News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Singularity is not coming by ars on Friday August 10, 2012 @05:36AM (#4365548)
You don't understand intelligence. Doubling the circuits doubles the speed of the intelligence, but it has no effect on it's quality.

You are assuming the existence of not just an intelligent parallel algorithm but an infinitely scalable one (i.e. one that could actually take advantage of more circuits)! Because without that, you don't need to double the circuits - you could just give them more time.

Concepts that are beyond a particular intelligence will still be beyond it, even if the speed is increased.

People have a really hard time admitting that some people are truly fundamentally smarter than others. It's not just that they can think faster - they can think things that other people simply can not, even if they worked really hard at it.

I'm sure you've heard the saying "I didn't think of that". That's exactly it, even if it thinks faster, it will still never "think of that".

Re:The Singularity is not coming by TheComedian on Friday August 10, 2012 @09:30AM (#4366048)
This is actually under debate. There is disagreement among neuroscientists whether intelligence is a result of brain modularity (specific regions of the brains optimized for certain tasks), or due to brain size alone. All that said, I'm skeptical of the singularity since it assumes that a recursive process can continually improve intelligence without significant diminishing returns. The problem with this thinking is that it fails to take into account evolution. All this research into AI is based on the assumption that "intelligence" should be like human intelligence. But human intelligence has had several billion years to evolve and is highly optimized for our environment (actually our environment from several tens of thousands of years ago when we were hunter gatherers). It seems naive to me to assume that we are not nearing a local optimum in what is possible with human intelligence. I don't believe a singularity is possible because by recursively improving "intelligence" you will near the local optimum of that form of intelligence but that does not mean you can continue improving that intelligence indefinitely.
Re:The Singularity is not coming by andreasvc on Friday August 10, 2012 @06:25AM (#4365628)
Given that intelligence is probabilistic and approximate, doubling the circuits would increase accuracy. I think it's pretty plausible that intelligence does work this way, since humans make mistakes all the time.
Re:The Singularity is not coming by joe_the_user on Friday August 10, 2012 @04:39PM (#4368145)
You don't understand intelligence. Doubling the circuits doubles the speed of the intelligence, but it has no effect on it's quality.

Uh the singularity may be a crack-pot idea in the end but it seems like brings out a whole of slew crackpot refutations.

No, I don't understand flexible human intelligence or even animal intelligence fully and neither do you or other human. That's why it's not been programmed.

I do know that doubling circuit size doesn't double speed.

People have a really hard time admitting that some people are truly fundamentally smarter than others.

And you'd have a hard coming up with any evidence for this "fundamental" rather than relative intelligence difference.

The singularity, crackpot or not, is based on the hypothesis that there is a single "neocortical algorithm". It may indeed be dubious theory but it's cobbled together from some real evidence. If you're going to have counter-arguments to this, why not do the same?