News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta antitrust trial kicks off in federal court by echelon on Monday April 14, 2025 @10:12PM (#43688368)
Meta doesn't bother me too much.

I'm more concerned with YouTube owning all of social video. Movies are on a dozen streamers. Social stuff is on Instagram, TikTok, Reddit, and X. But video essays, independent animation, educational content, cultural critiques, music, video podcasts, trailers, gameplay, research, news - anything long form, serious, interesting - it's all trapped on YouTube as the only distribution platform. And they'll keep getting bigger with no possible alternative due to network effects.

I'm even more concerned with Amazon being a conglomerate [1] that is in online sales, hyperscaler infrastructure, consumer hardware, home automation systems, grocery stores, medicine, primary care, and movie production. And that they can leverage these synergies in grossly unfair ways.

I'm most concerned that the Apple / Google duopoly in mobile, web, and search has entrenched these two players across the vast majority of online transactions, interactions, and computational device usages. They collect margin on everything. They own your devices, they own search, they own the web, they own the apps, they have to be paid off to rank your business, have to be paid off to collect money, they regulate what you can do with your apps and websites, etc. etc. You jump through their hoops. This is their internet.

[1] Especially given the fact that Amazon can subsidize their efforts in these areas from profits in other business units and out-compete viable businesses in those markets. They can offer goods for free with an existing subscription and advertise far and wide across their retail website, plastered on their packaging, and emblazoned on the side of their delivery vehicles. Lord of the Rings got an 80 million dollar advertising package for free, whereas Bong Joon Ho's far more deserving film got next to nothing.

Re:Meta antitrust trial kicks off in federal court by eGQjxkKF6fif on Monday April 14, 2025 @10:28PM (#43688473)
It all bothers me. Centralization is bad. And if Facebook and Google wanted to just disable somebody's channel or pages, they could.

I think everybody on hackernews gets it. We're all pretty much on the same page.

Ain't nobody able to do anything about it though.

Re:Meta antitrust trial kicks off in federal court by transcriptase on Monday April 14, 2025 @11:40PM (#43688778)
Not everyone on hackernews gets it. There are quite a few people on here involved with or responsible for the awful things that get brought up, but they’re paid enough to actually convince themselves we simply don’t understand why it’s necessary.
Re:Meta antitrust trial kicks off in federal court by gosub100 on Tuesday April 15, 2025 @03:52AM (#43690112)
Or they just have a different opinion than you. The GP comment was misleading saying there is "no possible" option due to network effects. You absolutely can upload to rumble or floatplane or other sites that have their own networks. People should be praising YouTubes model to pay the channels for content. In an alternate universe, Microsoft is renting you cloud storage by the gb with 3-tier plans and thousands of people use it to share videos with their families.
Re:Meta antitrust trial kicks off in federal court by numpad0 on Tuesday April 15, 2025 @03:23AM (#43689917)
Laws, content moderation, and moderation obligations had created an insurmountable barrier to entry to fix that. Though abolishing those hard and soft laws can't be a solution for various reasons.
Re:Meta antitrust trial kicks off in federal court by tonyhart7 on Tuesday April 15, 2025 @03:48AM (#43690078)
"Meta doesn't bother me too much."

it is concern for someone outside western hemisphere, in Asia especially META dominance is even stronger

Re:Meta antitrust trial kicks off in federal court by pjc50 on Tuesday April 15, 2025 @04:56AM (#43690510)
> I'm more concerned with YouTube owning all of social video. Movies are on a dozen streamers. Social stuff is on Instagram, TikTok, Reddit, and X. But video essays, independent animation, educational content, cultural critiques, music, video podcasts, trailers, gameplay, research, news - anything long form, serious, interesting - it's all trapped on YouTube as the only distribution platform. And they'll keep getting bigger with no possible alternative due to network effects.

Yes, but: despite all of us adblocking them, this is all supported by their ad revenue.

The discovery effect is simply too powerful. I can't really see a way out of this because people are not going to go back to paying for media. Possibly the only way is something like the increasing control of social media from the EU forcing a separate EU Youtube, which might include things like the French TV rules forcing a certain amount of content to be in French, plus control over foreign disinformation influencers.

(you know what the only other social video platforms are with millions of users? Bilibili, xiaohungshu etc.)

Re:Meta antitrust trial kicks off in federal court by BrtByte on Tuesday April 15, 2025 @05:45AM (#43690792)
Meta's stuff gets a lot of attention because it's flashy and tied to social media drama, but the structural power of Amazon, YouTube, Apple, and Google is way scarier long-term. They're not just dominating products - they're controlling infrastructure. Distribution, discovery, monetization - the whole stack.
Re:Meta antitrust trial kicks off in federal court by petersteinberg on Tuesday April 15, 2025 @09:24AM (#43692361)
What’s surprising to me about the dominance of YouTube is the fact that 1) unlike all the social networks there is very little network effect with YouTube, and 2) there are perfectly to viable alternatively such as Vimeo that are routinely bypassed.