Re:What is going on with the editing of submission titles?
by portLAN on Friday August 17, 2007 @05:53PM
(#43630)
Probably the best solution is to have a "posted by" (editor name) and a "submitted by" (user name) like Slashdot. Alternatively, an "edited by" tag added to anything changed after submission.
Re:What is going on with the editing of submission titles?
by dfranke on Friday August 17, 2007 @07:18PM
(#43663)
I second that, but I think editors want to stay anonymous. Just adding an asterisk next to edited titles would be sufficient.
Re:What is going on with the editing of submission titles?
by dpapathanasiou on Friday August 17, 2007 @05:51PM
(#43629)
I'm not sure I understand that explanation.
So we share the same title for each link (yes, we do), but we see different comments?
No, we don't: if there's a ridiculous/obnoxious/puerile/etc. comment posted, we all share that, too.
Why should the editing policy for titles be different from comments?
Re:What is going on with the editing of submission titles?
by palish on Friday August 17, 2007 @06:04PM
(#43633)
He may have meant that different users should give a specific submission the same title, one without spelling mistakes and bias. So if a user titles a submission with spelling mistakes or bias then it would be reasonable to edit the title to the correct form.
I think the best plan is just to make it policy that submission titles have a different status from comments. They have to, because all the users have to share the same title for each link.