (or concrete), or twisting a composite (twig). They all fail differently (and the first two at 45deg to each other. Mohr's circle is interesting, and fatigue failure more interesting still.

https://youtu.be/1YTKedLQOa0?t=533

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by adrian_b on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @01:29PM (#43907583)
The "infinite" compressive strength for a sample that cannot expand laterally is only an approximation valid for small pressures.

At high enough pressures, all materials change their molecular and crystalline structures into structures with higher densities of atoms per volume and the volume of the tested samples diminishes, so the samples collapse at certain pressure thresholds.

The well known transformation of graphite into diamond is just an example of what happens with any substance at high pressures. Diamond is a more unusual example just because it remains stable even after the pressure that has created it is removed.

Moreover, for non-homogeneous materials, like concrete or many natural rocks used in construction, which are composed of harder particles cemented in a weaker matrix, it is normal to have a tensile strength that is many times smaller than the compressive strength, because when subjected to tension the weaker matrix allows pieces to detach, but in compression the strength may be determined mostly by the threshold where the harder particles break.

The snail teeth are also made of composite materials, mineral crystals in a protein matrix, so they are also likely to have different strengths depending on what kind of stresses are applied and in what directions.

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by throwawee on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @09:21AM (#43904803)
Then the ideal armor must be sea snail teeth woven together with spider silk. This advancement could save millions in mythril and adamantine.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by AndrewOMartin on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @09:40AM (#43905004)
Finally the Druids get a viable endgame armour set!
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by VladVladikoff on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @10:36AM (#43905642)
If you’re into this kind of fantasy bioengineering I highly recommend reading The Tainted Cup and the sequel, A Drop of Corruption. And if anyone has read these, please tell me about any other books in this similar bioengineering genre, or even just highly unique fantasy worlds (I’m just so sick of books about dragons and boring magic).
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by dekhn on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @11:17AM (#43906104)
A long time ago, Harry Harrison wrote a series (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_of_Eden) where dinosaurs weren't wiped out, evolving for millions of years before primates showed up. The dinosaurs have a genetic-engineering based industry.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by yreg on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @11:00AM (#43905913)
Tress of the Emerald Sea is set on quite a unique world. The planet is covered by oceans of magical "spores" which react violently to water.

For example the spores in the Emerald Sea, where the hero is from, instantly grow into massive vines that destroy everything in their path. That makes sailing rather dangerous.

The story is whimsical, perhaps an adult fairy tale (or just a fairy tale?), so I don't know if it fits your taste.

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by doorpheus on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @12:44PM (#43907092)
Try the children of time it's a great scifi book about a spider civilization evolving with all the different tech they create
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by georgeecollins on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @01:21PM (#43907502)
I second the recommendation of Children of Time! A cracking fun novel that goes in some weird directions. Very well realized "aliens" that have their own culture and technology.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by yreg on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @07:03PM (#43910575)
I haven't read it yet, but I keep seeing it recommended on this website again and again, so something about it must be good.

And I think there is one more similar spider civilization book that's also popular – A Deepness in the Sky by Vernor Vinge.

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by foobarbecue on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @01:06PM (#43907362)
You might like some of the Paolo Bacigalupi windup world stuff. Some great belivable ideas, some that go too far beyond belivability for my taste, but I enjoyed it a lot. The basic idea is that there's an advanced society where for some reason electricity & electronics tech was never developed, so mechanical mechanism technology progressed instead.
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by VladVladikoff on Saturday May 10, 2025 @02:42PM (#43947878)
This was an excellent suggestion. Just got to the chapter where Isaac accidentally takes dream shit. Fun book! Thanks!
Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by ozim on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @01:22PM (#43907509)
But how much time to grind is needed and is there close by spawn point for sea snails and spiders or do you have to first get loot from snails and then travel to farm spiders.

So many questions and quests.

Re:Sea snail teeth top Kevlar, titanium as strongest material by lawlessone on Tuesday May 06, 2025 @10:14AM (#43905379)
so we need both to build a space elevator?