News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by kmeisthax on Sunday April 13, 2025 @01:37AM (#43670354)
Wait, to be clear, this 'dedicated return channel' is just for TVs to broadcast back to the station that they're watching the adverts? I thought ATSC 3.0 was going to rely on IP backhaul for that. Actually broadcasting back seems... impractical at best.

I mean, let's keep in mind, even ATSC 1.0 had really awful reception issues; compared to analog NTSC where there was enough redundancy that you could just tune into a garbage station from way too far away and see something. Now imagine trying to make that already unreliable channel bidirectional. I just really hope all the return channel stuff is optional, because it sure as hell isn't going to work without way more stations broadcasting on more channels, and OOPS you've reinvented LTE.

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by timewizard on Sunday April 13, 2025 @02:01AM (#43670445)
Ironically there's no redundancy in NTSC. There are layers of information and they degrade downward until you have just a black and white picture with no sound.

In ATSC there is two types of forward error correction on the digital bitstream. The problem it faces is it sits in the same channel allocations as NTSC while having to deliver significantly more information than NTSC. That and the actual digital modulation used is not as ideal for receivers to capture.

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by kmeisthax on Sunday April 13, 2025 @11:33AM (#43673526)
You can digitize and lossily compress an NTSC signal significantly without losing much detail; that's why I call it redundant. Compression removes redundancy.

In ATSC the tradeoff between compression and error correction is such that a noisy channel is far more likely to cut out or otherwise be unusable than it would have been in NTSC.

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by DoubleGlazing on Sunday April 13, 2025 @10:23AM (#43673024)
Back in the late 90s when Ireland was starting to think about digital terrestrial TV a system called DVB-RCT was considered. Basically your receiver could also transmit back to the television transmitter. The system could handle thousands of concurrent connections, albeit each one had very low bandwidth - around 1Kbp/s in peak time.That was considered good enough for very basic interactivity and for authorising PPV purchases etc.In quieter hours or in areas were there were fewer receivers that bandwidth would be much higher, but in reality that would be rare.

In the end the company that the governement selected to start the rollout of DTT went bust and I don't think the system was used anywhere else. The developer of the technology abandoned it in 2006 as other connection methods (broadband/mobile data) were preferred.

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by mindslight on Sunday April 13, 2025 @01:37PM (#43674431)
I would think that the expectation is for the common option to be IP backhaul based on embedded LTE/5G modems. Having a separate communication scheme is probably more of a hedge for super rural areas that don't have LTE/5G or other IP coverage, especially as that is where broadcast TV will have more staying power.
Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by Lammy on Sunday April 13, 2025 @04:29PM (#43675620)
This is my understanding as well. You can see the usage-reporting scheme and data structure here: https://www.atsc.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/04/A333-2024-04...

“The fundamental record that captures consumption information is called a Consumption Data Unit (CDU). For a streaming A/V channel, each CDU identifies a reporting interval during which a service is accessed. Such a CDU includes the service identifier, the time the service access started and the time the service access ended. If any Applications are active during the report interval, it also records when the Applications are active (whether on a primary device or a “second screen”, companion device), including the Application Identifier, the time the Application started being active, and the time it stopped being active.”

“For services, events logged into a CDU shall correspond to all usage intervals of no less than 10 seconds and may correspond to shorter usage intervals. For Application activity, events logged into a CDU shall correspond to all usage intervals of no less than 5 seconds and may correspond to shorter usage intervals. The precision and accuracy of start times and end times in the CDUs should be within 1 second.”

The payload schema is a 4651-byte JSON structure, so I would imagine that a response-payload fitting this schema would be same-order-of-magnitude size. With 10-second granularity that works out to roughly a half-kilobyte-per-second data rate, and according to the DRC spec the maximum payload size of one DRC message is 2048 bytes.

It will also report when you play something back from a DVR:

“Component.SourceDeliveryPath – Delivery path used for or the source of the content component indicated by the parent Component element.

SourceDeliveryPath.type –

0 – Broadcast delivery (content component is delivered by broadcast)

1 – Broadband delivery (content component is delivered directly by broadband by broadcaster)

2 – Time-shift-buffer source (content source is local time shift buffer)

3 – Hard-drive source (content source is local hard drive)

4 – Delivery via direct connection (HDMI)

5 – Alternate IP delivery (content component is delivered via intermediary)”

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by kmeisthax on Sunday April 13, 2025 @06:38PM (#43676364)
> 5 – Alternate IP delivery (content component is delivered via intermediary)

Ok, this is entirely paranoid conspiracy theory rumblings at this point, but why does this sound like a way to catch unlicensed rebroadcasters?

Re:BPS is a GPS alternative that nobody's heard of by mindslight on Sunday April 13, 2025 @09:48PM (#43677364)
Honestly that sounds pretty congruent with thinking about the spec from the position of the authors. Like what is the difference between "local time shift buffer" and "local hard drive" if it isn't some contractual authorization aspect they're pushing? Especially when you think that this standard is going to be deployed on TVs that will likely be displaying video from other sources than just broadcast.