News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What “Worse is Better vs The Right Thing” is really about by greenyoda on Sunday August 12, 2012 @11:53AM (#4372770)
"Taking Wintel as an example, that could be done by abstracting away the hardware. Require programs to be shipped as some high level bytecode, that your OS can then compile, JIT, or whatever, depending on the best current solution. That makes your programs dependent on the OS, not on the hardware. Port the compiling stack of your OS, and you're done. If this were done, Intel wouldn't have wasted so much resources in its X86 architecture."

Unfortunately, that could have only happened in an alternate universe in which humans had developed more advanced technology by the 1980s. At the time Windows and the Intel x86 architecture were being developed (Windows 1.0 was released in 1985), computers did not have the speed or the memory to add another layer of abstraction. From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_1.0:

"The system requirements for Windows 1.01 constituted CGA/HGC/EGA (listed as 'Monochrome or color monitor'), MS-DOS 2.0, 256 kB of memory or greater, and two double-sided disk drives or a hard drive."

Yes, that's 256 KILO bytes. And a double-sided disk drive (5.25" floppy disk) was at most 1.2MB. The Intel 80386, the first 32-bit member of the x86 family, was released in 1985, so Windows had to be developed on and run on the 16-bit 80286. And it had to run all the old MS-DOS programs that were written in assembler, if Microsoft wanted to retain its existing customers.

There were hardly any layers of abstraction to be had in those days. The OS kernel (MS-DOS) was still being written in hand-optimized assembler.

The subsequent history of the x86 product line was determined by the requirement that object code had to be backward compatible. Which brought us to what we have today.

Re:What “Worse is Better vs The Right Thing” is really about by loup-vaillant on Sunday August 12, 2012 @03:22PM (#4373326)
> Unfortunately, that could have only happened in an alternate universe in which humans had developed more advanced technology by the 1980s.

I agree. Too bad.

> The subsequent history of the x86 product line was determined by the requirement that object code had to be backward compatible.

Of course. My point is, this sucks. Collectively, we could have done much better much sooner, but our current organization scheme (mostly free market) compels us to do otherwise.

Re:What “Worse is Better vs The Right Thing” is really about by nasmorn on Monday August 13, 2012 @05:47AM (#4375136)
We are talking about the fastest spread pf a truly disruptive technology in the history of mankind prior to mobile communications. Why was anything too slow.