Many companies in the tech sector have effectively been using Apple as their R&D department for decades. Samsung is just the latest and most blatant.
Nothing that Apple did was really that new ... they have never been the "new"; just the people that came up with the right marketing sauce to convince people to buy it; and that's just a US thing. US lagging behind in mobile tech was an on-going joke up until about 2007 because other companies had had run-away successes in the Asian and Europe markets already. Just nothing of that scale in the US.
There were touch-screen smartphones in 1994 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:IBM_Simon_Personal_Communi... ... Oftentimes there were widely available commercial equivalencies 10, 15, even 20 years prior to the Apple "Innovation" event. And then a few years later they (Apple) pretend like they invented and own all of it.
I don't see Palm or Rim or LG or Qualcomm or IBM or Sony or Nokia or Ericsson or even Microsoft going around and suing the pants of people in the Mobile space; even though they clearly have more of the prior art right than Apple does.
With Apple, suing people out of market has been their modus operandi at least since Lisa.
And I really don't know what you mean with the Microsoft comparison; you can do a very identical analysis with early 80s computer UIs ... from visicalc to desqview to deskmate to countless utility suites that did WIMP pre-lisa, some even graphically (e.g., wordperfect, wordstar)
This isn't about whether or not Apple make good and/or innovative products. It's about their claim of exclusive rights to the concepts they use in building them.
Syncing data over a network wasn't unheard of as well, but then someone came with dropbox.
Nothing today is "really new", but the novelty is in the way this is put together and used.
There may well be something special about the packaging of a particular set of features, but that isn't the standard for patent.
Samsung did not just copy one or two isolated design details, they copied the whole damn thing. Do not your let your fandroidism or anti-Apple bigotry blind you to the reailty of what is being contested here.
You're making it sound like there's this big profit tree out there that everybody's supposed to get an fair share of. Nobody "eats up" profits. They earn them.
Apple has the most profits with all other companies, except the one they are suing, selling at a loss. Yes, at a loss. http://www.bgr.com/2012/04/30/apple-samsung-take-profit/
The basis of these types of IP arguments is that the competitor can take short-cuts and thus price the originator out of market or at best make a much more handsome profit because they didn't have to do the R&D or some other type of fair-play argument line. You certainly don't have to prove that harm is being done for patent violation, but the idea is that such a system exists to stop it. If there's a sniff test here, the highest-profit-margin-in-the-industry Apple isn't passing it.
Until recently Apple had no presence in the low end of the market which meant that a large proportion of the market that Samsung and other Android handset manufacturers had was in the budget sector. That part of the market is always less profitable on a per unit basis and more reliant on volume.
It is also arguably more competitive than the high end. Few Android handset manufacturers other than Samsung are making models that compare favourably with the iPhone, however down the bottom end there are loads of players (many fighting for their lives) cutting further into margins at those price points.
Interestingly Samsung, arguably the only Android manufacturer that does compete successfully at the top end is massively profitable itself.
But if Samsung and other choose to scrap it out in a low margin market, you can't really blame Apple when that strategy fails to realise the same profits and you can't really use it as any sort of justification.
How do you suppose they did that? With lawyers? I don't think so.
> What if Apple spent all this lawyer money instead on making a superior product that would beat their competitors
They already do. They didn't need this lawsuit to stay competitive.
Samsung's deliberate copying of the iPhone, as directed by management and documented quite extensively in the evidence, is the source of most of these problems. When you have Samsung saying "Make it more like the iPhone" you have problems.
I think it's safe to assume they have enough money to develop new products and keep an army of lawyers fed and watered.
Samsung are an extremely unethical company. I try not to have anything to do with them whenever I can help it.
> What if Apple spent all this lawyer money instead on making a superior product that would beat their competitors, you know, because it was a better product, and not just go around and be the corporate Tonya Harding?
That's exactly what they did do with the iPhone. Samsung used their might to stop it from coming to South Korea and give themselves time to develop a knock-off of it.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Computer,_Inc._v._Microso...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graphical_Environment_Manager#L...
Buying their products is saying, with your actual wallet, and your actual real money in completely unequivocal terms: "Yes, I fully support these blunt litigious anti-competitive tactics. Please do this more."
It's almost like a more evil serpent version of the Windows tax: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_refund#The_.22Windows_t...
What if Apple spent all this lawyer money instead on making a superior product that would beat their competitors, you know, because it was a better product, and not just go around and be the corporate Tonya Harding?