News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Isaac Asimov Describes How AI Will Liberate Humans and Th... by throwanem on Friday April 11, 2025 @11:36AM (#43655066)
"Teenage boy wish fulfillment" is well beneath any reasonable standard of criticism, and I've addressed that with about as much respect as it deserves.

There is much worthy of critique in Heinlein, especially in his depiction of women. I've spent about a quarter century off and on reading such critiques, much more recently than I've spent meaningful time with his fiction. I've also read what he had to say for himself before he died, and what Mrs. Heinlein - she kept the name - said about him after. If we want to talk about, for example, how the themes of maternal incest in his later work reflect a degree of senescence and the wish for a supercompetent maternal figure to whom to surrender the burden of responsibility, or if we want to talk about how Heinlein seems to spend an enormous amount of time just generally exploring stuff from female characters' perspectives that an honest modern inquiry would recognize as fumbling badly but earnestly in the direction of something like a contemporary understanding of gender, then we could talk about that.

No one wants to, though. You can't use anything like that as a stick to beat people with, so it never gets a look in, and the people who care nothing for anything of the subject save if it looks serviceable as a weapon claim to be the only ones in the talk who are honest. They don't know the man's work well enough to talk about the decades he spent writing stories that absolutely revolve around character development, which exist solely to exemplify it! Of course these are dismissively discarded as his 'juveniles' - a few letters shy of 'juvenilia' - because science fiction superfans are all children and so are science fiction superhaters, neither of whom knows how to respond in any way other than a tantrum on the rare occasion of being told bluntly it's past time they grew up.

But they're the honest ones. Why not? So it goes. It's a conversation I know better than to try to have, especially on Hacker News; if I don't care for how it's proceeding, I've no one but myself to blame.

There are no comments on this comment yet.