News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by elmerfud on Monday April 07, 2025 @04:47PM (#43615773)
Reading the article you can call this a protest, because yes it does fit under that definition because it's quite broad, but it doesn't fit the normal idea of what we would consider a protest. This was not people who decided not to attempt the 50th anniversary and then go outside and conduct a peaceable protest. You could equally use the word disruptors to describe what they did.

As Microsoft said it seems that they work quite willful in their disruption. People seems to have forgotten how to be effective at making changes. They should have first gone and made their grievances known in a private way to the appropriate people. Get the attention of leadership in a way that is respectful and they in turn will be more willing to hear what you have to say. If that doesn't work you begin to broaden out your objections to get others involved and to make the issue more well-known. Seems people have forgotten that part abd skip those initial steps going straight to the disrupting ways. As if they are babies throwing a tantrum. I don't know if it's because they were never given discipline when they were younger and so throwing the tantrum is the way that they've learned gets them what they want.

I think the protesters do have a valid point but I'm with Microsoft on this one. They didn't try and have their grievances handled in a productive way by going to those and making their case they started by just being disruptive jerks. Even if they have the most valid point in the world, the way they presented it should get them tossed out.

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by nonrandomstring on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:16PM (#43616038)
> They should have first gone and made their grievances known in a private way to the appropriate people. Get the attention of leadership in a way that is respectful and they in turn will be more willing to hear what you have to say.

Masterful. I literally laughed until I shat myself. You owe me a new pair of pants dude.

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by elmerfud on Monday April 07, 2025 @10:51PM (#43617944)
I didn't know you wore pants when you were sitting in your mom's basement trolling. There is a way to do things so you're looked at as honorable and respectful and then there's a way to do things where you're looked at like a disruptive thug.

One gets you respect from even those who may disagree with your point of view, because they can still respect you as a person. The other way you're just looked upon as a disruptor who doesn't have any place in a civilized decent society. Whatever your point is was lost in how you tried to convey it.

Just like your point about pants is lost in whatever you're trying to convey.

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by ryandrake on Tuesday April 08, 2025 @01:46AM (#43618675)
I can't think of a single company (besides maybe a tiny start-up where you know all of leadership) where airing ethical grievances through a private, respectful, official channel would accomplish anything. If you're at the point where you're objecting so strongly to something your company is doing on ethical grounds, you're 99% of the way out the door already.

Better to just quit and if asked, quietly note the reason in your exit interview. Banding together and politely petitioning your company is not going to change anything--your employer is not a democracy. And obviously protesting your employer publicly is not going to help, either.

I didn't quite soil my pants like that other guy, but I at least mildly chuckled at the thought of telling my manager in my next 1:1 that I object ethically to some business my 10,000+ person company is engaged in.

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by nonrandomstring on Friday April 11, 2025 @04:58AM (#43651817)
Hey you seem rattled by that. I'm just humorously, and therefore much more kindly pointing out something that could sound cruel if put plainly; that you have a naive and distorted understanding of human relations and offer really, really bad advice. But you seem stuck on appeasing tyranny, so good luck with that. It never worked. I'll be in my mom's basement if you need me :)
Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by bbqfog on Monday April 07, 2025 @04:56PM (#43615850)
That doesn’t work and these people have increased awareness of Microsoft’s role in the genocide. We’re literally talking about it now because if their sacrifice. Anyone clutching pearls over this was pro-genocide in the first place and not worth catering to.
Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by JumpCrisscross on Monday April 07, 2025 @04:58PM (#43615865)
> these people have increased awareness of Microsoft’s role in the genocide. We’re literally talking about it now because if their sacrifice

Every Fortune 500 company does business in Israel, which means it directly or indirectly supports their military. If someone is just learning that I'm not sure how useful they are to anyone's cause.

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by bbqfog on Monday April 07, 2025 @04:59PM (#43615886)
A lot did business with Nazi Germany too. Corporations need to be forced to behave in a moral fashion.
Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by JumpCrisscross on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:03PM (#43615921)
> lot did business with Nazi Germany too

And then we told them not to and they (mostly) stopped. The correct way to effect this change is politically. Not at a company anniversary party.

