You are assuming the existence of not just an intelligent parallel algorithm but an infinitely scalable one (i.e. one that could actually take advantage of more circuits)! Because without that, you don't need to double the circuits - you could just give them more time.
Concepts that are beyond a particular intelligence will still be beyond it, even if the speed is increased.
People have a really hard time admitting that some people are truly fundamentally smarter than others. It's not just that they can think faster - they can think things that other people simply can not, even if they worked really hard at it.
I'm sure you've heard the saying "I didn't think of that". That's exactly it, even if it thinks faster, it will still never "think of that".
Uh the singularity may be a crack-pot idea in the end but it seems like brings out a whole of slew crackpot refutations.
No, I don't understand flexible human intelligence or even animal intelligence fully and neither do you or other human. That's why it's not been programmed.
I do know that doubling circuit size doesn't double speed.
People have a really hard time admitting that some people are truly fundamentally smarter than others.
And you'd have a hard coming up with any evidence for this "fundamental" rather than relative intelligence difference.
The singularity, crackpot or not, is based on the hypothesis that there is a single "neocortical algorithm". It may indeed be dubious theory but it's cobbled together from some real evidence. If you're going to have counter-arguments to this, why not do the same?
> Let’s have a hypothetical AI that researches artificial intelligence, and that constantly rewrites its own code to incorporate its finding into its own intelligence.
No,
A hypothetical General AI would double the amount of circuits involved in it's processes to double its intelligence and go from Monkey-brain-sized to human brain sized. Repeat as necessary. The intelligence algorithm running on those circuits doesn't have to improve (though we'd hope it would at least a little).
Of course, you would need an initial intelligent parallel algorithm. That might indeed be hard or impossible. But his argument in itself doesn't proving anything about this.
Sure, even with flexible general AI, some problems would remain hard but a lot of things aren't the Knap-sack problem. In fact there's no evidence the massive success of human intelligence has had much to do with tackling NP-complete problems. Instead, flexibility and pattern finding set human apart from both other animals and the most powerful artifact we can so-far create.
Just consider, Moore's Law continued at least for a fair period driven by humans whose innate intelligence didn't increase at all.