I really wish a lot more work went in to security question penetration testing. It's relatively easy for a determined attacker to come up with the correct answers to these questions (or convince a human that they know the answers). The recent iCloud breach makes me believe that in many cases the "security questions" practice is by far the weakest link in modern web authentication.
Isn't that how the Sarah Palin thing happened?
I would hazard a guess that most sites store "Secret Questions/Answers" in plain text, or a two-way hash (that their support app reverses), as they are used to confirm identity along with the basics (DOB, address, email, etc).
Example:
For: "Who was your favorite high school teacher."
- Mr. Berners-Lee - Mr. Berners Lee - Tim Berners-Lee - Mr. Lee
Never mind if you had two different teachers who were great, and you switch them interchangeably depending on whether you're in an English mood or a Music mood
"Whose was your favorite high school teacher?"
-Pecan pie.
Maybe you could do something like consistently answer the previous question from the dropdown?
We've already gone over the possible reasoning for not hashing the answer.
Isn't that just encryption?
(Yes, I design these answers virtually impossible to brute-force even for myself.)