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by mackyspace on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:05PM (#43615943)
We're talking about it, so it seems pretty effective to me! The "won't people think of Bill Gate's feelings!" arguments aren't very compelling, just makes you look like you want to be complicit.
Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by JumpCrisscross on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:08PM (#43615965)
> We're talking about it, so it seems pretty effective to me!

Talking about an issue is productive if you need to bring awareness to it. There is nobody on the planet who isn't aware that something is happening in Israel and Gaza. And when an issue is this divisive, calling attention to it mobilises both sides. (See polling following the protests at Columbia, for example. Awareness went up. But net support increased more for Israel than Palestine because people just defaulted to their priors.)

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by mackyspace on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:10PM (#43615985)
Support for Palestinians has increased steadily since Israel started its latest genocide. I think you're confusing Zionist PR expenditures with actual support, which is rapidly dwindling for Israel.

https://news.gallup.com/poll/657404/less-half-sympathetic-to...

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by JumpCrisscross on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:11PM (#43615994)
> Support for Palestinians has increased steadily since Israel started it's latest genocide

I never argued otherwise. I'm saying look at the polling immediately after the protests.

Media reporting of atrocities drives down favourability for Israel. Media reporting of the protests drives down favourability for Palestine. It's why, despite favourability for Israel monotonically declining since 2023, its net favourability vis-a-vis Palestine blipped up in '24.

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by mackyspace on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:11PM (#43615999)
That's not true at all and you won't find a poll that backs up what you're saying.
Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by JumpCrisscross on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:13PM (#43616018)
> That's not true at all and you won't find a poll that backs up what you're saying

What's not? Literally look at the Gallup poll you cited [1] to see Palestinian favourability dip in 2024.

I'll note that part of it is the media's fascination with the pro-Hamas minority at pro-Palestinian protests. Organisers are getting a little better at screening those folks out.

[1] https://news.gallup.com/poll/657404/less-half-sympathetic-to...

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by mackyspace on Monday April 07, 2025 @05:23PM (#43616110)
There's zero evidence that the protests have had negative impact on support for Palestinians. The media is staunchly Zionist, you could make the case the protests have effectively counterbalanced their propaganda.
Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by JumpCrisscross on Monday April 07, 2025 @06:12PM (#43616524)
> zero evidence that the protests have had negative impact on support for Palestinians

Of course there is [1][2]. (You see similar effects from e.g. bridge blocking in the broader protest literature.)

And again, what do you think happened in 2024 that caused support for Palestine per your source to drop?

> media is staunchly Zionist

The population has been broadly pro-Israel until very recently. The media market is, in the end, a market.

[1] https://today.yougov.com/politics/articles/49311-opinion-on-...

[2] https://www.insidehighered.com/news/quick-takes/2024/05/03/p...

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by mackyspace on Monday April 07, 2025 @07:21PM (#43616942)
What happened? About a trillion dollars worth of hasbara, which in the end couldn't counteract the actual footage IDF were posting of their war crimes.
Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by runarberg on Tuesday April 08, 2025 @10:40AM (#43622339)
I’m starting to suspect you are arguing in bad faith. Three hours after you posted this, you posted [1] a sibling thread citing older numbers from the same source. Why did you do that? Over there your narrative was that support for Palestinians weren’t as great as your parent was arguing, so instead of citing this poll from this year, you posted an older poll from 2024 where support for Palestinians weren’t as great. You knew about this newer poll, but you still choose to post the older one that just so happens to align better with your argument.

Also this poll doesn’t back up what you are saying. These protests are as much anti-israel as they are pro-palestine, and support for Israel has been consistently dwindling. The protests continued throughout 2024 especially leading up to the November election, yet in 2025 support for Palestine was in all time high. Most likely the support dropped in 2024 because the horrors of the 2023 oct 7 terrorist attacks were still in fresh memory, so support for Palestine, which had been steadily increasing, took a momentary dip, but quickly readjusted at an increasing rate as the accusations of the Gaza genocide became ever harder to deny.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43617196

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday April 08, 2025 @02:43PM (#43625167)
> you posted [1] a sibling thread citing older numbers from the same source. Why did you do that?

I’m citing the poll the commenter I’m responding to originally cited. Given they trust that poll, it made sense to respond to it. I was also making a point about a dip in 2024; the newer poll doesn’t update those data.

