I think that's a bit telling on their motivations (esp. given their recent large institutional deals with universities).
> We found that students primarily use Claude to create and improve educational content across disciplines (39.3% of conversations). This often entailed designing practice questions, editing essays, or summarizing academic material.
Sure, throwing a paragraph of an essay at Claude and asking it to turn it into a 3-page essay could have been categorized as "editing" the essay.
And it seems pretty naked the way they lump "editing an essay" in with "designing practice questions," which are clearly very different uses, even in the most generous interpretation.
I'm not saying that the vast majority of students do use AI to cheat, but I do want to say that, if they did, you could probably write this exact same article and tell no lies, and simply sweep all the cheating under titles like "create and improve educational content."
They never could be arsed to learn how to input their assignments into Wolfram Alpha. It was always the ux/ui effort that held them back.
In other words, is the school certificaftion meant to distinguish those who genuinely learnt, or was it merely meant to signal (and thus, those who used to copy pre-llm are going to do the same, and thus reach the same level of certification regardless of whether they learnt or not)?
You're right.
Quite incredibly, they also do the opposite, in that they hype-up / inflate the capability of their LLMs. For instance, they've categorised "summarisation" as "high-order thinking" ("Create", per Bloom's Taxonomy). It patently isn't. Comical they'd not only think so, but also publicly blog about it.
This context is important: this taxonomy did not emerge from artificial intelligence nor cognitive science. So its levels are unlikely to map to how ML/AI people assess the difficulty of various categories of tasks.
Generative models are, by design, fast (and often pretty good) at generation (creation), but this isn't the same standard that Bloom had in mind with his "creation" category. Bloom's taxonomy might be better described as a hierarchy: proper creation draws upon all the layers below it: understanding, application, analysis, and evaluation.
In the article, I guess this would be buried in
> Students also frequently used Claude to provide technical explanations or solutions for academic assignments (33.5%)—working with AI to debug and fix errors in coding assignments, implement programming algorithms and data structures, and explain or solve mathematical problems.
"Write my essay" would be considered a "solution for academic assignment," but by only referring to it obliquely in that paragraph they don't really tell us the prevalence of it.
(I also wonder if students are smart, and may keep outright usage of LLMs to complete assignments on a separate, non-university account, not trusting that Anthropic will keep their conversations private from the university if asked.)