In other words, housing will always be a huge chunk of your income because it's hugely important. The only way it could be less is if it stopped mattering where you live. Then housing would be essentially a commodity and priced accordingly.
It's important to realise that money is an abstraction that we use to do trade, but it's not trade itself. Pricing is a reflection of market forces. You can't just magically change the price of housing and suddenly have more of everything else with no compromises. You have to change the market.
People always say "more housing*, but that's incredibly naive. More housing in the UK means tiny plots of land crammed in next to a dual carriageway in the middle of nowhere. People don't want to live there, but there's no choice. As long as there's inequality there will be high house prices. Turning housing into a commodity such that you can allocate only a small part of your income to it would take a lot more fundamental changes towards equality like vastly improved public transport, decentralisation of business, turning the most beautiful areas into national parks instead of estates owned by the rich etc.
I don't know how it is in the UK, but in Paris, I hear from a lot of people that their retirement plan is to sell their Parisian apartment and move to a lower cost area with what they've gained. Doesn't work out if your "investment" is underwater.
With climate change it will be literally what will happen to many homeowners in low lying coastal areas some decades from now.
The numbers are just made up and don't matter. You can't eat a number and it won't keep you warm or dry. It's so weird to me that even in a place like this people can't see beyond the numbers.
> The numbers are just made up and don't matter.
You've asked why people care. They care because they've made their retirement plans on a made up number. Is that reasonable? I don't think so, and it's why I'm renting not buying. But you're tilting at windmills at this point to explain to people who have a vested financial interest why they're wrong.
No, it's not immaterial. If you paid $1M for something and next year that something is worth $500K, it's a problem, regardless of whether you own it or it's mortgaged, regardless of whether you plan to sell it or live in it. You lost $500K, it's as simple as that.
Uhh, why? Unless you were planning on selling up and spending it all on a cruise or something house prices are immaterial to home owners.
> I have to refinance every 5 years, because that's the game in the UK, so if rates spike I'm also screwed.
This is the real problem. It's partly our fault, of course, for agreeing to a mortgage which we couldn't afford if the interest rates doubled. You know exactly what you're signing up to, but you still do it.
The trouble is there's no choice. The finance industry has us by the balls. I don't even think of it as a housing crisis, I think of it as finance crisis. The real problem is banks control far too much of our lives. The entire money supply is essentially just mortgages. This abstraction we call money has been taken way too far.