News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is AI so popular when nobody wants it? by CobrastanJorji on Tuesday April 29, 2025 @03:40PM (#43837091)
I doubt many people besides Google executives really want Google to summarize your search results.
Re:Why is AI so popular when nobody wants it? by jankeymeulen on Tuesday April 29, 2025 @03:43PM (#43837144)
I was thinking the same, who on earth would want that, so did my technical colleagues, but since the AI summaries rolled out over here, non-technical folks I've asked about it actually seem to like it.
Re:Why is AI so popular when nobody wants it? by falcor84 on Tuesday April 29, 2025 @04:01PM (#43837363)
I'm also a big fan of perplexity, using it for about a quarter of my searches.
Re:Why is AI so popular when nobody wants it? by kstrauser on Tuesday April 29, 2025 @04:35PM (#43837746)
Seriously? I think that's what most people want from a search engine, even if they wouldn't phrase it that way.

Today I heard my wife ask our HomePod which US state was most similar in size to Germany. First, I was absolutely shocked that it gave a useful and correct answer. Well done, little dingus, and sorry to have doubted you. But more relevant, her goal wasn't to do a search. Her goal was to get an answer.

For the most part, people want an answer from Google, not a list of pages that might potentially answer them if they're lucky. Sometimes I do want to see a long list of results I can skim through for the most likely answer, especially if I'm looking for technical details on something. But if I ask "how long do I bake a frozen 20 lb turkey?", I really just want a correct answer.

So maybe people wouldn't actually say they want Google to summarize their search results if you phrased it exactly like that. But I bet most people, most of the time, would say that they wish the thing would just look at the 437 pages of results and tell them the answer.

Re:Why is AI so popular when nobody wants it? by aaronbaugher on Tuesday April 29, 2025 @04:41PM (#43837794)
True. We've gotten used to searching the web being like this: Type in "how long to cook a frozen 20-pound turkey," scroll past a few ads, and then either spot the direct answer in the blurb of one of the results, or see a promising-looking one and click through.

There's a lot of skimming and scanning that we've come to expect as part of the process in locating a piece of information, and we do it quickly with practice, but that doesn't mean it has to be that way.