News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by kragen on Sunday April 27, 2025 @11:56PM (#43817379)
Actually, they all do.
Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by fc417fc802 on Monday April 28, 2025 @01:34AM (#43817928)
Depends on what is meant by high strength. Silverware is a fair point that hadn't occurred to me. Handrails is an interesting one but I suspect it's more cost effective to place a thin contact surface on top of something cheap.

The others I'm not so sure about. I think you'd have corrosion issues with water tanks and bacterial issues there are easily addressed by regulating temperature. And why would heat exchangers require particularly high strength? Since when are those a structural component?

In any case as you said electroplating something cheap is probably the way to go.

Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by kragen on Monday April 28, 2025 @01:52AM (#43818035)
Recuperator-type heat exchangers need high-strength materials because both the strength of a wall and its thermal resistance are proportional to its thickness. So, if you can magically make copper five times stronger, you can make it one fifth as thick, cutting its thermal resistance by a factor of 5 and getting a much better heat exchanger.

As for water tanks, regulating temperature is not always "easy", and a major reason copper is used for water pipes is its great resistance to corrosion. In this case apparently it will be more expensive than the same mass of stainless, but it's apparently also stronger than stainless, so maybe you can use less of it, making it cheaper again.

Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by fc417fc802 on Monday April 28, 2025 @02:14AM (#43818155)
Fair point about water pipe corrosion, my mistake. Although thinking about it more carefully what is strength saving you there other than cost? This material is going to be at least a 10x cost premium judging by the elemental composition. And if we're talking household temperatures I expect there are polymer coatings that would work better.

The heat exchanger point is interesting. However doesn't stainless already lose out to 3D printed aluminum for the sort of applications where the optimization is worth the cost? This material is even heaver than steel and substantially more expensive.

It's tangential but I wonder how amenable to 3D printing this material will prove to be.

Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by kragen on Monday April 28, 2025 @02:23AM (#43818199)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43816979 suggested that the raw materials imply about a 6x cost increase over stainless, which is less than 10x. I haven't done the numbers myself.

High-energy cryogenic ball milling of 10 grams for four hours in a continuous flow of liquid nitrogen under an argon atmosphere with <1ppm oxygen (https://www.science.org/action/downloadSupplement?doi=10.112...) sounds expensive, but maybe they only did it that way because it was a low-risk way to ensure the alloying worked with the lab equipment they had on hand, not because it's the cheapest way to make the material. Hopefully cheaper ways are found.

I'm no expert in heat exchangers, but my calculations suggest 3-D printing is or will be an enormous boost there, and may reverse the gradient of merit for wall material thermal conductivity, favoring good thermal insulators over good thermal conductors like copper and aluminum. As for aluminum, it is only suitable for low temperatures.

Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by fc417fc802 on Monday April 28, 2025 @02:31AM (#43818246)
6x for the raw materials before you account for the production process.

I'm curious. What mechanism would lead to an insulator being favored in a heat exchanger?

Fair point about aluminum and temperature. As a layman an engine block is high temperature to me. I guess this would be extremely useful for more exotic stuff.

Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by kragen on Monday April 28, 2025 @02:41AM (#43818319)
If the fluid path through the heat exchanger is very short and the contact area is very large, preventing lengthwise conduction of heat from one end of the fluid path to the other, rather than getting enough conduction between the fluids, should become the performance-limiting factor. See https://dercuano.github.io/notes/capillary-heat-exchanger.ht....

I could be wrong about this, but I didn't just make it up; I got it from Lingai Luo's book on heat and mass transfer intensification, which hopefully I've understood correctly.

Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by fc417fc802 on Monday April 28, 2025 @03:13AM (#43818494)
No I think you've understood that correctly. I'd count that as one of those things that's blindingly obvious once it's pointed out but not until then.

With 3D printing I wonder if you could insert bands of insulator into an otherwise conductive wall? But you're dealing with large (potentially ridiculously so) temperature ranges so I wonder if it would prove difficult to match the thermal properties of the two materials closely enough.

I now have the weirdest desire to play with heat exchanger designs that I have absolutely zero use for. I've been nerd sniped.

Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by kergonath on Monday April 28, 2025 @02:22AM (#43818194)
No, they don’t. The force a man can apply does not require "high strength" materials to withstand. They don’t need high temperature performance, either. Seriously, we don’t need superalloy spoons.

When we’re talking about advanced materials, "high strength" means hundreds of MPa and "high temperature" is beyond 500°C (and more depending on the application).

Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by kragen on Monday April 28, 2025 @02:28AM (#43818222)
Any material can withstand the force a man (or a woman) can apply if you make it thick enough. Contrapositively, if you make it too thin, it can't. So sign me the fuck up for the superalloy spoons, but hold the nickel, please.

(It would be excellent to be able to clean my silverware by firing it in a kiln, though with a copper alloy I'd probably have to scrub off the verdigris.)

Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by kube-system on Monday April 28, 2025 @01:40PM (#43823983)
304 stainless is already strong enough that you could make a durable spoon thin enough that it would be painful to use. And it is cheap.
Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by kragen on Monday April 28, 2025 @02:53PM (#43824697)
8–11% nickel, not antibacterial, and five times weaker in the annealed state. Thin out the middle and leave thick edges to avoid pain. None of this is an option with this new alloy unless someone finds a cheaper way to make it and probably some kind of beryllium-copper-like precipitation hardening process so you can form it.
Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by fc417fc802 on Monday April 28, 2025 @06:40PM (#43826889)
> Thin out the middle and leave thick edges to avoid pain.

Ok but if you do that then what is the point of the exercise? I thought fancy flatware was thin because of the appearance. If the edges are thick doesn't that defeat the purpose?

The equivalent thickness being something like 5x stronger is of course the benefit here.

I don't think price is an issue for high end home use items. Rich people buy far weirder and more expensive things.

Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by kragen on Tuesday April 29, 2025 @07:47AM (#43831269)
I was thinking the edge could have a radius of about 350μm (like 21-gauge wire) while the main body might be 200μm thick.

Price is always an issue. Maybe you're willing to pay €100 a spoon, or €1000, or even €10000, but nobody is going to pay €1000000000 per spoon. If there's a good chance the price will drop by a factor of 10 in the next year, many rich people might be unwilling to pay even €100.

Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by fc417fc802 on Tuesday April 29, 2025 @01:36PM (#43835635)
I'm just not clear what the aesthetic advantage of making the body thinner than the edge is. At least not once you're already down under a millimeter.

In an adjacent exchange it seemed we both expected the price to be far lower. 10x or even 50x the material cost of a piece of stainless steel flatware seems well within budget for a rich customer.

Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by kragen on Wednesday April 30, 2025 @08:13AM (#43844118)
Sure, silver silverware already costs that much (and is antibacterial, and requires scrubbing tarnish off, though only for aesthetic reasons). It'll be interesting to see what shakes out.
Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by amluto on Monday April 28, 2025 @06:42PM (#43826917)
Nickel-free (e.g. 18/0) flatware is just fine from an engineering perspective, and it’s cheap, and it sticks to magnets, which is fun. It’s even available as fairly nice, decorative name-brand products.

And I found some studies suggesting that 304 and 316 stainless steel leach very little nickel when in contact with food. It’s the cheaper nickel-containing stainless steel that’s a problem.

Re:New material gives copper superalloy-like strength by kragen on Monday April 28, 2025 @11:57PM (#43828565)
Yeah, it's fine in my experience.