> support for Israel has been consistently dwindling

Literally what I’ve been arguing [1].

Support for Israel is monotonically decreasing. When protests are covered, support for Palestine dips.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43615994

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by runarberg on Tuesday April 08, 2025 @09:39PM (#43628122)
For the record (not looking to argue, just pointing out interesting fact) this was just released today and shows for the first time that majority of Americans across all ages and all party affiliations have an unfavorable view of Israel (53%; up from 42% in 2022).

https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/04/08/how-ameri...

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by amitport on Sunday April 13, 2025 @06:04AM (#43671604)
Don't forget it all came to the center stage after a mass butchering at a music festival, few beheadings and some Jewish babies kidnapped. Pretty effective! What is a little terrorism for a greater good! /S
Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by elmerfud on Monday April 07, 2025 @10:48PM (#43617930)
It may not have worked but it would have been the right way to do it. Then after it didn't work they could do more meaningful things that are higher visibility.

There's a right order in which to do things which lends credence to what you're doing. Right now they're just viewed as a bunch of idiotic disruptors because they didn't do things in the right order.

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by bbqfog on Monday April 07, 2025 @11:19PM (#43618069)
Is targeting families with ai “the right way to do it”? Office decorum doesn’t even register in importance.
Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by ndsipa_pomu on Tuesday April 08, 2025 @04:07AM (#43619418)
Whenever there's protests, there's always people complaining that the protesters are doing it the wrong way - that's the history of protests and inevitably, the people complaining about the protesters end up on the wrong side of history (e.g. The Suffragettes went completely against the "rules of protesting" with such things as letter bombs).
Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by therealpygon on Tuesday April 08, 2025 @08:21AM (#43620858)
> “They should have first gone and made their grievances known in a private way to the appropriate people.”

Why did you automatically assume they didn’t? Do you have special knowledge of the situation or did you just assume that was the case solely on the words of a company press release? Clearly the company would have no reason to use the same tired recycled excuses in press releases of “you should have talked to us privately” every company claims after a protest (which often get proved out as false in later employment lawsuits).

It seems odd that someone would write, “this is especially true when I've witnessed how Microsoft has tried to quell and suppress any dissent from my coworkers who tried to raise this issue” if the issue had never been raised or discussed prior.

Do they deserve to be fired? Sure. Does that mean protesting and disrupting a celebration was wrong after many people had tried to voice opposition of their use of AI this way, I don’t know that I can agree.

If you have ever worked at a Fortune 500 company, you would know that you might as well scream into a void if you think a company is going to reverse their decision to make more profit because of some whiney employees who don’t want to “just do your job”. Sometimes disruptive actions are the only way to bring attention to the things companies do, as can be seen by this being covered in the press , which means more attention has been brought to the issue, which was exactly the goal was it not?

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by runarberg on Tuesday April 08, 2025 @10:24AM (#43622160)
Seeing the footage I very much doubt Ibtihal Aboussad hadn’t addressed this before via a more proper channel. She addressed Mustafa Sulema by first name, she talks as if she knows he knows what she is talking about, as if she has addressed this to him personally multiple times before.

Reading about her history and role in No Azure for Apartheid it is very unrealistic to assume this is the first action they did.

Instead of just posting speculation, I went and checked, and https://noazureforapartheid.com was archived on the wayback machine in November last year https://web.archive.org/web/20241115041755/https://noazurefo... where they list 4 simple demands. It is unlikely they never sent those demands to Microsoft‘s senior management over those 4+ months.

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by DiogenesKynikos on Thursday April 10, 2025 @06:25PM (#43648597)
> Get the attention of leadership in a way that is respectful

"Excuse me sir, but I've just become aware that you signed a deal to provide tech support for an army that is conducting a genocidal campaign. Would you please consider rethinking this contract? Thanks."

That's respectful, but completely pointless. Microsoft knows who its doing business with.

Re:Microsoft fires engineers who protested during company's ... by amitport on Sunday April 13, 2025 @06:01AM (#43671577)
Even if they made steps, and were ignored, because management disagrees with them or for whatever reason, they still don't get a pass for disrupting normal business. It is a private company, you can say your opinion, but if you disrupt, you are gone. Very sane and simple.